Attorney General Todd Blanche should be the first Cabinet member up for impeachment when the new Congress starts considering such moves, former federal prosecutor Joyce Vance argues, saying he has made the Justice Department into a tool of President Donald Trump.
“Here’s what I find so constitutionally offensive about the way that Todd Blanche has conducted the Justice Department’s business, and I think it’s impeachment worthy,” Vance said on Stacey Abrams’ Crooked Media podcast Assembly Required. “He has turned the Justice Department into a political tool that the president can wield against his enemies.”
That is the way authoritarian regimes work, said Vance, who was a U.S. attorney for the Northern District of Alabama and writes the Substack Civil Discourse. “I think it’s conduct that should go first in line for impeachment,” she said. It’s important to note that the impeachment standard for “high crimes and misdemeanors” doesn’t require the subject to have committed a prosecutable crime.
Vance acknowledged that impeaching Blanche would probably do nothing to improve the person leading the Justice Department. “I am not under the illusion that we will get a better attorney general for the next two years, but it will send a message to people at the Justice Department,” she said. “The world sort of stops for an impeachment,” she added, and it will be an opportunity to educate people.
“It’s critical that we understand that the Justice Department cannot be corrupted by a president ever again,” she said.
Vance said Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth’s actions in the military are “utterly shocking,” pointing to his firing of generals as an example. “With Hegseth it’s sort of like, let me count the ways,” she said. And she blamed Health and Human Services Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. for the country losing its measles-free status. “Sounds like a high crime and misdemeanor to me,” she said.
However, Vance cautioned against moving too quickly. Pointing to Rep. Dan Goldman, she said different committees oversee different Cabinet secretaries, so it would be possible for more than one to be investigated at the same time. Articles of impeachment, though, are “a charging document, sort of like an indictment,” she said, and should only come after a thorough investigation.
“I just don’t think that we should prejudge people anymore in this context than we should in the criminal context,” she said.
She also suggested that Republicans may be more willing to distance themselves from Trump as his term in office draws to a close. None of them wants a future Democratic attorney general “to be able to come after them like Todd Blanche has gone after Jim Comey,” she said.
Trump’s own impeachments have not succeeded, in part because, as Vance puts it, “Republicans lack a spine.” But as the Trump era comes to an end, she said, “one or two of them might have a spine now.”