Former Trump lawyer attacks renewed Epstein probe as 'McCarthyism'

Former Trump lawyer attacks renewed Epstein probe as 'McCarthyism'
US first lady Melania Trump walks next to President Donald Trump after speaking on the day he signs an executive order on women's health, spearheaded by first lady Melania Trump, in the Rose Garden at the White House in Washington, DC, US, October 19, 2026.
REUTERS/Umit Bektas

Now that President Donald Trump's Republicans lost the 2026 midterm elections, it is all but certain that long-redacted files related to the late sex offender Jeffrey Epstein will receive renewed attention.

Epstein's victims call this justice. Attorney Alan Dershowitz calls it 'McCarthyism.'

To be clear, Dershowitz is not impartial here. In addition to defending Epstein during his earliest criminal cases, Dershowitz was accused of sexual misconduct himself by Virginia Giuffre, one of Epstein's victims; Giuffre later walked back her accusation.

Dershowitz can therefore be accurately described as both a former lawyer for and a former accused next to Epstein. Between that history and the fact that Dershowitz supports Trump (who he represented during his first impeachment trial — and who has also been accused of crimes by Epstein's victims, which he likewise denies), one would expect the former Harvard professor to have a dim view of the anti-Epstein furor.

Speaking with Dershowitz for AlterNet, I covered not only his past with Epstein, but also his views on Trump's seemingly illegal attempts to silence his critics (this was a continuation of a previous part from our interview). Yet the Epstein segment has stuck with me because those questions came at the end of our conversation, and I did not have time to follow up on several of Dershowitz’s claims. For example, he said that “many, many, many” of the women claiming to be Epstein’s victims never met the offender himself, that some of them actually victimized others and that “many of them are lying.” He offered no names and no evidence for these assertions, even after I followed up with questions subsequent to the interview below. (He instead referred me a New York Times story that "describes pimps and willing adult massagers.")

At one point Dershowitz even told me that, as far as he knows, none of the accusers have been subjected to “truth-telling determinations," despite a federal jury in 2021 hearing testimony from four women and convicting Epstein associate Ghislaine Maxwell of terrible crimes based on those victims' credibility. In short, Dershowitz reminds me of a line by Sen. Daniel Patrick Moynihan (D-NY), who famously said, “Everyone is entitled to his own opinion, but not his own facts.” Dershowitz is entitled to his opinions, even ones with which I strongly disagree, such as his view that any adult woman who accuses a man of sexual misconduct should be publicly named. But claims that cast doubt on the credibility of Epstein’s victims should not go unchecked... even if telling the full truth about Epstein is politically inconvenient for Trump and Dershowitz.

The following interview has been lightly edited for clarity, context and length.

Dershowitz talks Trump.

Rozsa: Trump has tried to get Jimmy Kimmel pulled from the air for making jokes that he found to be tasteless. How do you feel about that? Do you consider that a [free speech] violation?

Dershowitz: No, he has the right to try to influence what’s on the air. And, you know, media have the right to decide what’s on the air. If he uses the pressure of the government to take people off the air, that’s one thing. But, you know, you seem like an honorable guy, but if it wasn’t Jimmy Kimmel, if it was some Southern segregationist Klansman who was very funny, and liberals try to take him off the air, I don’t know which side you’d be on. I know which side I’d be on, but I don’t know which side you’d be on. So how much of this is because you disagree with everything Trump is doing, and how much of this is pure, neutral, non-content-related free speech, I leave to you.

Rozsa: Well, I can respond with a very concrete example. I thought Dave Chappelle made a very antisemitic monologue on Saturday Night Live a couple years ago. He had some comment about how when you see a group of Italians together, it’s a mob, and when you see a group of Black people together, it’s a gang. But when you see a group of Jews, you’re supposed to call it a coincidence. I thought that joke was extremely offensive. I didn’t think it was funny, and I thought it was hateful. But if someone said that he should have been pulled from the air or that NBC should have been fined because he made that joke, I would absolutely disagree. Even though I’m Jewish and I found the content of his speech offensive, to paraphrase Evelyn Beatrice Hall, I would defend to the death his right to say it.

