From various, overlapping and contradictory news reports, Donald Trump is flailing in figuring out what’s next with this country’s war with Iran.
His dilemma is proving confusing to Iran, to our military, to Israeli allies, to diplomats and the American public. Secretary of State Mario Rubio has put the best face on this, saying we are now in a period of “strategic waiting” for economic squeeze to force a different attitude on Iran. Meanwhile, a fifth tanker was on fire in the Strait in as many days, this one apparently the result of hitting a mine.
For a variety of reasons – including overwhelmingly adverse midterm election results and anti-war fervor — Trump is neither moving to resolve disputes nor to launch new attacks. In a single week, Trump has started and pulled back from renewed negotiations, managing to undercut Vice President JD Vance and international diplomats along the way, and he is sending more troops for open-ended but unclear assignments into the region. Trump finds himself defending an embattled War/Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth from ouster while reportedly talking with potential replacements.
The difference is only that Trump now apparently thinks a standstill is a good place to stand.
A new Democratic congressional majority taking power in January in the House and Senate promises to act uniformly against extending funds for the war and to insist that Trump invoke the War Powers Act or walk away from this war. Trump seems to be doubling down on an open-ended naval blockade of Iranian oil exports in the Strait, but also not clearing the shipping routes in the Strait for the rest of the world.
Trump wants to declare that he personally has solved the threat of nuclear weapons development by Iran and control of the Strait and to assert that there is no need to do more. Trump is insisting that without requests to delay renewed bombing from Gulf allies, he would likely go ahead but reports from Washington and Israel confirmed that Trump and Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, who is facing potential ouster, had a yelling match over any renewed conflict with Iran, as Netanyahu is demanding.
Overall, Trump seems more fixated on the brewing war with Congress than on settling war in Iran.
Many Pieces, Little Progress
However disparate the elements, Trump seems to be flailing. The reasons for the war have never become clear, there is no end goal, the reliance on an air war is proving less than effective. The military is restive under Hegseth, whose leadership remains in doubt from an impeachment vote sidelined only because a number of opposition lawmakers got stuck in traffic.
Meanwhile, Iran is reportedly rearming itself and preparing for renewed bombing, promising retribution against Gulf neighbors that Trump acknowledges is restraining him from resuming attacks on Iran.
The move drawing headlines was Trump calling off Vance from any renewed negotiations with Iran — without real explanation other than domestic politics. Trump insisted that Vance – who blamed the midterm election results on a bad war in Iran – would be better spent investigating fraud in Democratic-run jurisdictions.
“We don’t need a deal with Iran,” Trump wrote on social media. “Those days have long since passed.”
Of course, there is no other plan to end the war, and Trump rejects any Iranian demands to leave the Strait and unfreeze Iranian assets abroad. Also, while a fraud investigation in Minnesota over phantom health grant spending has resulted in arrests that preceded Vance’s involvement, there is little evidence that fraud is more prevalent under Democrats than Republicans, including 70 allies and donors pardoned by Trump for similar frauds. Nevertheless, Trump’s defense against corruption charges is to counterpunch against Democrats – even as the war continues.
Trump continues to assert that the U.S. controls the Strait in blocking Iranian ships, but there is much dispute about how much international commercial shipping is moving through. Whatever Trump is asserting, there is no abatement in domestic oil and fuel prices.
Apart from all else, Trump’s deal to buy Russian diesel oil seems to be foundering with U.S. ports and refineries declining to take Russian diesel. Multiple news outlets report that U.S.
oil companies and terminal operators are shunning Russian diesel shipments, leaving tankers stalled despite the controversial, temporary sanctions waiver from the White House. They cite legal and reputational woes, and state officials in New Jersey, among others, that offloading Russian fuel would violate the law.
Meanwhile, Overseas
The U.S. military is moving another aircraft carrier group toward the Middle East to enforce the naval blockade and threaten bombing. Already, military families have been warned that the deployment will be for months, amid new reporting at MS NOW of supply shortages for the ships, sailors and Marines involved.
In Israel, there is little clarity about a new government following elections there, though there is evident concern about a redefined U.S.-Israel relationship. Trump announced he was cancelling $4 billion in annual military aid to Israel by the end of the year – seemingly just to avoid Congress telling him to do so.
Trump’s pussyfooting with Russia over Ukraine and his desires to talk about splitting the world map with spheres controlled by China and Russia also seems to be fading amid the Chinese spying scandal and blowback from allies over ties with Russia.
Meanwhile, The Wall Street Journal reports that Israeli intelligence believes Iran has moved
thousands of uranium-enrichment centrifuges into tunnels deep inside Pickaxe Mountain, a development that would heighten concerns that Tehran could reconstitute its nuclear program. In his recent “60 Minutes” interview, Trump suggested he was no longer worried about the country’s nuclear capabilities, his stated reason for starting the war.
The Times of Israel reports that Iran is producing 50 ballistic missiles a month, about half its prewar capacity, according to intelligence estimates. And Iran unveiled a new underground, Islamic Revolution Guards Corps (IRGC) Aerospace Force “missile city.” That bunker contains ballistic and cruise missiles, as well as their launch systems. Bloomberg cited intelligence reports that said Iran has at least 1,700 ballistic missiles left and is making more, and still has large stockpiles of precision-guided bombs and cruise missiles
Iranian missile launches at U.S. and allied targets in the Middle East used up at least 1,000 Patriot interceptors. About 650 of those missiles, costing $4 million each, are produced each year. Bloomberg estimated that Iran fired over 4,900 Shahed drones and at least 2,200 ballistic missiles since the war started on February 28 with joint US-Israel attacks.
IRGC spokesman Brigadier General Hossein Mohebbi recently said that missile and drone production facilities would all be moved underground, presumably to shield them.
Iranian security chief Mohsen Rezaei said in televised remarks this week that Iran will not allow even a single particle of enriched nuclear material to leave the country, adding that there are currently no negotiations taking place between Tehran and Washington.
Lest we lose the place of domestic politics in all this, Democrats also seem to be without a plan beyond voting for the War Powers Act and threatening funds for efforts to continue against Iran.
Terry H. Schwadron retired as a senior editor at The New York Times, Deputy Managing Editor at The Los Angeles Times and leadership jobs at The Providence (RI) Journal-Bulletin. He was part of a Pulitzer Gold Medal team in Los Angeles, and his team part of several Pulitzers in New York.