Marty Kaplan

Understanding Trump Voters Is Good - But Voting Against Kleptocracy Is Better

I was wondering if I was reading too much into the near-convergence of Sen. John McCain’s funeral; Labor Day, the traditional kickoff of the campaign season; and Rosh Hashanah, the start of the Jewish holidays of repentance and renewal.

But when I saw that Steve Bannon called the National Cathedral service “the High Holy Days” of the “permanent political class,” I knew I wasn’t overthinking it.

Dates may be coincidences, but metaphors can tell you a lot about the people who use them. “When someone shows you who they are,” Maya Angelou said, “believe them the first time.” Referring to a senator’s funeral as the “High Holy Days” wasn’t meant as a compliment by Bannon, someone viewed as their man on the inside by the neo-Nazi website Daily Stormer.

Recently, as the Days of Awe approached, Bannon’s ex-boss, Donald Trump, was stumping the country on behalf of his party’s mid-term election candidates, and so —back on the trail — was Barack Obama.

Trump’s rhetoric in Montana was typical of his rallies: a marathon of aggrieved rants, divisive attacks, wild lies and weird asides that thrill his red MAGA-hatted, Women For Trump-waving, who-are-these-people? base.

Right on cue, they booed “Crooked Hillary” and “The Failing New York Times.” They jeered Jon Tester, their Democratic senator, when Trump vented about the raw deal he gave Ronny Jackson, his physician and doomed pick to lead Veterans Affairs. When he fumed at Democratic senators questioning his Supreme Court nominee, Brett Kavanaugh — “Do you believe the anger and the meanness on the other side? Sick. It’s sick.” — they cheered in angry solidarity.

(All except for the dude in the plaid shirt. Anyone watching the rally on TV or social media could see him just over Trump’s shoulder making “Can you believe this?” faces. The “Whaaa?” on his lips was so off-brand he got thrown out. We’ll get back to him.)

An hour of outrage later, Trump was comparing himself to Abraham Lincoln. “The America of John McCain is the America of Abraham Lincoln,” Meghan McCain had said at the funeral of her father, whom Trump hated. It was Lincoln, of course, who began his national political career warning that “A house divided against itself cannot stand.” Trump began his warning that Mexicans are rapists. But in Billings, Trump claimed Lincoln as his rhetorical soul mate.

Trump told the crowd that the Gettysburg Address “was excoriated by the fake news…. They said it was a terrible, terrible speech,” he said, omitting that the bad reviews came mostly from Confederate papers. “Fifty years after his death, they said it may have been the greatest speech ever made in America,” Trump went on, omitting that Lincoln’s speech was about “the unfinished work,” “the great task remaining before us,” of re-uniting the United States. Trump didn’t volunteer to bind our nation’s wounds, but he did lay claim to Lincoln’s oratorical glory: “I have a feeling that’s going to happen with us.”

In not-so-subtle contradistinction, the search for common ground was the theme of Obama’s rally at the University of Illinois. He teed it up in his tribute at McCain’s funeral. “In a nation as big and boisterous and diverse as ours,” Obama said there, our institutions of self-government, our rule of law, our norms — “principles that are eternal, truths that are abiding… are what bind us together, give shape and order to our common life. Even when we disagree. Especially when we disagree.”

But now, as Obama carries that theme of unity around the country, he’s tackling it in a couple of ways I haven’t heard him develop before, one more successful than the other.

The first opens a path to changing the Trump topic from “Crazytown” (as chief of staff John Kelley calls the White House in Bob Woodward’s new book) to Cui bono?, which is Latin for “Follow the money.”

The rhetorical move to consider who really benefits from Trump policies off-stage, rather than what antics are taking place onstage, is liberating and unifying. We all want the best for America. This reframing frees the media from treating our nightmare as a reality show; it frees Americans to be citizens instead of spectators; it frees the 2018 campaign to address the injustices that electrified Bernie Sanders’s supporters.

Instead of offering a diagnosis of Trump’s psychological disorders, Obama offers a narrative of how we got Trump. The symptoms, even if pathological, may be entertaining, but the body politic needs to be healed. Here’s the story Obama tells, edited for length but in his words:

As we Americans have painstakingly pulled ourselves closer to our ideals — every child should have opportunity; everyone should be able to find a job; we have a collective responsibility to care for the sick, and to conserve the natural resources of this country and this planet — there’s been a backlash manufactured by the powerful and the privileged who want to keep us divided, angry and cynical, because it helps them keep their power and privilege.

