‘A huge setback for the GOP': Republicans suffer a blow in their fight for control of the House
Between President Joe Biden’s weak approval ratings, gerrymandering and voter suppression, many pundits have been predicting that Republicans will retake the U.S. House of Representatives in November. But that remains to be seen, and Republican gerrymandering was dealt a blow in the Midwest this week when the Ohio Supreme Court — including Chief Justice Maureen O’Connor — struck down the congressional map that Ohio Republicans had in mind for the Buckeye State.
On top of that, Rep. John Katko of New York State has announced that he won’t be seeking reelection — which is more bad news for the GOP. Katko is one of the Republicans who is moderate enough to fare well among centrist Democrats and swing voters in his state. Neither of these problems is necessarily decisive for control of the House, but if 2022 ends up being close, a few seats on the margin could make all the difference.
BREAKING: Redistricting: Ohio Supreme Court strikes down congressional map, forcing another round of drawing https://www.dispatch.com/story/news/politics/elections/2022/01/14/redistricting-ohio-supreme-court-decision-congressional-map-gerrymandering/9119566002/\u00a0\u2026 via @DispatchAlerts— Jessie Balmert (@Jessie Balmert) 1642179389
>@RepJohnKatko announces he will not seek re-election. Another one of the 10 House Rs who voted for impeachment who is calling it quits.\n\nSays it's "so that I can enjoy my family and life in a fuller and more present way"— Catie Edmondson (@Catie Edmondson) 1642178377
Ohio supreme court strikes down GOP-drawn congressional districts, saying they unfairly benefit Republicans. "Gerrymandering is the antithetical perversion of representative\ndemocracy. It is an abuse of power" https://www.supremecourt.ohio.gov/rod/docs/pdf/0/2022/2022-Ohio-89.pdf\u00a0\u2026pic.twitter.com/nSgAylQyyr— Sam Levine (@Sam Levine) 1642181926
The Ohio Supreme Court ruled, 4-3, that the map violated the state’s constitution by drawing the districts to unfairly favor one party over another. Columbus Dispatch reporters Jessie Balmert and Laura A. Bischoff note that the map “could have given Republicans as much as a 12-3 advantage in a state that voted for President Barack Obama and President Donald Trump twice.”
Ohio Supreme Court Justice Michael Donnelly, who was part of the majority opinion, argued, “When the dealer stacks the deck in advance, the house usually wins.”
READ: Here's what it would really mean to prosecute Trump
Now, lawmakers in the Ohio State Legislature, according to Balmert and Bischoff, will have 30 days to “craft a new map.”
The Cook Political Report’s Dave Wasserman, in response to the ruling, tweeted:
Not unexpected, but huge setback for GOP. Dems have potential to net 2-3 more seats out of a revised map.https://twitter.com/jbalmert/status/1482033890705514496\u00a0\u2026— Dave Wasserman (@Dave Wasserman) 1642180217
Meanwhile, in New York State, Katko’s decision not to seek another term takes away a GOP candidate who isn’t a polarizing figure among centrist Democrats and swing voters. Katko, who voted to impeach former President Donald Trump following the January 6, 2021 insurrection, is conservative but not extreme.
Not surprisingly, Trump sees Katko’s decision as good news, as he considers the congressman a RINO: Republican in Name Only.
Meanwhile, Donald Trump releases a statement celebrating John Katko\u2019s plan to retire, saying: \u201cGreat news, another one bites the dust.\u201dhttps://twitter.com/kkondik/status/1482033492603068419\u00a0\u2026— Sahil Kapur (@Sahil Kapur) 1642182480
READ: 'To defy Trump's wishes is to defy God's plan': The scary truth about modern right-wing misinformation
But outside of the MAGA bubble, political analysts are saying that Democrats just got some good news in New York State. Two of them are Cook's Wasserman and Kyle Kondik of Sabato's Crystal Ball:
Huge news in #NY24 and beyond, as the third of 10 Republicans who voted for impeachment retires. Katko is probably the only Republican who could hold the seat, especially if Dems redraw the district to be much bluer.https://twitter.com/CatieEdmondson/status/1482029647068082176\u00a0\u2026— Dave Wasserman (@Dave Wasserman) 1642179464
Katko's 2020 margin was 19.2 pts better than Trump's in his district, the best overperformance of the 9 total Biden-district Republicans (Brian Fitzpatrick a close second)pic.twitter.com/EtkNpg5DfJ— Kyle Kondik (@Kyle Kondik) 1642179294
Here are some more reactions to Katko’s announcement:
Rare good news for Dems: Katko is a Republican who's been winning in pretty strongly blue turf in upstate New York.\n\nAnother angle to look at it from: Katko was one of the small group of Republicans to back impeachment, so another one in that group is heading for the exits.https://twitter.com/RobertHarding/status/1482029091196915714\u00a0\u2026— Taniel (@Taniel) 1642178962
This. House Rs lost one of their top political talents.\n\nComes a week after this Politico story:\nhttps://www.politico.com/news/magazine/2022/01/06/john-katko-trump-impeachment-profile-526509\u00a0\u2026https://twitter.com/kkondik/status/1482033492603068419\u00a0\u2026— Josh Kraushaar (@Josh Kraushaar) 1642179416
I\u2019m shocked. He\u2019s well liked in the district and most considered his seat safe even post-redistricting. \n\nI can only figure he\u2019s expecting Rs to retake the house this November and shun him from committees for being a prominent across the aisle voter on things like impeachment.— Omicromulent (@Omicromulent) 1642188304
- These 3 US presidents show why 2024 could be good year for Joe ... ›
- Expect Ron Johnson to 'dial up the rhetoric' and double down on the ... ›
- Unseating Ron Johnson in 2022's midterms would be a 'very ... ›