Above the Law writer Katheryn Rubino say it turns out you can’t buy your way out of coughing up your secrets, at least not in the surreptitious deal big law firms reached with President Donald Trump nearly two years ago.
“The nine Biglaw firms that bent the knee to Donald Trump paid for one thing above all else: for it all to go away. Their deals came with roughly $940 million in pro bono payola for Trump-approved causes, and in exchange they thought they got peace, quiet, and nobody asking too many questions,” reports Rubino. “But reality is a harsh mistress like that.”
On Monday, U.S. District Judge Amir Ali granted a key records request in the American Bar Association’s suit over the administration’s “law firm intimidation policy.” Bloomberg Law reports the White House now has to produce the agreements it struck with Paul Weiss, Kirkland, Skadden, Latham & Watkins, Milbank, A&O Shearman, Simpson Thacher, Willkie Farr, and Cadwalader (now part of Hogan Lovells Cadwalader). It also has to hand over its communications with those nine firms, plus communications with the smaller group of firms Trump went after with executive orders.”
The firms struck deals with the administration to avoid Trump’s threat of crippling executive orders stripping progressive law firms and individual lawyers’ federal contracts and security clearances. And critics complained the deals effectively neutered and sidelined the companies, according to Eisen and a lawyer with direct knowledge of the matter.
Attorney Norm Eisen, a leader of the legal resistance against Trump’s Constitutional incursions, found that white shoe law firm Paul Weiss chairman Brad Karp now keeps his head down and refuses to offer advice to attorneys fighting Trump’s mid-term election schemes.
“He was one of the greatest champions of voting and civil rights — and for democracy — in the country, and to have someone like that advising you, resourcing you and fighting for you was indispensable,” Eisen told the New York Times.
But the actual details of the agreement that Trump used to snip firms are still under wraps, and the American Bar Association (ABA) demands sunlight.
“These are the same deals several of the capitulating firms spent last year insisting to congressional Democrats were barely deals at all. LOL, what pro bono deals? These ones, apparently! The ones the White House is about to have to produce,” said Rubino, adding that “The administration has fought this every step of the way.”
But Ali denied the government’s motion to dismiss back in April, “and once discovery opened the ABA came looking for the receipts, including anything involving [Trump advisors] Boris Epshteyn and Steve Bannon.”
Rubino said Trump’s politicized DOJ tried to close down the revelation by subpoenaing the law firms themselves for their Epshteyn communications, which Rubino said “conceded the material was relevant.” Then it tried to get Susman Godfrey, the ABA’s counsel, disqualified as a witness, but Ali “wasn’t buying it, since the government couldn’t name a single Susman lawyer who’d actually have to testify.”
And when Ali ordered the Trump administration to identify who drafted the Biglaw executive orders Trump that used to weaponize the White House against law firms, the administration invoked presidential privilege over the names. It warned that disclosure would “name and shame” the people involved. This, said Rubino, raised “the question of what exactly they’d be ashamed of.”
In any case, it didn’t work, said Rubino. “The judge wants to see how these deals got made,”
And the timing could not be “worse” for both Trump or the capitulating law firms, said Rubino. Just as Ali is preparing to dredge Trump’s sludgy deals into the light Democrats are grabbing control of Congress, so the deals are about to get a lot more attention than they would have under Republican.
“This is the same caucus that wrote to Kirkland four separate times asking what exactly the firm promised Trump and got a politely worded shrug every time. Shrugs don’t work as well against subpoena power,” said Rubino. “And it gets harder still if the White House has already produced a bunch of documents in federal court.”