Dershowitz: It was Voltaire, I think, who said it, but —

Rozsa: No, it was Hall paraphrasing Voltaire.

Dershowitz: Paraphrasing Voltaire, but Voltaire was Voltaire’s point. You know, I would not defend to the death the right of, you know, Hitler to give his speeches at Nuremberg. I’m a relative absolutist on the First Amendment, but I understand too that speech can lead to violence and be dangerous. I would never ban comedians of any kind. I didn’t find what you just said, Chappelle, funny. But I wouldn’t ban it. But you haven’t persuaded me that you’re absolutely neutral when it comes to issues of this kind. And the reason you haven’t is your views on the various museums, which have been political and polemical, and nobody objected to those until people tried to complain about it. So I think if you’re gonna be content-neutral defender of free speech, you gotta apply the same standards.

You have to pass what I call the shoe on the other foot test, and too many people on the left don’t do that.

Rozsa: I would say that part of the reason why, at least when it comes to the Smithsonian and the scrubbing of woke from our institutions, the reason I feel the way I do is I don’t believe that these are matters of opinion. Slavery was integral to the creation of the United States. Saying that, I don’t believe, is a matter of conjecture or —

Dershowitz: So you would ban, probably put in jail, a historian who said, “Look, slavery was also…” I obviously don’t believe this, but if a historian said slavery was essential to both the positives and the negatives in the United States, it helped build —

Rozsa: I would never put someone in jail for saying that, or any opinion that I find offensive.

Dershowitz: Well, but you just said that you think it’s a fact and nobody should be able to contradict the fact that —

Rozsa: No, I said the government shouldn’t be able to censor people who express that fact.

Dershowitz: Of course not. The government shouldn’t —

Rozsa: But that’s what Trump is doing with the Smithsonian and these other museums.

Dershowitz: I don’t think so. I don’t think so. What he’s saying is you can’t get government funding if you’re presenting a point of view, political point of view. And even if the political point of view is right or is popular, that’s not what museums are supposed to do. I had a big fight with a museum a few years ago in New York when they did an exhibit of Gertrude Stein, and they failed to describe the fact that Gertrude Stein was a Nazi, and that her best friend was the head of the Gestapo, that she had turned Jews over to the Gestapo, that she had written an article nominating Hitler for the Nobel Peace Prize, and an introduction to Pétain’s book on Nazism. I just thought the museum shouldn’t do that. And I protested, and I got the museum to sell a book in their bookstore which presented the truth about Gertrude Stein so that people going through the exhibit could see both sides of everything.

I wouldn’t ban the exhibit, but I would use all of my power to make sure that people boycotted the exhibit unless they presented a fuller picture of the Nazi Gertrude Stein.

[Editor's Note: Contrary to Dershowitz’s claims, Stein’s friend Bernard Faÿ was a Vichy official, not the head of the Gestapo.]

Rozsa: I actually agree with how you handled that situation, and you know that if I disagreed, I would tell you, but I completely agree with how you approach that. My point, however, and this is where I disagree with you, is I think Trump is censoring views about history that deviate from the Republican Party line.

Dershowitz: Let me ask you this question. Do you think that there’s anything that the left progressive woke has actually been stifled or censored in the United States today? Do you think that the left woke —

Rozsa: You already acknowledged that research grants have been pulled.

Dershowitz: That what?

Rozsa: Research grants have been pulled for people using words like diversity in their grant applications. People are —

Dershowitz: No. Well, I don’t believe — I would not, if I were a grantor —

Rozsa: Stephen Colbert was reportedly —

Dershowitz: I would not give government funds to any institution that said it would use it for purposes of racial diversity. I would not give government funding for that. I think that racial diversity —

Rozsa: Yes, but some of these papers just use the word diversity.

Dershowitz: Well, then you have to look to see what it means. I would say that using diversity in a grant application is a red flag, and I would look into it and see whether or not they are using racial criteria for making scientific decisions. And if they are, I would not give government funding for that.

