Democrats notch huge win in Emoluments Clause suit against Trump
Congressional Democrats are being allowed to forge ahead with their emoluments case against Trump after a federal ruling landed in their favor Tuesday. Democrats are expected to now begin obtaining financial records from the Trump Organization.
The Wall Street Journal reported that U.S. District Judge Emmet Sullivan denied a request from Justice Department lawyers to pause the case to allow an immediate appeal to a higher court in a setback for the president. The Justice Department said it would make an emergency plea directly to an appeals court in Washington, a long-shot legal tactic that is rarely granted in ordinary litigation.
The closely watched case, brought by nearly 200 House and Senate Democrats, is one of several novel challenges that allege Trump’s ownership of private companies that accept foreign-government business may violate the Emoluments Clause of the Constitution.
“If the President succeeds in running out the clock, an entire presidential term will have gone by with the nation’s highest officeholder making countless foreign policy decisions under a cloud of potentially divided loyalty and compromised judgment caused by his enrichment from foreign states. That is precisely the nightmare scenario the Framers adopted the Foreign Emoluments Clause to avoid,” the members of Congress wrote in a previous court filing
“This case will be poised for resolution within six months; an immediate appeal would hardly materially advance its ultimate termination," Sullivan noted in the 12-page ruling.
🚨BREAKING: a federal judge DENIES @realDonaldTrump’s appeal and says Senate and @HouseDemocrats can begin collectin… https://t.co/6z13TsyoMc— Dena Grayson, MD, PhD (@Dena Grayson, MD, PhD) 1561495491
Judge Sullivan ok’s discovery on #Trump’s foreign business entanglements starting on June 28. Not just Trump Hotel,… https://t.co/YhYtGTpEL4— Elizabeth Wydra (@Elizabeth Wydra) 1561483731
No one should profit from the presidency, directly or indirectly. Trump has used his office to funnel taxpayer doll… https://t.co/t4ENV67y9r— Steve Cohen (@Steve Cohen) 1561405473
Kudos to Judge Emmet Sullivan for allowing #Emoluments lawsuit to proceed - discovery will include #Trump organizat… https://t.co/gDOsJmn7N2— Shanlon Wu (@Shanlon Wu) 1561501329
Big legal win: Trump #emoluments lawsuit moving to discovery. @MyConstitution can begin proving its case that Trump… https://t.co/zfwrEVNBHt— MoveOn (@MoveOn) 1561499314
The ruling allows the Democratic plaintiffs, led by Sen. Richard Blumenthal, to begin the so-called discovery phase… https://t.co/iBYIuf0hhr— Bruno J. Navarro (@Bruno J. Navarro) 1561491487
Violating the #Emoluments clause is an impeachable offense in an of it’s self. #ImpeachmentInquiryNow https://t.co/tZk5GtKKUm— Glory to Ukraine (@Glory to Ukraine) 1561212366