A constitutional lawyer is saying the incoming Democratic-controlled House should impeach President Donald Trump, and not just his minions, or else they’re making him a king.
In a Monday column in Liberal Currents, Robert Black said Democrats should impeach Trump for high crimes and misdemeanors because he’s committed them, and because their oaths to the Constitution require it.
“Trump has certainly committed the specific offense of bribery throughout his second term,” Black wrote. Trump also committed treason on Jan. 6, 2021, in Black’s view.
Since the Democrats’ landslide victory in the midterms, conventional wisdom has been to target Trump’s subordinates rather than Trump himself, Black wrote. Before the midterms, former Vice President Kamala Harris suggested Democrats shouldn’t impeach Trump and should focus their limited resources elsewhere.
On Nov. 9, Rep. Thomas Massie (R-Ky.) filed articles of impeachment against Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth over the war with Iran, the capture of Venezuelan leader Nicolás Maduro and the boat strikes in the Caribbean. Massie’s resolution was tabled on Nov. 10, but all the Democrats voted to proceed. Likely incoming Speaker Hakeem Jeffries (D-N.Y.), who has been lukewarm about impeaching Trump, says he’s a “hard yes” on impeaching Hegseth.
The idea is that Trump’s first two impeachments backfired by rallying his base, Black wrote. Democrats will have only 56 seats in the Senate in January, far short of the 67 required to convict, while Hegseth is believed to be unpopular with congressional Republicans.
Black doesn’t think the 2019 impeachment helped Trump, as it hardly shows up in his approval ratings. But he said strategy is beside the point: senators who try an impeachment swear to “do impartial justice according to the Constitution and laws,” and all members of Congress swear to defend the Constitution.
Republicans who voted to acquit Trump abdicated their responsibility in favor of their party, Black argued, and Democrats shouldn’t do the same. It made sense to be cautious in 2019, when Trump’s re-election put the republic at risk, he wrote. But with the biggest Democratic landslide in 40 years, and Trump term-limited, Democrats can stand on principle, according to Black.
Britain’s Parliament impeached the king’s ministers because it couldn’t impeach the king. But the U.S. Constitution makes the president impeachable. The House has impeached lower-ranking executive officers only twice: Secretary of War William Belknap, for taking bribes, in 1876 and Homeland Security Secretary Alejandro Mayorkas in 2024. Black said impeaching Mayorkas was a cowardly substitute for impeaching then-President Joe Biden.
Citing Harry Truman’s “the buck stops here,” Black said a president who stands by a subordinate who breaks the law can be impeached for it. By impeaching Hegseth instead of Trump, the House would be treating Trump like a king, and betraying the millions who marched under the “No Kings” banner, Black wrote.
Black still supports impeaching Hegseth: following Trump’s orders is no excuse. But it’s no substitute for impeaching Trump, he said.