2020 was a ‘dry run’ for MAGA Republicans to ‘steal the 2024 election’: conservative Bush-appointed judge
Warnings that MAGA Republicans will steal the 2024 presidential election if given a chance have not only been coming from Democrats. Some non-MAGA conservatives are speaking out as well, including J. Michael Luttig — a George W. Bush appointee who spent 15 years as a federal U.S. Court of Appeals judge. In an op-ed published by CNN’s website on April 27, Luttig warns that MAGA efforts to steal the 2020 presidential election were merely a “dry run” for 2024.
“The Republicans’ mystifying claim, to this day, that (former President Donald) Trump did, or would have, received more votes than Joe Biden in 2020 were it not for actual voting fraud, is but the shiny object that Republicans have tauntingly and disingenuously dangled before the American public for almost a year and a half now to distract attention from their far more ambitious objective,” Luttig emphasizes. “That objective is not somehow to rescind the 2020 election, as they would have us believe. That’s constitutionally impossible. Trump and the Republicans’ far more ambitious objective is to execute successfully, in 2024, the very same plan they failed in executing in 2020 and to overturn the 2024 election if Trump or his anointed successor loses again in the next quadrennial contest. The last presidential election was a dry run for the next.”
Although Republicans have had their share of midterms red waves in post-1980s elections — including the red waves of 1994 and 2010 — Democrats have been outperforming them in the popular vote in presidential elections. Democrats have won the popular vote in seven of the United States’ last eight presidential elections; the exception was 2004, when incumbent President George W. Bush defeated Democratic nominee John Kerry in both the electoral vote and the popular vote.
But even if 2024’s Democratic presidential nominee legitimately wins the electoral vote, Luttig warns, MAGA Republicans have a game plan for overturning the election results.
“From long before Election Day 2020, Trump and Republicans planned to overturn the presidential election by exploiting the Electors and Elections Clauses of the Constitution, the Electoral College, the Electoral Count Act of 1877, and the 12th Amendment, if Trump lost the popular and Electoral College vote,” Luttig explains. “The cornerstone of the plan was to have the Supreme Court embrace the little known ‘independent state legislature’ doctrine, which, in turn, would pave the way for exploitation of the Electoral College process and the Electoral Count Act — and finally, for Vice President Mike Pence to reject enough swing state electoral votes to overturn the election using Pence’s ceremonial power under the 12th Amendment and award the presidency to Donald Trump.”
Luttig continues, “The independent state legislature doctrine says that, under the Elections and the Electors Clauses of the Constitution, state legislatures possess plenary and exclusive power over the conduct of federal presidential elections and the selection of state presidential electors. Not even a state supreme court, let alone other state elections officials, can alter the legislatively written election rules or interfere with the appointment of state electors by the legislatures, under this theory.”
According to Luttig, now is the time to take steps to prevent MAGA Republicans from stealing the 2024 election.
“Forewarned is to be forearmed,” Luttig advises. “Trump and the Republicans can only be stopped from stealing the 2024 election at this point if the Supreme Court rejects the independent state legislature doctrine — thus allowing state court enforcement of state constitutional limitations on legislatively enacted election rules and elector appointments — and Congress amends the Electoral Count Act to constrain Congress’ own power to reject state electoral votes and decide the presidency.”
Luttig’s CNN op-ed has caught the attention of The Bulwark’s Bill Kristol and other Never Trump conservatives:
Important. From conservative former judge Mike Luttig:\n"Trump's and the Republicans' objective is to execute successfully in 2024 the same plan they failed in executing in 2020, and to overturn the 2024 election if Trump or his successor loses again."https://www.cnn.com/2022/04/27/opinions/gop-blueprint-to-steal-the-2024-election-luttig/index.html\u00a0\u2026— Bill Kristol (@Bill Kristol) 1651057672
Bush-appointed Judge Luttig lays out the record: "Trump and Republicans planned to overturn the presidential election by exploiting" Constitutional loopholes "if Trump lost the popular and Electoral College vote."\n\nIt "was a dry run" for future elections.https://cnn.it/3ERMrf2— Will Saletan (@Will Saletan) 1651067556
Here are some more responses to Luttig’s op-ed:
Important to note just how disproportionately prominent and vital Taylor Green/Boebert etc were in Jan 6 build up. They hadn\u2019t even been seated in congress yet & here they are conspiring with WH chief. No doubt who wears the pants in Repub caucus.— Eric Morrison (@Eric Morrison) 1651064261
Keep your committee assignments. Texts show just how prominent MTG, Boebert are in the Repub caucus. The power in Congress no longer measured by legislative prowess. It\u2019s all about your power as a culture warrior.— Eric Morrison (@Eric Morrison) 1651064482
The Michigan attempted kidnapping of governor Gretchen Whitmer was a dry run before the dry run.— Greg SLAVA UKRAINI \ud83c\udde8\ud83c\udde6\ud83c\uddfa\ud83c\udde6 (@Greg SLAVA UKRAINI \ud83c\udde8\ud83c\udde6\ud83c\uddfa\ud83c\udde6) 1651061414
That is the only platform the Republicans have. Infrastructure, healthcare, childcare, voting rights...they vote against.— DCNATIVE (@DCNATIVE) 1651059957
The very fact that they are considering running a man who attempted a coup, sickens me. There's no way he should be allowed to run for any office.— Donna Fallis (@Donna Fallis) 1651062672
- Bill Maher on why democracy is dying in plain sight - Alternet.org ›
- Michael Flynn envisioned 'a Myanmar-style military coup' for the US ... ›
- US Generals issue chilling warning of divided military and possible ... ›
- The outcomes of these state races could either protect or undermine US democracy: law professor - Alternet.org ›
- More than 15 Republicans are testing the waters for 2024 -- 'even if Trump runs': report - Alternet.org ›
- How GOP-controlled state legislatures could pull off a coup in 2024: journalist - Alternet.org ›