A former federal prosecutor says she’s worried about who gets to charge people with federal crimes, and she’s not talking about seasoned prosecutors, as one might think.
Former federal prosecutor Joyce Vance, who served for 25 years, including eight as U.S. attorney for the Northern District of Alabama, noted in a Friday Substack post, citing new ProPublica reporting, that the Justice Department has lowered its standards for hiring federal prosecutors.
“It’s hard to comprehend the magnitude of the crisis that is unfolding at DOJ,” Vance writes.
She says that once, these positions would attract hundreds of highly qualified candidates, but now, the jobs are being filled by candidates fresh out of law school, some of whom haven’t even passed the bar yet.
Vance says the problem is that the career prosecutors who should be training and guiding these new hires left or were purged during Trump’s second term. These veteran prosecutors knew that a prosecutor’s job was about the facts and the law, not the president’s personal vendettas, Vance writes.
Vance points out that federal prosecutors brought 63,954 cases in district courts during Trump’s first year back in office, an increase of 21.9% over fiscal 2024. The entire increase, Vance says, is due to the increased number of immigration cases, many of which are misdemeanors. The Justice Department, in Vance’s view, has given up pursuing fraud, drug trafficking, and other serious cases in favor of pursuing low-level immigration charges.
Vance argues that since prosecutors have such a great amount of power, they need time to develop good judgment through experience and working under the guidance of experienced prosecutors. Every new prosecutor, she says, learns the warning from former Attorney General and Supreme Court Justice Robert Jackson, who spoke in 1940:
“[The prosecutor’s] discretion is tremendous. He can have citizens investigated and, if he is that kind of person, he can have this done to the tune of public statements and veiled or unveiled intimations. ... While the prosecutor at his best is one of the most beneficent forces in our society, when he acts from malice or other base motives, he is one of the worst.”
Vance recalled that when she first joined the office six years out of law school, her mentor, federal Judge Clarence Allgood, told her it wasn’t about numbers, but about real people with families. And, she says, her criminal chief, Bud Henry, was always careful to make sure that defendants’ rights were protected in every case. He would have thrown anyone out of his office who suggested bringing a case to please the president, she says.
The DOJ has defended its hiring spree. It’s “proud to empower young and passionate prosecutors,” a spokesperson said to Bloomberg Law when the department suspended its one-year experience requirement in March.
But Vance says that when you lose institutional knowledge, it’s hard to get it back, and the price will be paid in terms of injustice and in people’s lives and freedom.