Trump’s collapse could finally save Thanksgiving with your MAGA relatives


President Donald Trump has crashed and burned, but that stupendous flame-out may give non-MAGA the opportunity to reconnect with MAGA friends and relatives this holiday season — if they take it slow.
Sarah Longwell is the publisher for the center-right anti-Trump publication, The Bulwark, and an accomplished focus group pollster, noted for her extensive surveys of Trump voters’ feelings and thinking. Her latest podcast on Saturday with Jessica Tarlov, co-host of Raging Moderates and Fox News’s The Five, reveals the MAGA cult may now be vulnerable enough to listen to some reason, so long as you don’t call them a cult.
“The through line to me of the way that I hear a lot of Trump voters and Republicans talk about Democrats is more like they're brainwashed,” said Longwell. “Like they feel bad for them that they can't see the bigger picture, that they're so emotional about everything, which I think kind of gets to the key part about where the misunderstanding in the Trump era comes from.”
According to Zoom interviews with participants, Longwell said MAGA doesn’t understand why Democrats treat Trump as an existential threat to themselves, their family and country. They also can’t seem to connect with the belief that supporting a “racist” and “awful” president makes them an extension of that same racism and awfulness, or as “a moral failing” that makes non-MAGA relatives want to avoid them.
“My experience in talking to the other side is they don't even want to hear me talk about my gardening, much less about politics,” said one MAGA participant. “… [Tt]here is no way I'd want to have a conversation politically with the liberal side.”
“I have two friends that, one is from kindergarten and … another one I've been friends with for over 40 years. We can't even discuss politics because they are so — they cannot stand Trump. And they're female, but then their husbands are the same way,” said another respondent. “It's just, it's terrible. … I remember when I was younger, you'd be able to have discussions with people of the different parties, and I remember my parents voting different ways in different presidential elections. But it just seems like there's so much anger on the liberal vote and so much hatred against Trump himself that it skews everything.”
However, it does not help that the Republican message machine has successfully conveyed to MAGA that voting Democrat counts as betrayal of Christianity, said Tarlov.
“My grandmother flipped. She's pushing (Democratic Texas Senator James] Tallarico to everybody and has abandoned her Christian faith,” said another MAGA respondent. “I don't understand it. It's very hard for me because it's drove a wedge in between our family. … ‘You still need to go and get all these vaccines. You need to do this. This is just the way that it is.’ And my grandmother went into that same mindset. It's like my mom kind of pulled and corrupted my grandmother. And I've tried to tell her and … I'll give her Bible verses. Like I put in the chat, like the mind and heart leans to the right, but a fool to the left. And my grandmother just thinks that it's an attack.”
“It stuck out to me listening to the woman talking about her grandmother who's gone for Tallarico, which is a betrayal of her Christian values,” lamented Tarlov. “And that she tries to read her Bible verses so that'll return her to Donald Trump and Ken Paxton. Like, that's a tough one, right? Because that's fully untethered to earth at this point.”
Still, both Tarlov and Longwell agreed that Trump’s continuing collapse may give families and friends a small opportunity to recover.
“There's going to be a new generation of people who were raised on MAGA, who are going to try to say real ‘America First’ has never been tried. And we're not totally at the end of the MAGA discourse, but we might be at the end of the Trump era. And I think that instead of talking, you might take the opportunity to listen to some of your family members who might feel differently now that they've watched Trump fail this catastrophically. And so rather than trying to jam it down their throats, which might be satisfying, maybe let them come to you, listen and just say how do you feel about things.”
“Be sharp but not cruel,” confirmed Tarlov, speaking of conversation around the holiday dinner table and in social media comments. “[Tamp down] this desire within us to dunk on each other all the time, which is definitely increased by social media use. … I'm not saying you should go scream about Antonin Scalia at Thanksgiving, but it's helpful to go from hectoring to conversation.”