Peggy Noonan warns a ‘Chernobyl’ is coming as Trump's Washington shrugs

(Gage Skidmore)
Peggy Noonan in Phoenix in 2016

Peggy Noonan in Phoenix in 2016
President Donald Trump rose to power through the right-wing political coalition that took over the Republican Party during the two terms of Trump's entertainer-turned-politician predecessor, President Ronald Reagan. Yet according to one of Reagan's speechwriters, the AI boom — which Trump is pushing — is putting America at grave risk.
"Here’s where I think we are in artificial intelligence: Bad stuff just happened, worse is coming, there’s still time to turn it around," Peggy Noonan wrote for The Wall Street Journal on Thursday.
She added, "America was jarred last week when various systems—Microsoft services, air-traffic control, some banks, the National Security Agency—experienced outages and systems failures. Were these incidents unrelated? Missouri Sen. Josh Hawley said on Tuesday: 'If this is all a coincidence it’s like the greatest coincidence in the history of the world.'"
Noonan noted that when AI companies describe possible "hiccups," that is more ominous than consumers might realize.
"In a way it sounded reassuring, but then you remember that one of the hiccups could be a Chernobyl, the shorthand word some in the industry use for the Big Terrible Thing—a catastrophe brought by AI," Noonan wrote. "Which most of its inventors expect. It could be a world-changing event carrying the deepest repercussions, including loss of life. It’s not much when a website goes down for a few days. But a true disaster . . ."
Noonan continued, "I’ve been thinking about something else. It means more than we’ve noticed that the regular people of America just took, on their own, the first and only significant action against the coming of AI. In the midterm elections they famously voted, in 40 of 41 local ballot measures, to restrict the building of data centers."
She concluded, "It’s odd no political figure has come forward to own this issue fully, and move it forward, and get the thanks."
While Noonan did not explicitly mention Trump, her article indirectly criticized him by pointing out how his administration has done little to reassure the American public as a series of rolling tech outages raise fears of AI-related problems. Additionally, Trump has been one of the biggest boosters of AI among American politicians.
"As President, I am 100 percent in favor of Super Intelligence (SI), and will work with the many states in the U.S. that want to become RICH by having them. They are GOLD, and only foolish leadership will say ‘NO’ to the riches they bring! President DJT,” Trump wrote on Truth Social earlier in November.
Noonan, who rose to power with Reagan, has frequently criticized Trump for not living up to the leadership standard that she believed Reagan had set. Speaking with AlterNet in August, a foreign policy adviser who worked with Reagan had a similar observation.
"He would give us sometimes two hours a day to discuss these issues — almost incredible," Jack Matlock told AlterNet. "I would say that, of everyone I've dealt with, he was, only half-jokingly, the best student I ever had. He had some ideas that weren't right, but if you corrected him, he would thank you instead of getting angry. Before his first meeting with Gorbachev at the Geneva summit, he wrote a four-and-a-half-page description of what he expected. This was handed to me — typed up by his secretary, with a few corrections in his own handwriting — and I was told: read this, and when we brief him in Geneva, if he's got something wrong, straighten him out. That was the attitude of that administration. I haven't found that attitude in any other administration I worked for."