Alan Dershowitz has candid words for Trump — and a blunt take on free speech

Alan Dershowitz
Attorney Alan Dershowitz is, for better or worse, one of the most famous lawyers in America. And he has some surprising words for President Donald Trump.
In the late 20th century, Dershowitz played key roles in the successful legal cases of accused criminals like Harry Reems, Claus von Bülow and OJ Simpson. Throughout that time he became one of the most distinguished law professors in the world, teaching at Harvard University and authoring seminal texts on subjects ranging from criminal defense to Jewish rights.
Yet he is also a controversial figure. For one thing, in 2020, he defended Trump during his first impeachment trial, which involved Trump threatening to withhold military aid from Ukraine unless they helped him smear Democratic presidential candidate Joe Biden. For another, Dershowitz was accused by one of Jeffrey Epstein's sex trafficking victims of having abused her, including when she was underage; after legal proceedings, Giuffre recanted her claim.
Now, in an AlterNet exclusive, Dershowitz opened up about his views on some of the biggest issues of the Trump era — free speech, anti-Jewish hate and whether the president himself is a criminal.
The following interview has been lightly edited for clarity, context and length.
The First Amendment vs. Anti-Semitism.
Rozsa: First, when I was 12, I was nearly murdered in an antisemitic hate crime. So I definitely know that antisemitism is both real and dangerous. At the same time, I am concerned that the Trump administration may have gone too far in the name of fighting it, such as in the case of Mahmoud Khalil, a green card holder who was detained by ICE for three months over his speech [criticizing Israel]. As a Jew who has both fought antisemitism and advocated for civil liberties, where do you draw the line between standing up against antisemitism and also respecting free speech rights?
Dershowitz: I have no respect for the free speech rights of non-American people. The First Amendment applies in America to Americans, and there’s been no restriction of anybody’s free speech rights. They can go on Zoom, they can have free speech outside the country. So I don’t see any contradiction between wanting to enforce immigration laws and make sure that people don’t come into the country. If they came in by fraud, even if they got elected to Congress, like Ilhan Omar, or became a Columbia student, they can still exercise their free speech. In fact, their free speech has gotten a new megaphone because of the controversy around them. So, you know, they can do podcasts, they can do video conferences, they can do anything they want. So their free speech hasn’t been restricted.
On the other hand, my free speech has been severely restricted by Harvard, which has essentially banned me from speaking at Harvard; the 92nd Street Y, which has banned me; Temple Emanu-El, which has banned me from speaking. So there have been great restrictions on my free speech right now. I still can speak to you, but many audience members who would like to hear me can’t hear me in these various venues. So I care deeply about free speech, but you have to look at it functionally. If you can speak through Zoom, if you can speak through other media, and you’re not entitled to be in America, that does not sound to me to be a violation of the First Amendment.
Rozsa: I, first of all, want to make it clear that I personally do not think that Khalil is antisemitic. I was speaking broadly about the concept of where that line should be drawn. I actually disagree with you about Khalil’s ideas, and I also think that being detained by ICE for three months over one’s opinions does count as a violation of the principle of free speech rights, even if it doesn’t technically violate the First Amendment itself. Do you at least see my point there?
Dershowitz: That didn’t happen. He wasn’t detained because of his speech. He was detained because of his status. If he were an American and said exactly what he said, nobody would try to prevent him from speaking. He was detained because of his status. He is a vicious antisemite. Let’s be clear about that. Anybody who solely focuses on Israel and Israel’s right to exist without caring about the Kurds, without caring about the Uyghurs, without focusing on any other group, but only focusing on the nation state of the Jewish people qualifies for me as an antisemite. So I disagree with you on both scores.
Did Dershowitz embolden Trump?
Rozsa: I understand that. Now I want to talk about another question in terms of President Trump and how he implements his policies. In February 2020, during President Trump’s first impeachment trial, you argued that a lawful act doesn’t become impeachable because of a reelection motive and added, quote, “If a president does anything unlawful, that’s completely different.” I later wrote a piece calling this the "Dershowitz precedent" because I argue that it essentially emboldened Trump to view himself as above the law. Do you believe in his second term that he has felt emboldened to do things that are illegal?
Dershowitz: Not by my defense. My defense was a constitutional defense. I think that President Lincoln, President Jefferson, President Roosevelt all did things that would come under the impeachment clauses that were directed against President Trump. So, you know, you can ask, were they emboldened? They did things that pressed the limits of executive authority. So my answer is no, I don’t think that President Trump has been emboldened by my defense or by others who argue that you can’t turn a lawful act into an impeachable offense just because it might have been motivated in part by political or electoral considerations. That would open the door to virtually every president being impeached.
