The latest court filing from President Donald Trump's administration tries to justify his 250-foot triumphal arch by claiming it's necessary for national security. But it's using new language to do that.
Roger Parloff of Lawfare explained on social media that it appears the Justice Department is attempting to "circumvent the Commemorative Works Act." Their argument says that while the arch "celebrates 250 years of independence," it is "forward-looking" in design, not "backwards-looking to commemorate something."
The Commemorative Works Act requires that an act of Congress authorize the building of on National Park Service and General Services Administration land in Washington and nearby areas. Since Congress isn't likely to approve it, the administration had to find a way of saying that the arch wouldn't fall under the act.
The administration’s main defense is a grandfather clause in the act, reading, “This chapter does not apply to commemorative works authorized by a law enacted before January 3, 1985.”
The filing closes by saying the arch is a kind of security barrier.
"Therefore, the government has the authority to build a Military Triumphal Arch, something which will help fortify Washington, D.C. and the surrounding area and will represent a beautification of D.C. that should not be forfeited. Scores of cities around the world have Triumphal Arches, and Washington, D.C. should have one. The Nation deserves an Arch that inspires its Successes and Triumphs," the conclusion says.
It prompted one of Parloff's followers to quip, "I am no military engineer, but I had always understood an arch to be a wall with the middle left out. As a fortification, it wants something."
However, the government doesn't appear to mean "fortify" in the conventional sense. Here they say that it would protect Washington from "drones."
“National security agencies have considered that the Arch can be incorporated into their ongoing efforts to defend the National Capital Region from evolving threats, like those posed by the proliferation of small, unmanned aircraft systems (UAS)," the filing claims.
While there have been drones in Washington, the most recent concern was at the Washington DCA airport, which would be too far from the arch to make a difference. Instead of claiming documented examples of threats, it highlights "growing" threats, potentially "uses by criminals or extremists."
Despite the claim that the security is essential, the filing argues, “Scores of cities around the world have Triumphal Arches, and Washington, D.C. should have one. The Nation deserves an Arch that inspires its Successes and Triumphs.”
An earlier report from CNN indicated that the final plans submitted for the Nov. 5 planning commission meeting contained no military component, despite the administration’s public descriptions of drones, ammunition and sniper positions. When the planning committee met, the new design also didn't show any military additions.
“The applicant updated the transportation plans and lighting plans as necessary. No other plan elements have changed," the meeting notes said.
The "final monumental arch rendering" doesn't indicate where any of the military fittings in any of the drawings either. There's no observation deck or "nest" for sharpshooters.
It does go into great detail about the "twin 20-style lighting" posts, which have a walk/don't walk sign and two light fixtures.
Trump has also said the arch will have a cafe, but that hasn't been shown in the designs either.
About an hour after the last hearing, US District Judge Tanya Chutkan issued a temporary block for 14 days.
The Commemorative Works Act could block the arch if a court determines it is a new monument requiring congressional authorization. The administration argues it is exempt because Congress authorized a related project at the site in 1925.