Taken in the Night
A few years ago, my two half-sisters each spent two weeks in a treatment center for teens. Not for drugs or drinking or criminal activity - Holly and Nicole were being treated for bad behavior. They were "out-of-control," which, I have to say, they really were.
I won't go into all the gory details, except to say their family went through some serious trauma that was more than my stepmother could handle by herself. So she put her faith in a psychologist and checked her daughters into the treatment program at Bayview Hospital.
The program was very structured. They were told when and where to eat, sleep, go to the bathroom, read, express their feelings, and practically everything else. It sounded terrible to me. Holly agreed and said it didn't help her out at all. But Nicole, maybe because she is older, liked it and seemed to get a lot out of the program.
What my sisters experienced was a type of behavior modification program. The term sounds a little sketchy, sort of like brainwashing (which is what some critics actually call it). What it means is that through a combination of therapy and behavior modification they were "cured" of their out-of-controlness (in theory, anyhow).
And it's more common than you might think. My stepmom isn't the only freaked out parent who turned to a program to help straighten out her kids. In fact, more and more parents across the country are discovering that there's a growing business of private-pay behavior modification (or BM) programs out there sold as last-resorts for teens seriously at risk.
They come in all sorts of different packages, from those cool-sounding wilderness adventure trips to attitude- adjustment boarding schools to short-term, turn-around programs. But these tough-love programs all have one goal: to fix up "out-of- control" teens before they end up dead or in jail.
The BM programs have names like Turn-Around Camp, Paradise Cove, and High Peaks Wilderness and sound in their brochures almost like vacation spots where troubled teens can take a rest while getting it together. Some of them even operate out of the country in hot spots like Mexico, Jamaica, and Western Samoa.
The programs are not cheap - parents are willing to pay up to $5,000 a month ($60,000 a year!) to get their sons and daughters out of their hands and turn them around with some hard work and therapy. But as more and more kids go through these programs, there have been more and more horror stories and critics who say it's the programs themselves that are out of control.
Los Angeles-based psychologist Diana Devilliers, who has worked with troubled teens in a residential facility, says these programs can definitely help. But, she says, the BM programs that work the best include some sort of family therapy, because teens don't usually become "out-of-control" without help from their families.
"If the kids are out of control, it's because parents have usually lost their effectiveness," she says. Oftentimes, a teen's bad behavior has to do with larger family problems such as divorce, lack of supervision, a parent depending too much on their children, alcoholism, and abuse.
While some of these BM programs offer family therapy, some seem to focus just on the teen's behavior. But if a teen is sent away for attitude adjustment and her family members don't do their own adjusting, Devilliers says, then she will likely come back to the same situationÑand have the same problems.
But these schools and programs must be doing something right or they wouldn't be so popular. Surely parents have something better to do with $5K a month. In fact, in press accounts and testimonials, many parents said they totally helped their kids out. (Check out woodbury.com for information on the different programs and what people say about them.)
Case in point: Justin Bell. Justin went through eight months of one of the more intense programs, Tranquility Bay in Jamaica. He told the Associated Press last summer that it saved his life. "If I hadn't gone into the program I'd be dead right now, because I would have killed myself," he said. Sure, it was a hard and scary experience, but "desperate situations need desperate solutions," Justin said.
These BM programs aren't the right solution for everyone. In fact, some former students and their families said they were more like private prisons than therapy programs. And in the past year, their rep has been hurt by a rash of critical reports on TV and in magazines and newspapers.
Also, several of these programs have been sued by parents or teens who were in them, and tell scary stories of kids getting hit and kicked, tied up, forced to sit or lie on the floor for hours, and put in cells and isolation.
One of the things that has upset people and been played up big in TV and magazine investigations is that a lot of the programs suggest that parents hire an escort service to take their reluctant kids to wherever the program is located. But people who have been through them say it's like being kidnapped, with the escorts showing up in the middle of the night, using force, and sometimes even handcuffs on the surprised kids.
An estimated 20,000 teens go through these BM programs every year. What's scary is that it's not only teens with serious anti-social and dangerous behavior who go through BM. Getting defined as "out-of-control" can be as ridiculous as having different views from your parents. Some kids were sent to BM programs because they were confused about their sexuality or their religious parents thought they're weren't devout enough.
David Van Blarigan didn't see it coming. He didn't use drugs and didn't have any problems in school or with violence. What he did have, it later turned out, was a disrespect for his Christian parents.
One night, about two years ago, he woke up in the middle of the night to his parents and two big strangers who turned out to be his escorts to Tranquility Bay in Jamaica. David's grandparents fought to get him out and David later sued his parents for sending him to the program.
Donna Burke's two sons also went through Tranquility Bay, though not with her approval - her exhusband signed the forms. When Burke visited the facility she was horrified to find something more like a prison camp than a school: "Not only was every child frightened to death, they were all very thin, sunburned, covered with rashes and bites and living in overcrowded conditions."
She said the experience traumatized her kids for life and put a permanent nix on their relationship with their father. (You can read their story at intrepidnetreporter.com.) People under 18 don't have as many rights as the older group, and are considered to be property of their parents, to do with as they see fit. But kids do have rights, says child advocate Alexia Parks, and there are things they can do to protect themselves from getting sent to a BM program against their will.
Parks got involved with BM schools when her niece was involuntarily shipped to one. Parks has written a book, "An American Gulag," in which she casts a critical eye on these programs. (Check it out at teenliberty). She believes that BM programs and schools are thought-control camps for nonconforming teens.
If you suspect your parents are planning to send you to a BM program and you don't want to go, there are some things you can do:
"Teens can sign a document ahead of time saying they want legal representation if they 'disappear,'" says Parks. "They can also become emancipated...depending on age requirements in each state."
You can also go to a local juvenile court and file an emergency child-in-need-of-services report, which will get you an attorney or you can let the local law enforcement agency know that you do not consent to getting put into a program. Generally, letting people - and your parents - know what's happening and how you feel about it is the best defense.
Though my sisters' program was pretty tame compared to these new batch of pricey programs, it had mixed results for my sisters. I think Nicole's experience helped her survive the hell that is junior high and keep it together while she works through high school. But Holly hated it and said it was a lot like jail (which she would know - but that's a whole other story).
Mariel Garza is freelance writer and magazine editor based in Los Angeles.
This article originally appeared on ChickClick's teen channel Missclick.