On Monday, a prominent GOP insider revealed how a “vibe shift” has pushed Democrats to become the party of “actual Christianity,” dealing a major blow to President Donald Trump’s electoral coalition. According to longtime conservative political commentator Charlie Sykes, Trump’s behavior has become so blatantly amoral that Christians are abandoning the MAGA right in favor of the “basic decency” offered by religious leaders within the Democratic Party.
There are many storylines in this year’s political upheaval, writes Sykes, “but the comeback of Christian Christianity — and its embrace by some Democrats — is one of the most intriguing.” While Democratic candidates have traditionally been reluctant to talk about religion and have eschewed targeting Christian voters, who were presumed to favor so-called “family values” Republicans, the midterms brought a “significant vibe shift” as Democrats broke through to voters of faith in some of the country’s reddest regions.
While there were examples across the country, Sykes notes that two stood out: Methodist megachurch pastor Adam Hamilton in Kansas and Presbyterian seminarian James Talarico in Texas, both of whom won in deeply conservative states that hadn’t elected a Democratic senator in decades. According to Sykes, they accomplished this by using the Bible to call for decency in politics and oppose Trump brutal deportation project. But they weren’t alone, as they were among six clergy or pastors-in-training who won seats as Democrats, helping the party recapture Congress and dealing a major blow to Trump and his allies.
When Democrats like Talarico or Hamilton speak about their faith, naturally weaving scripture and biblical themes into their speeches and interviews, Sykes argues that it comes as a stark contrast to what Americans have become used to. “For a political culture that has marinated for a decade in Trumpian hatreds,” writes Sykes, “their invocation of the Sermon on the Mount and calls to ‘love thy neighbor,’ sound radically counter-cultural.” While the Christianity of Trump was a message of fear, grievance, and hatred, Democratic candidates like Talarico and Hamilton champion decency and kindness. As Talarico put it in his victory speech, “The politics of division is no match for the politics of love.”
“There are Christians all across America who may not agree with Talarico and Hamilton on every issue,” Sykes quotes from the Atlantic, “but who are deeply grateful these men won, because they offer an ethic and a disposition profoundly different from those of MAGA world. The senators-elect from Texas and Kansas believe that statecraft is soulcraft, that words should heal rather than wound, and that mercy is not weakness. They take seriously Isaiah’s invitation: ‘Come now, and let us reason together.’”
And as Sykes notes, he writes all of this as Trump and his allies are embroiled in yet another example of their amoral behavior, frantically covering for now-former Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang even though he’s committed espionage via extramarital affair. Trump himself shrugged off the allegations, and it’s been reported that the White House is falling in line to back Huang, with MAGA megadonor Elon Musk leading the charge to “wipe away Huang’s sins.” With this in mind, conclude Sykes, it’s not hard to see why "in the Age of Trump a return to basic decency — including actual Christian Christianity — is so profoundly counter-cultural.”