'Pay up or shut up': Dems tell Trump 'we need our money back'

Now that the US Supreme Court has ruled President Donald Trump levied illegal tariffs on US businesses and consumers for more than a year, progressive Democrats are escalating demands that Americans get their money back.

Days after the Supreme Court shut down Trump’s ability to unilaterally enact tariffs through the International Emergency Economic Powers Act (IEEPA), Congressional Progressive Caucus Chair Greg Casar (D-Texas) said on Tuesday that during the State of the Union address, Trump should announce refunds for Americans he unlawfully taxed.

“Americans don’t need a rambling, two hour lecture from Trump,” Casar wrote in a social media post. “We need our money back. He owes us: $1,700 in illegal tariffs per family; $4 billion he’s profited off the presidency; $1 trillion he stole in tax breaks for the ultra-rich. Spare us the speech. Pay up or shut up.”

Casar’s demands for tariff refunds aren’t isolated.

Politico reported on Monday that Democrats have pounced on the Supreme Court ruling to deliver a simple message to voters: Trump wrongfully took your money and should return it.

Rep. Steven Horsford (D-Nev.), who along with Rep. Janelle Bynum (D-Ore.) introduced legislation mandating tariff refunds on Friday, accused Trump of outright thievery.

“When someone takes money that wasn’t authorized and does it in a way that harms you,” Horsford told Politico, “they’ve stolen from you, and that is what the Trump administration has done for the last year.”

Horsford’s rhetoric echoed a statement made by Sen. Elizabeth Warren (D-Mass.), who said in the wake of the Supreme Court ruling last week that Trump “illegally stole your money” and “should give it back to you” instead of trying to cook up new ways to slap tariffs on imported goods.

Groundwork Collaborative on Tuesday previewed Trump’s State of the Union speech by noting the president has totally failed to keep his promise to bring down prices, adding that his tariffs “cost the average working family nearly $1,200 last year.”

“No matter what Trump says in the upcoming State of the Union address,” Groundwork Collaborative said, “it won’t change the fact that working families know that the president and his lackeys in Congress alone bear responsibility for painfully high prices and a dragging economy.”

Although the Supreme Court clipped Trump’s power to levy tariffs via the IEEPA, he has since announced plans to issue a 15% global tariff using his authority under Section 122 of the Trade Act of 1974, which allows the president to levy tariffs to address “large and serious” balance-of-payments deficits with foreign nations.

However, as a recent analysis by the libertarian Cato Institute explained, any tariffs enacted through Section 122 expire after 150 days without authorization from Congress, which in theory could put vulnerable congressional Republicans on the spot to vote for or against the president’s signature economic policy this summer right before the 2026 midterm elections.