Sex & Relationships

Gay Marriage Ban Looks to Have Passed in California, but Is It Legal?

Lawyers and marriage equality proponents are calling Proposition 8 illegal, and they may have good legal ground to stand on.
Hundreds of gay people and their allies at the Music Box in Hollywood on Election Night thundered their approval when states such as Pennsylvania and Ohio were called for Barack Obama. Like so many others around the world, gay people, anxious for change, felt the pendulum of history about to make a huge sweep in a progressive direction.

In between the election results and foot-stomping music, a steady stream of elected officials -- including new hero Jack O'Connell, California's superintendent of education, who appeared in a No on Prop. 8 ad condemning the "lies" promulgated by the Yes on 8 campaign -- promised to "fight for equality" even if Proposition 8 passed. But for most, that was unthinkable. How could the people of California in 2008 vote to eliminate the existing fundamental right of same-sex couples to marry and write that prohibition into the state constitution?

When the news networks announced that Obama would be the next president of the United States, and the first African-American president, the theater seemed to shake with the explosion of joy. The cheers were even louder when Obama mentioned gays in his acceptance speech.

But as the night wore on, the revelers became more and more somber as it appeared that Prop. 8 would pass and make same-sex couples an unwanted part of history, too. By morning, while the world rejoiced at the prospect of a new beginning, lesbian and gay couples cried in despair at the profound loss of equality.

By Wednesday morning, with 95 percent of the precincts tallied, passage of Prop. 8 looked assured with 52 percent of the vote and a 400,000-vote advantage. But No on Prop. 8 leaders refused to concede until all the votes were counted.

"The fundamental fact is, the issue in this election race is too close to call, and people's literal fundamental rights hang in the balance," said National Center for Lesbian Rights Executive Director Kate Kendell during a hastily called conference call.

Equality California Executive Director Geoff Kors told reporters that the uncounted absentee ballots are not the same as those filed early by older conservative voters.

"People who do absentee and just basically bring them in that day or mail them in the day before -- like me -- tend to be more progressive and more likely to be with us," Kors said. "And then there are kind of provisional ballots -- which happen to a lot of new voters -- which we know tend to be with us."

California Secretary of State Debra Bowen is expected to make an announcement about the uncounted ballots by Thursday afternoon.

Meanwhile, California county clerks stopped issuing marriage licenses to same-sex couples based on the semi-official results and a provision in the state constitution that says that, if approved by a majority of voters, any amendment or revision should take effect immediately.

Several lawsuits were immediately filed seeking an injunction and arguing the unconstitutionality of Prop. 8 to the California Supreme Court. Attorney Gloria Allred and her partner John West filed a suit in the high court on behalf of their clients Robin Tyler and Diane Olson, who were the first lesbian couple married in Los Angeles after same-sex marriage became legal.

"Prop. 8, if it passes, conflicts with the equal protection clause (in the California Constitution)," Allred said at an afternoon news conference in her Los Angeles office on Wednesday. "We will argue to the court that Prop. 8 is a disguised revision to the constitution which cannot be imposed by the ordinary amendment process, which only requires a simple majority. We believe that then the court must hold that California may not issue marriage licenses to non-gay couples because if it does, it would be violating the equal protection clause as straight couple would have more rights, by being allowed to marry, than gay couples."

Lambda Legal, the National Center for Lesbian Rights, and the ACLU also filed a lawsuit directly with the high court challenging Prop. 8. They, too, allege that the measure is invalid because it failed to follow the proper process required to make far-reaching changes to the California Constitution -- such as denying a fundamental right to a minority and prohibiting the courts from remedying abuses of that minority's rights.

Late in the afternoon, Los Angeles City Attorney Rocky Delgadillo joined yet another lawsuit filed by San Francisco City Attorney Dennis Herrera and Santa Clara County Counsel Anne C. Ravel to invalidate Prop. 8.

"Equal protection under the law is a bedrock principle of our constitutional democracy," said Delgadillo. "Proposition 8 flies in the face of that principle and strips away fundamental rights from countless Californians. Proposition 8's supporters won a temporary victory, but only after waging a misleading campaign based on fear and bankrolled by out-of-state interests. I am committed to using every resource at my disposal to secure the full civil rights of my constituents and all Californians. We will not allow discrimination to be written into our state constitution, and I am confident we will preserve equal rights for all. This is California."

Late Wednesday, Attorney General Jerry Brown told reporters that he would defend the rights of the estimated 18,000 same-sex couples married between June 16 and Nov. 5 but added that he would also defend the new law, if challenged.

Prop. 8 supporters, meanwhile, were gleeful. "We know God has gone before us," said Ron Prentice, executive director of the California Family Council, in a Focus on the Family newsletter. "Tens of thousands of people were praying and fasting to give victory to California and protect marriage." Rallies in West Hollywood and San Francisco were scheduled for Wednesday night to try to provide some cathartic release for the agonizing civil rights setback the gay community perceives is inevitable with the ultimate passage of Prop. 8.
Sign Up!
Get AlterNet's Daily Newsletter in Your Inbox
+ sign up for additional lists
Select additional lists by selecting the checkboxes below before clicking Subscribe:
Election 2018