Rozsa: That’s an interesting perspective. I had not thought of it that way, so I’m taking a moment to reflect on what you said. I hope you take that as a compliment. You have a long history of making comments that cause people to pause and reflect. I would argue that was part of how you assisted O.J. Simpson when you advised him. You gave his legal team food for thought that helped reorient themselves. This actually —
Dershowitz: That’s what I tried to do in all my legal representation. I try to push the envelope and, as a professor, I try to do the same thing. I try to stretch people’s minds and make them reconsider issues that maybe they thought were settled.
Rozsa: So this brings me to an interview I had with you in 2019 when I expressed concern that if President Trump was defeated in 2020, he would refuse to accept the result. You told me no president will refuse to step down if his opponent is elected in his place. It just will not happen and the American public would never tolerate it.
Dershowitz: Right.
Rozsa: Looking back, do you think that maybe you were incorrect, that Trump did refuse to step down and the public did tolerate it?
Dershowitz: Of course not. Neither of those is true. First, Trump did not refuse to step down. He stepped down. He accepted the election, although he challenged it. I wish that Al Gore had challenged the election in 2000. He didn’t. Challenging an election is a good thing. Some people wish that Richard Nixon had challenged the 1960 election. He challenged it, he criticized it, he continues to criticize it, but he stepped down. He left the White House. So no, I don’t think that what I said was wrong. He’s criticized many elections, and sometimes he’s been right, sometimes he’s been wrong. But he’s never refused to accept the results of the election by refusing to leave the White House.
Rozsa: It’s interesting that you say that. I would argue the January 6th coup attempt constituted his effort to not step down from power.
Dershowitz: That’s just simply false. He made a speech. I’ve read the speech. He asked people to protest in a lawful manner. He didn’t urge them to go and do anything illegal. What they did, they did on their own, and it was not a coup attempt. And he did not try to prevent, by physical force, a succession. So I don’t agree with that.
The value of civil debate.
Rozsa: All right. I find it interesting that we’re able to have this conversation civilly, even though we keep staunchly disagreeing with each other. Do you think that that is something unusual in your own experience in —
Dershowitz: In the last 10 years, you can’t have a debate. For example, the professor at Harvard, Michael Sandel, wrote a book against meritocracy. I think meritocracy is the key to democracy and the key to the American success. And so I challenged him to debate, and Harvard wouldn’t have such a debate. I used to debate William Buckley. I used to debate many, many conservatives. Debate is dead. There are no more debates. And that is largely a function of the Democratic Party. They have refused to have debate. They are in the process of trying to rid themselves of John Fetterman, who is a centrist Democrat, that he probably will not be a Democrat for the next election. And so, yeah, I think it’s good that we’re having a debate and a discussion, and I think there’s too little of it.
And speaking of my book, by the way, I have a book called Why I Quit the Dems: and So Should You! You can’t buy that in an independent bookstore. If you walk into your local independent bookstore, they won’t sell you that book. They don’t carry that book. Independent local bookstores have become enemies of free speech and enemies of the First Amendment. They carry only radical books, only liberal books, only progressive books. You can’t buy a conservative book or a Republican book in many, many of these so-called independent bookstores. So I urge your viewers and listeners not to patronize independent bookstores. They are the enemies of free speech. They used to be the protectors of free speech, but no more. If a bookstore won’t sell books on both sides of the political spectrum, you should not patronize them.
If you wanna buy my book, you should buy it on amazon.com or any of the other websites that sell all kinds of books, not ones that censor and engage in closing down the marketplace of ideas.
Rozsa: If I may push back a little, you said that you think it’s the Democrats’ fault that free speech is harmed in this country, but Project 2025, as implemented by Trump, has rigorously purged ideas that the Trump administration objects to. They describe these ideas as woke or as DEI.
Dershowitz: Give me an example of something that was actually censored by the Republicans.
Rozsa: How about the Smithsonian exhibits where they keep removing stuff that is critical of American history?
Dershowitz: The Smithsonian Institution has become very much a polemical, political institution. I completely agree that public institutions — whether it be Smithsonian, whether it be museums paid for by state or city funds, whether it be National Public Radio, which used to be, not anymore, but used to be publicly supported — they should not be ideological. And they should not be pushing a narrative that America was created by slavery and that America’s a terrible country. I think that the Smithsonian should present history objectively and —
Rozsa: But when the government is the one stating what is and is not objective, what is and is not polemical, then that violates the fundamental idea behind the First Amendment, which is that the state should not dictate how individuals perceive events around them and how they express those opinions.
Dershowitz: Some part of the state has to prevent other parts of the state. Remember, the Smithsonian Institute is the state. So what the Trump administration did was not telling the Smithsonian Institution what they should do, telling them what they can’t do, and I completely agree with them. I agree with them —
Rozsa: What about canceling millions in research grants to universities because —
Dershowitz: Oh, that’s wrong. That’s wrong. And I have opposed that from the very beginning.
