Trump keeps trying to pick a fight with a dead president

Trump keeps trying to pick a fight with a dead president
REUTERS/Nathan Howard
U.S. President Donald Trump gestures during an event at The Villages Charter School at The Villages, Florida, U.S., May 1, 2026.
Bank

President Donald Trump repeatedly compares himself to the first Republican president, Abraham Lincoln — and seems to genuinely believe no one but him knows Lincoln was a Republican.

While it has long been well-known that Lincoln and Trump disagreed on a range of foreign policy and social justice and intellectual issues, Trump nevertheless likes to argue he and Lincoln were similar figures — and that, if anything, Trump himself was better.

"That actually seems to be the root of it: In Trump’s mind, Lincoln remains the one obvious exception to his claims of being the greatest president of all time," wrote Margaret Hartmann, senior editor for Intelligencer, on Sunday. She followed by pointing out how Trump in 2018 declared "I’ve always said I can be more presidential than any president in history, except for Honest Abe Lincoln when he’s wearing the hat.”

Hartmann proceeded to rattle off a couple dozen large and small occasions when Trump has offered a side-by-side comparison between himself and Lincoln.

For example, Trump's refusal to accept his defeat to Joe Biden in the 2020 election was the first violent rebellion to a presidential election loss since... well, the one that accompanied Lincoln's first election in 1860. Per Hartmann, "after losing the 2020 election, Trump talked to Carol Leonnig and Philip Rucker for their book I Alone Can Fix It. During the interview, he bragged that if it weren’t for the pandemic, even two of our greatest presidents couldn’t have defeated him."

Trump's observation: “I think it would be hard if George Washington came back from the dead and he chose Abraham Lincoln as his vice-president, I think it would have been very hard for them to beat me."

In 2018, Trump declared at a Montana rally, “You know when Abraham Lincoln made the Gettysburg Address speech, the great speech, did you know he was ridiculed? Fifty years after his death, they said it may have been the greatest speech ever made in America … I have a feeling that’s going to happen with us. In different ways, that’s going to happen with us.”

One year later, on the social media platform then known as Twitter, Hartmann points out he wrote "[Newt Gingrich] just stated that there has been no president since Abraham Lincoln who has been treated worse or more unfairly by the media than your favorite President, me!" Hartmann pointed out Trump had declared at the time. "At the same time there has been no president who has accomplished more in his first two years in office!"

"Up to this point, Trump’s comparisons to Lincoln were largely silly and subjective," Hartmann continued. "Then, in June 2020, he got into a one-sided fight with Abe over which of them had done more for Black Americans. Initially, Trump exempted Lincoln from comments suggesting his policies, such as the First Step Act, were more significant than enforcing Brown v. Board of Education or passing the Civil Rights Act."

More broadly, Lincoln advocated for an early version of what would in the 21st century be regarded as economic justice ideology throughout his mid-19th century presidency.

Speaking to this author for Salon in 2021, Columbia University historian Eric Foner, author of "Free Soil, Free Labor, Free Men: The Ideology of the Republican Party Before the Civil War," explained that Lincoln both directly advocated for and during his presidency pushed policies to implement "what we call the free labor ideology — that labor is the source of wealth (a common idea in the 19th century, a society of small scale capitalism), that slavery denies the dignity of labor, and that opportunity for the laborer to rise in the social scale is essential for a good society and for economic growth."

{{ post.roar_specific_data.api_data.analytics }}
@2026 - AlterNet Media Inc. All Rights Reserved. - "Poynter" fonts provided by fontsempire.com.