When I saw that critics and audiences alike panned "Madden" at Rotten Tomatoes (where I've been a film critic for more than a decade), I literally uttered the word "Woah!"
Even now, the fact that "Madden" is being widely shellacked utterly astonishes me. The film I watched captures the joy of watching and analyzing football — something I have done since my father and I began watching games together in the early 1990s — so beautifully, I recommend it to every football fan old enough to hear salty dialogue.
Directed by David O. Russell and starring Nicolas Cage as the titular head coach and Christian Bale as Oakland Raiders owner Al Davis, "Madden" tells Coach John Madden's story from his successful Super Bowl run in the 1976-1977 NFL season until the triumphant release of the football-themed video games bearing his name. Russell takes a few dramatic liberties to create a more compelling film (for example, he has Madden meet his future video game collaborator Trip Hawkins much earlier in the filmed story than in real life), but the major facts are accurate. Using those objective details of Madden's life as a skeleton, Russell fleshes them out with his trademark snappy dialogue and visually striking period recreations.
"Madden" brings to colorful life America as it existed from the late 1970s through the early 2000s. It educates audiences about the deep layers of strategy that go into crafting successful football plays, about how Madden's unique approach to coaching the sport was incorporated into the video game, how he similarly innovated the art of football commentary by putting audiences into coaches' and players' minds. There are also plenty of details that will bring back fond memories from those who watched football during the Madden era: His silly jokes and plugging of turducken, his commercials for Miller and Tinactin, his unquestioned ability to break down any play coherently to anyone willing to listen.
That last detail is perhaps the biggest reason I enjoyed "Madden," and suspect others will too once it is no longer fashionable to pan it.
“Being a geek is all about being honest about what you enjoy and not being afraid to demonstrate that affection," the actor Simon Pegg famously observed. "It means never having to play it cool about how much you like something. It’s basically a license to proudly emote on a somewhat childish level rather than behave like a supposed adult. Being a geek is extremely liberating.”
The animating spirit behind "Madden" is the real-life coach's unbridled enthusiasm for the game of football. As the real Hawkins recently told TIME Magazine, "From my perspective, from spending hours and hours alone in a room with him, the guy’s a classic nerd, and a classic introvert. But then he also knows how to lead. You realize pretty quickly, yeah, this guy can tell 60 very large humans on an NFL team what to do, and get them to do it.” Whether you use the word "geek" or "nerd" to refer to passionate genius, Madden clearly was one, and the movie "Madden" is tremendous fun because it captures the spirit of exuberant zeal for the sport in every frame. You see it in Madden's many monologues about the art and strategy of football, or in the welcome cameos from real life football stars and "Madden NFL" fans Julian Edelman and Marshawn Lynch (as video game developers).
Does Cage perfectly impersonate the real Madden, much as comedian Frank Caliendo did on a number of occasions? No, but I doubt Russell wanted him for that reason. Just like the initial actor considered for the role, Will Ferrell, Cage brings to all of his roles a child-like go-for-broke mentality that makes him captivating as a performer. This joie de vivre, this embrace of the fun that life can offer, is arguably the defining quality of Cage's work (see my favorite Cage movie, "National Treasure"). Because Cage and Madden were so similar in this crucial respect, the casting decision works — at least, if one accepts that we are watching less a recreation of Madden than a performance about what Madden represented.
By contrast, Bale truly does seem to resurrect the famously Promethean owner, from his idiosyncratic facial features and thick Brooklyn accent to the "Just win baby!" attitude and, like Madden himself, deep love for the game. I suspect critics and the audiences influenced by them are rebelling against Cage's acting precisely because his style is so different from Bale's. In Christian Bale, you have a thespian known for his chameleonic abilities, for switching effortlessly from Patrick Bateman and the superhero "Batman" to a paunchy, middle aged American vice president, Dick Cheney. When Bale's immersive style is juxtaposed with Cage's Elvis impersonator attitude toward bringing back Madden, the effect can be jarring.
Yet "Madden" does not have to be a perfect movie to be a great one. As I viewed it with my father in a shirt promoting my Salon interview with President Jimmy Carter (because the start of the film is set during the Carter era), I found myself transported back to a bygone era in American cultural history. The ride had some bumps along the way, but for those who enjoy trips back into late 20th century football and TV history, enough there proved satisfying that I walked away feeling happy.
If a movie can make you so happy, what better reason can there be to urge others to watch it too?