Editor's Note: This story has been updated to include comments from Democracy Defenders, Mr. Lewis and harpist Susan Robinson on which pianos will remain. A second addition includes details from the Kennedy Center. The headline has also been updated.
Photos show piano movers rolling massive Steinway grand pianos through the red-carpeted halls of the Kennedy Center this week, and British music journalist Norman Lebrecht posted them on the classical music news site Slipped Disc.
When President Donald Trump's handpicked board took over the Kennedy Center last year, the once-successful living monument to former President John F. Kennedy was profitable. After Trump decided to add his name to the Kennedy building, acts and shows pulled out of their performances, unwilling to let it turn into his theater.
Lewis Piano Movers was tasked with moving the Steinway grand pianos, as shown in photos. The pianos are valued at about $187,000 to $246,900 or more if they're brand new.
Van Lewis, who took the photos, posted them on Facebook saying, "Bittersweet day, I love moving Pianos, BUT taking all the Steinways out of the Kennedy Center is sad….."
The Kennedy Center has held used Steinway piano sales in the past, so AlterNet reached out to Steinway in Washington D.C. to ask if the sale was happening again this year. Jenny returned the call and said it would not host the sale, as the Kennedy Center had closed.
She said the shop owner intends to retire and close, so they're selling all their pianos at a heavy discount. With the Kennedy Center closed, the shop is also moving the Steinways to offer for sale. AlterNet asked why the Kennedy Center would need to sell everything, and she made it clear that it was because it was "closed." She referred all other questions to the Kennedy Center.
The Kennedy Center closing was supposed to be temporary. In fact, U.S. District Judge Christopher Cooper found that the Kennedy Center cannot close for the two-year renovation that the administration decided would begin immediately.
In May, the judge said the Trump-aligned board’s original closure decision was “ill-informed and seemingly preordained” and that the board had not properly considered its legal duty to both maintain and operate the Kennedy Center. He halted the planned two-year shutdown while the underlying lawsuit proceeds.
The order allows repairs to move forward and leaves the door open for a possible extended closure. Last week, the Center's director, Matt Floca, announced it would be closed for only a week. At the end of last week, they announced it would be closed for another week. Now it's clear that, behind the scenes, the Kennedy Center is telling vendors the building is shuttered.
It's unclear if the pianos and instruments are being liquidated from the site other than the Steinways.
Judge Cooper has now required the administration to give the plaintiffs and the court 30 days’ notice before any demolition, new construction or major change to the project moves forward. Judge Cooper also sought updates on a short-term closure that officials described as necessary for emergency safety assessments. However, the judge made it clear that a long-term closure was not possible for now.
Democrats proposed a bill this week to protect the building, but Republican Sen. Mike Lee (Utah) is blocking it. That means breaking his filibuster requires a 60-vote supermajority.
AlterNet reached out to the press team at Democracy Defenders, which has represented Rep. Joyce Beatty (D-Ohio) as she's attempted to sue to protect the building.
"If the Trump administration is in fact closing the Kennedy Center, doing so without permission from the judge is in direct violation of standing court orders. The president is not above the law, and this pattern of brazen defiance reflects a constitutional crisis of his making. The American public deserves answers," they said in a statement from Rep. Joyce Beatty's counsel, Norm Eisen of Democracy Defenders Action and Nathaniel Zelinsky of Washington Litigation Group.
The Justice Department claimed in a filing that the Kennedy Center isn't closing, but that they're simply doing some renovations because it isn't "safe."
The principal harpist of the Kennedy Center Opera House Orchestra since 1995, Susan Robinson, commented on Mr. Lewis' photos, "We noticed the pianos were disappearing! You were wise to do so. My instrument (harp) used to live over in the Opera House, but I’ve moved it to the Concert Hall since it’s one of the few spaces in the building still occupied by arts professionals! I was really afraid someone would take a wrecking ball to the building irregardless of its precious contents."
Robinson said on Friday that, as she understands, the "house pianos" will remain for now. All other Steinway pianos are being sold.
The used pianos will be available at a discounted price.
The Kennedy Center replied to AlterNet's questions about 30 hours later, clarifying that the larger Steinway shop in New York will absorb Mr. David Slan's Steinway shop in the DC/Maryland/Virginia area. That closure is the reason the Steinways were returned. The Kennedy Center said it intends to enter into a contract with the New York Steinway in the future.
Of the 31 pianos at the Kennedy Center, the theatre did not own 16. These were used in "rehearsal rooms and dressing rooms," the representative said. Mr. Slan intends to close by the end of the year, so those pianos are what were taken from the Kennedy Center and will be sold.
Across the Kennedy Center's 17-acre campus, the seven main theatres and THE REACH expansion there will still have 15 pianos.