The wealthiest influence government to skew things even more in their direction — to cut their taxes, unwind regulations, weaken worker protections, shrink the safety net. People who once felt solidly middle class feel real economic insecurity. These conditions are ripe for exploitation by politicians who have no shame about tapping into America’s dark history of racial nationalism, of ethnic and religious division, who appeal to tribe and to fear, who pit one group against another, and tell them that order and security would be restored if it weren’t for people who don’t look or sound or pray like they do.

A politics of resentment and paranoia takes hold. Demagogues arise who undermine norms that ensure accountability. A vision takes hold among politicians that the protection of their power and those who back them is all that matters, even when it hurts the country. Hence Trump. Hence a Republican Congress utterly unwilling to find the backbone to safeguard the institutions that make our democracy work.

It’s a narrative that’s closer to the late Howard Zinn than to Goldman Sachs — or, for that matter, to Vladimir Putin. For Obama, for Trump-voting Rust-Belters and for we the people, that has to be a step in the right direction.

The other issue Obama is wrestling with is the one I think cost him the House in 2010, the Senate in 2014 and much of his two-term agenda: his insistence on singing Kumbaya with a Republican Party unalterably opposed to finding common ground with him on anything. In light of that history, in light of his Trump narrative, what does Obama think our current political moment requires?

Steve Bannon’s answer, recounted by a reporter he used his High Holy Days line on: “America… is no country for anyone who wants to ‘hug it out’ with the opposition party in the name of finding common ground.” Bannon’s new movie, “Trump@War,” is designed “to fire up Trump’s base and ‘make ’em wanna grab a pitchfork. This is not a search for truth.’ And the coming mid-term elections… ‘are not about persuasion. This is muscle versus muscle.’”

Obama’s answer, the climax of his new stump speech, winds up at the same place Bannon does, minus the pitchforks and the know-nothingism: Vote. “Don’t hashtag, don’t get anxious, don’t binge on whatever it is you’re bingeing on, don’t lose yourself in ironic detachment, don’t put your head in the sand, don’t boo. Vote. Vote.”

But Obama’s strategy for victory — “by reaching out to everybody and competing everywhere and by fighting for every vote” — strikes me as a work in progress. I’m all for mobilizing the 4 out of 5 young people who don’t vote. But with limited time and money, I fear that Obama’s optimism about winning voters in every demographic is the triumph of hope over mid-term experience. Maybe I’m being unfair, but when Obama says this:

We have to be able to get inside the reality of people who are different, have different experiences, come from different backgrounds. We have to engage them even when it is frustrating. We have to listen to them, even when we don’t like what they have to say. We have to hope that we can change their minds, and we have to remain open to them changing ours.

I can’t help thinking of those cheering, jeering folks in their MAGA hats, whom I suspect are as keen on finding common ground with me as Mitch McConnell was with Obama.

Except for 17-year-old Tyler Linfesty. He’s the #PlaidShirtGuy in the Montana crowd whose reactions went viral. After he’d been ejected from the stands for inappropriate affect, he told a reporter he’d been a Sanders supporter, but he’d gone to the Trump rally not to troll him, but “because he didn’t want to miss an opportunity to see the president.” His expressions, he said, “were simply him keeping it ‘real.’”

Tyler Linfesty is going to vote in 2020. I bet there are a lot of people in his generation who have plenty in common with him. Here’s hoping that voting is how they’ll be keeping it real, too.

Marty Kaplan is a senior columnist for the Forward. Read his columns here. Follow him on Twitter at @martykaplan

Keep reading...Show less

The Resistance Needs to Tell Better Stories in the Face of Trump's Circus Politics

I recently returned from a Trump fast. It was actually a news fast, but since the news these days is pretty much all Trump all the time, a Trump detox is what it turned out to be.

Keep reading...Show less

Is There Such A Thing As Evil - And Is Trump It?

Is Donald J. Trump a liar? Yes, at this point it seems safe to say that he regularly tells intentional untruths. So, is Donald Trump evil?

