Startled Trump nominee gets torn apart by unexpected Senate ally

Startled Trump nominee gets torn apart by unexpected Senate ally
U.S. Senator John Neely Kennedy (R-LA) reacts as he speaks with members of the media outside the Senate chamber, following a meeting between U.S. President Donald Trump (REUTERS)

U.S. Senator John Neely Kennedy (R-LA) reacts as he speaks with members of the media outside the Senate chamber, following a meeting between U.S. President Donald Trump (REUTERS)

Push Notification

Mediaite reports one of President Donald Trump’s judicial nominees got some unfamiliar pushback from a unexpected source — one of Trump’s most loyal GOP lawmakers on.

“Sen. John Kennedy (R-LA) warned Trump judicial nominee James P. Sullivan he was ‘talking in circles’ as the senator grilled him on his ‘originalist’ take on the Constitution,” reports Mediaite.

Republicans are in a rush to approve as many of Trump’s judicial appointments as possible before Democrats take control in January, despite almost a third of active judges already being Trump appointees. Sullivan was before the Senate Committee on the Judiciary on Wednesday to serve as a judge of the U.S. Court for the Western District of Texas.

But whether it was to make a good show or for other reasons, Kennedy appeared ready to press forward with his own brand of scrutiny.

Sullivan’s hearing was already off to a troubled start when he fumbled at remembering what the 22nd Amendment was about, reports Mediaite. But then Kennedy knocked Sullivan further sideways with an in-depth exploration of Sullivan’s constitutional interpretation and whether his interpretation meant he was okay with cutting someone’s ear off as a criminal punishment.

“So at the time the 8th Amendment was adopted, I think it was 1791, but don’t hold me to that, one of the punishments that was generally accepted was cutting off somebody’s ear. Would you support a statute by Congress to provide that we could cut people’s ears off?” Kennedy asked Sullivan, according to Mediaite.

“Well, Senator Kennedy, as a nominee to be a district judge, I would be bound by U.S. Supreme Court precedent and —”

At that point Kennedy interrupted with a follow-up inquiry: “Well, you just told me that you’re an originalist and it depends on what people thought in 1791. In 1791, it was okay to cut somebody’s ear off as punishment. It was okay to brand somebody. So, under an originalist interpretation, those are acceptable [punishments]. Those aren’t cruel and unusual punishments.”

Kennedy did not mention that the 8th Amendment protects Americans from cruel and unusual treatment in the court system, reports Mediaite. Instead, Kennedy continued barking.

“Are you an originalist or not?” Kennedy demanded of Sullivan as he continued to fumble with his answer.

Sullivan eventually confirmed that he was, but Kennedy was ready with his 8th Amendment snag: “Okay, under originalism and the 8th Amendment, why are you saying that the 8th Amendment, we don’t use originalism?”

But Sullivan further annoyed Kennedy by saying: “No, I think that we do, but we also use originalism to understand what the judicial power in Article III means.”

“You’re talking in circles, Judge,” Kennedy snapped. “I’m just asking you. If you’re an originalist and what people thought in 1791 controls, then why would it be unconstitutional, if you think it would be, for us to pass a statute that we can cut somebody’s ear off for robbery.”

“As a nominee to be a district judge, I think it would be unconstitutional because the US Supreme Court has said so,” Sullivan insisted. However, Kennedy was unwilling to give Sullivan even the slightest bit of slack.

“So you think the US Supreme Court doesn’t apply originalism?” Kennedy challenged.

“As a district judge it would not be my place to grade their homework, but I don’t —” Sullivan said, just as Kennedy erupted with more accusations.

“They either do or they don’t. You’re talking in circles,” Kennedy declared.

Assuring again that it was not his job to “grade” the Supreme Court’s homework, Sullivan hazarded that “sometimes” the Supreme Court neglects to take an originalist approach as he would were Sullivan the bench.

Kennedy apparently had no mercy for that, however. “It sounds like you just did,” Kennedy said.

Trump nominated Sullivan after Texas voters ousted Sullivan from the Texas Supreme Court in the midterm elections, Mediaite reports.

{{ post.roar_specific_data.api_data.analytics }}
@2026 - AlterNet Media Inc. All Rights Reserved. - "Poynter" fonts provided by fontsempire.com.