Election 2016

Hillary Clinton Pounces on a Very Flustered Donald Trump in the First Debate

Clinton appeared more presidential.

Donald Trump brought his tough-guy, America-first rhetoric onto the presidential debate stage Monday, but was repeatedly flustered and upstaged by Hillary Clinton, whose focused barbs made him interrupt and pout, and whose knowledge of how the political world works reduced him to grasping outbursts.

The first presidential debate of 2016 lived up to its hype. Trump did not deny the most incendiary attacks from Clinton—including the likelihood he does not pay any federal income taxes—telling black Americans he has nothing to apologize for after lying for years that President Obama was ineligible for office; admitting he stiffed contractors he hired for his resorts and calling his bankruptcies smart; and attacking women for not looking right for the job—in the latest case the presidency.

The debate started with both candidates being polite as moderator Lester Holt asked about creating jobs. Clinton laid out her plans for rebuilding infrastructure including a green energy system across the country. But she wanted to get under Trump's skin and quickly succeeded by saying his business empire came from his father giving him many millions more than he has acknowledged.

Trump was soon wiping the sweat from his lip, creasing his forehead, frowning and trying to sound reasonable as he attacked Clinton with popular one-liners from his rallies, such as lambasting her support of previous trade deals and saying she has no jobs plan. That’s when the tables quickly turned. "Yes, I do," she tartly replied, "read my book." That kind of response, which pushed Trump to fume and fulminate, underscored her ensuing dominance on temperament and substance.

The debate continued with Trump dragging out old and off-topic right-wing memes, such as saying the Federal Reserve was political, would soon raise interest rates and destroy the economy. That line was typical of many that followed, including accusations that Clinton created ISIS, that she and the Democrats have failed non-whites in inner cities, that everything wrong in America is not just the fault of Democrats but especially the Clintons, current candidate and ex-president. In sum, Trump was appealing to anybody who was aggrieved and wanted to blame someone else.

But Clinton kept needling Trump about his business dealings, his bankruptcies and his refusal to release his income taxes. In each exchange, he took the bait and said something that seemed unlikely to win over undecided voters. He claimed he was a good businessman for using the bankruptcy laws even as he paid himself but not others. He said the contractors he stiffed deserved such treatment. He said he’d release his taxes once an IRS audit was done, but almost immediately said he’d been audited continuously for the past 15 years—meaning the release will not be forthcoming. When Clinton suggested he did not pay any income taxes, he interrupted “that makes me smart.”

While Trump tried to score by colorfully repeating simple lines like states like Ohio have suffered because of trade deals like NAFTA, Clinton stood behind her podium looking composed and waiting. She launched into more detailed replies, attacking Trump for distortions and evasions and explaining how his stances would hurt middle- and working-class families while benefiting wealthy people like his family. Trump did not deny, for example, that his proposed tax cuts would help the rich. She replied that such “Trumped-up trickle-down” economics didn’t work under Ronald Reagan and would not work now. She emphasized enlarging safety nets, like raising the minimum wage, pay equity for women, instituting family leave, and debt-free college for most families.

The debate turned to police reform and gun control, with Trump saying he was the “law and order” candidate. Clinton replied that sounding tough was not being effective. She said climate change is real and presents big economic opportunities. Trump denied saying, as he indeed has, that climate change is a Chinese hoax. When Trump attacked her for using a private e-mail server at the State Department, Clinton admitted it was a mistake and said no more. He did not keep the focus there, another sign he is not a disciplined debater.  

One of the most effective responses from Clinton came after the moderator asked Trump about his dogged pursuit of promoting the birther lie, that President Obama was born outside of the country and therefore was an illegitimate president. Trump gave a long response, saying he did the country a service by keeping an issue alive. When it was Clinton's turn to respond, she said, calmly, "Well, just listen to what you heard." She tied Trump's "racist birther lie" to his "long record" of racist behavior, starting in the 1970s when his family's real estate empire would not rent apartments to black people until the U.S. Justice Department sued.  

The debate’s effect on the public will become clearer in coming days as polls are done, but journalists covering the debate were not the only ones who were quick to say Trump had lost the encounter. While there will be many reports fact-checking the candidates' claims and responses, the nature of television is such that the way candidates appear, interact, respond under pressure, and the resulting feelings they convey matter as much as the details of what is being said.

One revealing feature of watching the debate online was seeing Twitter comments as it unfolded. Frank Luntz, a longtime Republican pollster, said 17 of the 20 people in his debate focus group said Clinton won. Bernie Sanders tweeted, “I don't often agree with @MittRomney but he's right: Trump is a ‘fraud’ and a ‘phony.’” Others said the choice facing voters was “first female president or first white nationalist.” Others suggested that Trump just set a record for the most self-congratulatory statements in a presidential debate.     

In many respects, "debate" is not quite the right word for the encounter. The 90 minutes condensed much of what has been playing out in slower motion for the past year. Trump’s vacuous but biting attacks dominated his performance after he initially tried to exercise restraint and self-control. By the night’s end, he was pointing his finger at Clinton as he repeatedly accused her of being a fraud, a scheming politician, acting “holier than thou” and making promises she can’t deliver.

Clinton, for her part, showed the audience the seasoned politician that she is. She presented her agenda, took Trump's apart, and didn’t flinch from the stress of being under the spotlight, as he did. When Trump tried to smear her with typical innuendo that she had been staying “at home” in recent days, suggesting she was somehow weak, Clinton replied that she stayed home to prepare for the debate. “I did prepare and I am prepared to be president.” It wasn’t just one of the night’s best lines, she looked presidential while she was saying it.

This debate was clearly the best development for the Clinton campaign in many weeks. It's up to the voters, of course, to draw their conclusions on who is the most presidential.

Steven Rosenfeld covers national political issues for AlterNet, including America's democracy and voting rights. He is the author of several books on elections and the co-author of Who Controls Our Schools: How Billionaire-Sponsored Privatization Is Destroying Democracy and the Charter School Industry (AlterNet eBook, 2016).

Sign Up!
Get AlterNet's Daily Newsletter in Your Inbox
+ sign up for additional lists
Select additional lists by selecting the checkboxes below before clicking Subscribe:
Election 2018