Rozsa: What about them trying to kick Jimmy Kimmel off the air?
Dershowitz: Wait a minute. Let me finish my statement.
Rozsa: I apologize.
Dershowitz: I have strongly opposed any attempt to restrict pure science, but when scientists use their podium as scientists in order to indoctrinate students rather than teaching them how to think, I think that the government has a role to play in perhaps defunding propagandistic institutions the way they ultimately defunded National Public Radio, National Public Television, which was the right thing to do.
Trump vs. Science.
Rozsa: Sometimes what the government deems propagandistic is in fact not. For example, they refer to climate change as an ideology, when in fact, man-made climate change is an established fact that has been verified by literally tens of thousands of scientists across dozens of disciplines. So when a West Point professor is fired or funding is pulled because it tells the truth about humans overheating the planet, and then Trump says, “No, no, no. I’m simply stopping an ideology with which I disagree,” in fact, what he is doing is violating the free speech rights of those scientists.
Dershowitz: Who’s being interviewed here, you or me?
Rozsa: Well, I’m responding to your ideas.
Dershowitz: Okay. So take, for example, somebody like Thunberg, who uses environmentalism and climate control as a way of pushing her racist, antisemitic, anti-American, anti-Israel propaganda. So we know that climate control has been misused in order to promote ideologies and propaganda. I’m a supporter of climate control, I’m a supporter of environmentalism, but I think it’s a debate, an issue that can be debated. I think that you can argue. Look, the whole world can be wrong. You could say every scientist in the world in 1900s said that the Jews poisoned the wells and were responsible for this war and that war. And they were all wrong. Every one of them was wrong. I have a new book coming out. It’s called It Ain’t Necessarily So, where I challenge everything.
I challenge science, I challenge religion. So I think everything in a democracy subject to freedom of speech should be subject to challenge, including the things I agree with, like climate control. So challenging is fine. I think firing people because they have taught certain subjects is wrong. I would need to know the content of the teaching. I would fire a professor if the professor got up there and said, “Climate control? You can’t argue with that. You can’t disagree with that. And if you do disagree with that, you can’t be in my class.” I would fire a professor for doing that. Just as professors at Columbia have said Zionism is racism, and if you disagree with that, you can’t be in my class.
Rozsa: But if a science professor tells their students that you can jump off a roof and flap your wings and fly away, they should be fired because they’re teaching bad science.
Dershowitz: Of course.
Rozsa: I would argue that same principle applies to denying climate change.
Dershowitz: Well, that would be wrong. The climate change, to the degree that it is advocated, is somewhat controversial. The degree to which human beings have influenced the climate is an issue that should be debated and discussed in a classroom, outside the classroom. And I don’t think it’s the role of teachers to tell students to jump off the roof or to tell students to join demonstrations in favor of climate control. That’s just not the role of the teacher. The role of the teacher is to help students think for themselves and let them come to their own conclusions. And teachers who violate that rule don’t belong in universities. Teachers who use their podium to preach their own gospels, whether it be climate control or anything else, are violating, it seems to me, a role that’s almost a sacred role, because they have a bully pulpit, not to try to persuade students as to the correctness of their point of view, but to teach them critical thinking so they can come to their own conclusions.
I’m a strong opponent of capital punishment. If a student of mine came out of my class and said, “You know, you taught me how to think and I’m now redoubling my commitment to capital punishment. I wanna see more people executed,” I would say that was a great success on my part, even though the conclusion that the student reached is completely against my conclusion. But if I’ve taught him to think for himself, that’s my goal.
Rozsa: Okay, but if a science student says that greenhouse gases don’t trap heat and cause the planet to become excessively warm, they’re stating something as incorrect as if they said two plus two equals five.
Dershowitz: Let them try to prove it. I had a situation some years ago where my close friend, Stephen Jay Gould, who was the greatest paleontologist in the world —
Rozsa: Oh, I loved his writing. I’m sorry, but I’m a huge fan.
Dershowitz: So he was a close friend. We talked together. And he came to me with a problem. He said, “You know, I’m on the selection committee for who we give PhDs to. And we have an application from a Christian student from a Christian college. He’s a brilliant student with a brilliant application. But he believes in creationism. He believes that, you know, God created the world six days and then rested on the seventh. Should I admit him to the school?” And I said, “Absolutely, of course. Let him make his arguments. Let him try to persuade. And you’ll probably persuade him he’s wrong, but if you don’t, as long as you give him an opportunity, I think he’d be good.” I loved having students who fundamentally disagreed with everything that I believed in. And I would say this: in 50 years of active teaching at Harvard, I tried my best never to express a personal view in a classroom.
Never.