Keep reading...Show less

We Need Local News Sources to Protect Democracy - Corporate Owners Are Destroying Them

I don’t know if Timothy Burke is going to save journalism, let alone democracy, but the spooky video he made for Deadspin at the end of March racked up 30 million views within a week and got the country gasping at Sinclair Broadcast Group’s fake anti-fake-news campaign.

Keep reading...Show less

It’s Not Cambridge Analytica We Need to Worry About, It’s Our Minds

The Cambridge Analytica furor, like the uproar over Russian penetration of Facebook that preceded it, has painted a bullseye on Mark Zuckerberg.

Keep reading...Show less

If the Response to the Parkland Shooting Made You More Hopeful, You’re Not Wrong

I never imagined I’d hear first lady Melania Trump channel Norman Lear. On the other hand, I never imagined I’d hear “first lady Melania Trump,” so clearly anything is possible.

Keep reading...Show less

Of God, Dice And Fatal Car Accidents

It was the second time I noticed a news story about a fatal crash of a church group that I had the uneasy feeling there was a pattern.

Keep reading...Show less

This UFO Changes Everything

"Look at that thing, dude!” One hundred miles off the coast of San Diego, two Navy fighter pilots on a Super Hornets training mission spot a whitish, oval-shaped aircraft of some kind flying on an unearthly trajectory at crazy speeds. You can hear their astonishment on the 2004 recording.

Keep reading...Show less

Clarence Thomas Must Resign

Utah Republican Orrin Hatch called “bullcrap” on Ohio Democrat Sherrod Brown last week. The Senate Finance Committee lion tore into Brown for “spewing” that the Republican tax plan to transfer a trillion dollars to the rich was in reality a Republican tax plan to transfer a trillion dollars to the rich.

Keep reading...Show less

Harvey Weinstein Is a Sexual Abuser - Can We Still Watch His Movies?

Bad people can make and love good art. Can good people love bad people’s art?

Keep reading...Show less

Why America Is Desperately Trying to Understand the Vegas Shooter's Motives

Means, motive, opportunity. For detectives, nailing down those is the perp trifecta.

Keep reading...Show less

Our Country Has Gotten So Scary, I Don't Think I Can Live in Denial Anymore

Denial just ain’t what it used to be. Maybe it’s just me, but as recent news has delivered one gut punch after another, I'm feeling like magical thinking has lost its mojo.

Keep reading...Show less

This Is Your Brain on Trump: Why I Can't Help Calling His Supporters the Fools That They Objectively Are

Do you ever find yourself wondering what the story is with those thrilled faces behind Donald Trump at his rallies?

Keep reading...Show less

We Are Under Surplus Trump Stress: What Can We Do to Protect Ourselves?

In the contest between crisis and calm, oy has an edge over om. Case in point: Just as I was giving meditation another try to take my mind off Donald Trump, the North Korea fire-and-fury horror show broke out, and Trump’s itchy finger on the locked and loaded nuclear trigger made my strategy for sanity look awfully iffy.

Keep reading...Show less

How Long Will Trump's New Right-Hand Man Last? Place Your Bets

John F. Kelly’s front-stabbing Donald Trump’s new White House communications director Anthony Scaramucci only hours after Trump named the four-star Marine general his chief of staff was a sublime first move. But unlike Ivanka or Jared Kushner, Trump isn’t Dad to Kelly. How long can it be before Kelly’s service doesn’t pleasure the president anymore?

Keep reading...Show less

Will Mike Pence Pardon Donald Trump?

“Thank you, Mr. President,” Vice President Mike Pence tweeted July 15, celebrating the one-year anniversary of candidate Donald Trump naming him to the 2016 ticket. Will ex-president Trump get to say the same thing to Pence when the new president pardons him?

Keep reading...Show less

New Poll Reveals the First Word That Comes to Mind When Americans Think of Trump

“What is the first word that comes to mind when you think of Donald Trump?”

Keep reading...Show less

If Senate Republicans Think They Can Smooth Over the Devastating Health Care Bill With a Handsome Face, They're Mistaken

John Thune is the most handsome man in the U.S. Senate. With his square jaw, gleaming smile and cowboy tan, the 6’4” South Dakota Republican’s rugged good looks are antipodal to the mien of majority leader Mitch McConnell, whom Jon Stewart has definitively established is Yertle the Turtle’s doppelgänger. If the human brain’s positive bias toward attractive people didn’t cue me to infer that Thune is a great guy, a real straight shooter, I’d be as outraged by the assault on Americans’ health that Thune and his co-conspirators are currently waging, and by the subversion of American democracy they’re using to ram it through, as I am when its public face is McConnell’s.

