'The matter is closed': NY county clerk shuts down Texas AG's attempt to punish doctor
A county clerk in New York once again rebuffed Texas’s efforts to enforce a six-figure civil judgment against a local physician, reinforcing New York’s protections for abortion providers.
Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton pushed New York courts to honor a roughly $100,000 civil judgment rendered in Texas against Dr. Margaret Carpenter, who is based in Ulster County and is accused of prescribing abortion-inducing medication via telemedicine to a Texas patient, according to the Associated Press.
New York is one of eight states with shield laws designed to block enforcement of out-of-state penalties against providers in jurisdictions that have abortion restrictions.
READ MORE: Trump’s base feels humiliated because they were played for suckers — and they know it
Acting Ulster County Clerk Taylor Bruck, who announced the decision Monday, had earlier declined to file the judgment in March, citing New York’s shield law.
Last week, Paxton’s team contended that New York civil procedure mandates the filing and insisted Bruck had no legal choice. Bruck upheld his position Monday, stating that the office’s refusal remains final.
“While I’m not entirely sure how things work in Texas, here in New York, a rejection means the matter is closed,” Bruck wrote in a letter to Texas officials.
This legal standoff is one of two cases involving Carpenter that could challenge the boundaries of shield laws.
READ MORE: Stick a fork in him: Trump finally faces the threat of retribution — from MAGA
Earlier this year, New York Governor Kathy Hochul invoked the state’s shield protections to deny Texas’s request and a Louisiana extradition attempt related to separate allegations: Louisiana accuses Carpenter of prescribing abortion pills to a pregnant minor.
- 'Thugocracy': Ex-Bush speechwriter lays out ways Trump trashed 'constitutional conservatism' ›
- 'Will not tolerate': New York Times warns its journalists amid criticism of reporting on transgender people ›
- The backlash against Dobbs could do more than defeat Trump ›