Rozsa: My point is that, to answer your question, I think people who advocate racial diversity are being censored by the government.

Dershowitz: Well, they aren’t being censored. They’re not being funded. I wouldn’t fund them. And I think that, you know, racial diversity is destroying the country. It’s creating divisions, and it’s not real. Harvard doesn’t want racial diversity. What they want are more Blacks. And it’s numerical. And that’s always been the case. When Harvard started its campaign for diversity, the president of Harvard told me that what he wanted were wealthy, well-educated African-American kids, children of hedge fund people, children of, you know, professors, judges, because they’re easier to integrate than people from the streets. That’s not diversity. That’s racism. And I oppose that since 1970 and will continue to oppose it. And I do think that the government has a role to play in making sure that the Supreme Court’s decision prohibiting the use of race in university admissions is adhered to.

Dershowitz talks Epstein.

Rozsa: Right. And now I’m going to go to my last question. You’ve been very generous with your time. Thank you so much for speaking with me. My last question involves a somewhat sensitive subject, but I am curious for your thoughts on this. As I’m sure you know, the Jeffrey Epstein situation is constantly talked about in the news. There are people who I know who are on the files, like Bard College President Leon Botstein, who mentored me [when I was an undergraduate there] —

Dershowitz: What do you mean on the files? That sounds like Joseph McCarthy when you say on the files. Has anybody accused Botstein of having illegal sex with a minor or of doing anything unlawful on the files? I mean, that’s McCarthyism, pure and simple.

Rozsa: So you think that the criticisms of you for being associated with Jeffrey Epstein are also McCarthyistic?

Dershowitz: Of course. I was his lawyer. I was his lawyer. When I first met him through Lynn Rothschild, she asked me to meet with him because he was a major contributor to Harvard. I then called Provost Rosovsky, the provost of Harvard University, and I said, “This man, Jeffrey Epstein, who I don’t know, wants to meet with me. Should I meet with him?” And he said, “Well, absolutely. He’s a friend of Harvard, a friend of science.” So I’m not ashamed of anything I ever did. That’s why I offered to testify in front of Congress about it. I think the vast majority of things we’ve heard about Epstein are false. And there’s a false narrative out there. Many, many, many of the women who are claiming to be victims and survivors never met Jeffrey Epstein.

And many of those who did meet Jeffrey Epstein volunteered to come back over and over and over again. And some of those pimped for him and provided, for money, young women. So I’m very anxious to have the whole story of Jeffrey Epstein come out from beginning to end.

Rozsa: I have to say this: Underage people can’t consent.

Dershowitz: I’m not talking about that. I’m talking about 30-year-old women and 22- and 23-year-old women who came back over and over and over again. So they ought to be also subjected to cross-examination. As far as I know, none of these people have been subject to truth-telling determinations. And I know many of them are lying, because I know, of course, the one who accused me and then ultimately admitted that she may have confused me with somebody else. I know I never met her and never heard of her. And I know many others, the same is true. So I think that the allegations involving Jeffrey Epstein should be subjected to the same truth testing mechanisms. By the way, any adult woman who accuses a man of anything sexual, her name should be released.

It’s a terrible, terrible McCarthyite tactic to say that you could accuse somebody, have your name withheld — the name of the person who’s been accused, their name is all over the papers, but your name is withheld — which denies the defendant the right to explore and examine evidence and show that you have a history of not telling the truth. So I’m gonna continue to fight this McCarthyite battle involving Jeffrey Epstein, and I’m not gonna in any way apologize for anything I did. I was his lawyer, and I did a pretty good job in getting him the best possible deal I could, and we’ll continue to do that for anybody else who’s accused of any crime.

This article was paid for by AlterNet subscribers. Not a subscriber? Try us and go ad-free for $1. Prefer to give a one-time tip? Click here.

{{ post.roar_specific_data.api_data.analytics }}
@2026 - AlterNet Media Inc. All Rights Reserved. - "Poynter" fonts provided by fontsempire.com.