‘We screwed up’: Republicans have one question they won’t dare answer

‘We screwed up’: Republicans have one question they won’t dare answer
REUTERS/Jessica Koscielniak
U.S. Senator Ted Cruz (R-TX) and U.S. Rep. Jim Jordan (R-OH) speak at the Republican National Midterm Convention in Dallas, Texas, U.S., September 10, 2026.
Trump

Ever since the Republicans suffered generational losses in the 2026 midterm elections, the party has tried to figure out what it did wrong so that it can improve its performance in the future. Yet according to a recent report, there is one possible mistake they simply refuse to consider — namely, whether they were too close to President Donald Trump.

"Mr. Trump’s allies in Republican leadership, including Speaker Mike Johnson, have also avoided criticizing him or even offering much explanation of what went wrong," reported The New York Times' Bayliss Wagner on Sunday. "House Republicans just elected a close Trump ally, Representative Jim Jordan of Ohio, to be their next leader. And while Mr. Trump has acknowledged that he may have overstepped on immigration, on Friday he blamed lawmakers for failing to 'get the things that I wanted passed.'"

Wagner added, "The party’s limited reckoning over the midterms foreshadows the coming battle over its direction now that Mr. Trump is a lame-duck president — and suggests that influential Republican figures may be reluctant to change course."

Further down in the same article, Wagner elaborated on how the party is trying to separate their messaging from Trump's unpopularity in ways that may not be politically feasible.

"But the messaging problem was hard to untangle from the party’s actions," Wagner reported. "Many Republicans became increasingly vocal opponents of Mr. Trump’s tariffs and the Iran war, which were a major driver of cost increases, particularly for gas and diesel. And some aspects of Mr. Trump’s signature domestic policy law also proved unpopular, notably its cuts to Medicaid benefits."

That was not all.

"Senator Josh Hawley, a Missouri Republican who is a potential 2028 presidential contender, said the election showed that his party must focus more on affordability issues and working-class voters," Wagner added, quoting Hawley as telling the Associated Press that "we’re a blue-collar state, and I think the Republican Party will either be a blue-collar party or we will be a permanent minority party.”

Overall, Wagner said that the party is hoping to continue following Trump's policy path while Democrats sabotage themselves.

"Few in the party have called for a new policy agenda, viewing the headwinds they faced in this year’s midterms as temporary or strictly related to messaging," Wagner wrote. "Many are counting on Democrats to give them fodder for the campaign trail in two years by overreaching in oversight efforts or failing to deliver on their promises to lower costs."

By contrast, at least one Republican did acknowledge Trump's role in all of this. David Kochel, an Iowa Republican strategist, told the Times the midterms represented “a rejection of the president,” and that “it felt to me like a bit of a recall election — like, ‘We screwed up in 2024 and we’re going to try to fix it as best we can.’”

This is not the first article to report a seismic shift in the political landscape due to the midterms. On Saturday The Times' David French reported that “[Trump] got way over his skis, and so, here come the midterms, and the midterms were a genuine landslide. I mean, they were a genuine landslide. And so, all of a sudden, you’ve gone from a situation in which you’re saying, ‘Do we have permission to do investigations?’ to ‘Do we have a mandate that we must do investigations?’”

Meanwhile The Times' Peter Baker reported shortly after the election that Trump himself had entered a state of seeming denial about the results.

"In the days since his defeat, he has sounded like a man in denial," Baker wrote. "With his party still picking through the wreckage of a political earthquake, a seemingly oblivious President Trump signed a steel beam for his new White House ballroom and flew to Florida to give a speech on the space program. He seems flat these days, maybe a little dazed."

{{ post.roar_specific_data.api_data.analytics }}
@2026 - AlterNet Media Inc. All Rights Reserved. - "Poynter" fonts provided by fontsempire.com.