Experts dismantle 'crackpot legal practice' underpinning Trump threats

Experts dismantle 'crackpot legal practice' underpinning Trump threats
U.S. Attorney Aaron Reitz, Image via Screengrab / KVUE.

U.S. Attorney Aaron Reitz, Image via Screengrab / KVUE.

MSN UK

A former House general counsel and other veteran legal experts on Thursday tore apart a series of letters from President Donald Trump’s to prosecutor U.S. Attorney Aaron Reitz, calling the missives an “essentially crackpot legal practice.”

Reitz last week sent warning letters to four Democratic senators and a Democratic House member “suggesting that their vows to aggressively investigate President Donald Trump’s allies could lead to criminal probes and charges,” Politico reports. Legal experts described those letters as “legally meritless,” according to Politico.

Stan Brand, a former House general counsel under Speaker Tip O’Neill, called the letters “saber-rattling,” but argued “there’s no force behind the saber.” His advice, according to Politico, is to “disregard the letters and avoid ‘adding a patina of legitimacy to what is essentially crackpot legal practice.’”

“I wouldn’t dignify this with some counteroffensive in court,” Brand said. “If these guys try to enforce, it’s going to get flushed.”

Sen. Elissa Slotkin (D-MI) is among the Democrats who received the Reitz’s letter. In a video posted Wednesday, she challenged the U.S. attorney to “come get me.”

“If there’s a legal case to be made that you should prosecute someone for freedom of speech, do it,” she said.

Brand isn’t the only legal expert telling Democrats to bin the letters.

Georgetown University law professor Steve Vladeck called the letters “clumsy and over the top,” according to the report.

“It has seemed inevitable since long before Election Day that the Trump administration would take an incredibly combative approach against any efforts on Congress’s part to exercise even traditional forms of oversight over the executive branch,” Vladeck said. “The odds that, somewhere along the way, that approach provokes novel and serious Speech or Debate Clause issues seem as high as the odds that they’ll provoke novel questions about executive privilege, Congress’s legitimate investigative powers, and everything in between.”

“I’d largely ignore it and not give it air,” one white collar attorney who’s described as previously “represent[ing] Trump allies” told Politico. A second attorney told the publication the threats are “even more laughable than usual.”

“I … think that Congress can ignore the recent threats,” that second attorney said.

Former federal prosecutor Joyce Vance similarly argued Reitz “doesn’t … have the authority to back up his threatening letter.”

Writing Tuesday for her Substack, Vance noted Reitz lacks the jurisdiction to investigate the Democrats he sent letters to.

“Absent a designation by the Attorney General to take up a matter in another district, for instance, because the U.S. attorney there must recuse themself, they lack jurisdiction to prosecute crimes committed outside of their district,” Vance wrote.

For it’s part, Trump’s Department of Justice isn’t backing down, telling Politico the letters are “a valid exercise of DOJ” authority.

“Sending threatening letters to Americans for associating with the president — before those officials have oversight power — is a clear attempt to chill associational rights and speech,” one anonymous DOJ official told Poltiico. “And, yes, it is a valid exercise of DOJ’s prosecutorial power to prevent ‘anyone acting under the color of law to willfully deprive a person of their constitutional or federal rights.’”

{{ post.roar_specific_data.api_data.analytics }}
@2026 - AlterNet Media Inc. All Rights Reserved. - "Poynter" fonts provided by fontsempire.com.