Keep reading...Show less

Muslim, Jewish, Christian: The Problem Is That Trump 'Tolerance' Treats Every Belief as Equally Meaningless

Post-truth POTUS turns out to be perfect casting for tackling the One True Religion problem.

Keep reading...Show less

He Was Tackling the Opioid Crisis Head On: Then Trump Fired Him

At least I got to thank him for his service, while he was still serving.

Keep reading...Show less

This Passover, I'm Setting Myself Free From Technology

The people, the food and the storytelling are what I love most about the Passover seder I go to, but I also really like the updates to the ritual. We spill drops of wine as we name the ten Biblical plagues, but we count off ten modern plagues as well, like hunger and terrorism. Traditional symbols are on the table, like horseradish for the bitterness of slavery and salt water for tears, but there’s also an orange, an innovation from the 1970s, standing for feminism and against homophobia. (An orange? Seriously? There’s a story.)

Keep reading...Show less

What Happens to a Country Whose Leader Can't Say 'I'm Sorry'

“I blame myself—it was my fault, and I take full responsibility for it,” Donald Trump never said, not once in his entire life.

Keep reading...Show less

Has Truth Itself Gone Extinct in the Trump Era?

Let’s give it up for truth. C’mon, a nice hand. It gave us a lot of good years.

Keep reading...Show less

I Know How You Feel: Beat Up, Battened Down, Fetal, Furious - But There’s Nothing Wrong With You; It’s Him

Remember when we couldn’t wait to say good riddance to 2016? We’d had it with that abusive spouse of an election year. We were sick of the emotional rollercoaster. We needed an armistice, a breather. We were desperate to rise from the political sewer to the shining city on the hill.

Keep reading...Show less

Trump's Torture Policy Is Already Operating in Washington

President Trump feels waterboarding works.

Keep reading...Show less

Why I'm Skipping the Inauguration

Many people are saying they won’t be watching the inauguration on TV.

Keep reading...Show less

The Media Spent the Election Teaching Americans How to Love a Dictator - What Will They Do With Him in Office?

For a majority of Americans, feeling traumatized and terrified are reasonable responses to the words "President-elect Donald Trump." But even if his inauguration marks the demise of the star-spangled mythos we grew up on, being catatonic is no way to spend the next four years, especially if we're lucky enough to survive, oh, a nuclear war. But acceptance of Trump—acceptance is the last of Elisabeth Kubler-Ross’s five stages of dealing with death—is hardly chicken soup for our souls. Denial, anger, bargaining, depression, Trump: That can’t be the best we can do. 

Keep reading...Show less

Do CIA Revelations Mean Trump Will Be Putin's Puppet?

In 1964, when Barry Goldwater ran against Lyndon Johnson, a man named John A. Stormer self-published a book called None Dare Call It Treason. It accused America’s left-leaning elites of paving the way for a Soviet victory in the Cold War. The book sold seven million copies, but Johnson crushed Goldwater in the election.

Keep reading...Show less

Trump's Quiet Pick for Legal Adviser Shows He's Dead Set on Nuking Our Democracy

When Hillary Clinton lost the Electoral College, most post-mortems faulted Democrats for failing to empathize with the anger and abandonment non-coastal Americans are feeling. But last week, when Donald Trump sucked up to the (previously dishonest, subsequently gem-like) New York Times, flip-flopping six times in an hour-long interview, I wondered whether his backtracking might be causing some of his supporters to feel abandoned. If they are, I empathize with their incipient buyer’s remorse. I imagine they must feel a bit like Bernie Madoff’s investors did, after realizing they’d been conned.

Keep reading...Show less

The Prostate Presidency

In her Clinton wardrobe and hair, accompanying herself on the piano, Kate McKinnon’s cold open of the Saturday Night Live after Election Day was a dirge for the loss of Leonard Cohen, for the loss of Hillary Clinton and for the lost Americans now struggling for hope and direction.

Keep reading...Show less
@2022 - AlterNet Media Inc. All Rights Reserved. - "Poynter" fonts provided by