China's President Xi Jinping and US President Donald Trump arrive to attend a welcome banquet for the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation
A former Republican strategist said that President Donald Trump’s first-ever three-way summit with Vladimir Putin and Xi Jinping could have ramifications that reach beyond any one bad deal it might produce by sending a message that the United States no longer supports the notion that borders should not be changed by force.
Steve Schmidt, who was the chief strategist for John McCain’s 2008 presidential campaign and who has since left the Republican Party, argued Wednesday in his Substack newsletter, The Warning, as Trump arrived in China for the meeting, that the summit could undermine core U.S. foreign policy principles.
The three world leaders are due to meet Thursday on the sidelines of the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation summit in Shenzhen. The White House said Trump plans to use the meeting to discuss the Iran war and nuclear arms, and a senior U.S. official said Trump will avoid discussing Ukraine with the Chinese president and Russian leader.
Schmidt said he was not opposed to the summit, noting that presidents have met with adversaries in the past. He cited President Franklin D. Roosevelt with Soviet leader Joseph Stalin, President Richard Nixon in China, and President Ronald Reagan with Soviet leader Mikhail Gorbachev. Negotiating arms reduction, he said, is a valid goal, but it must be guided by principle and not just a desire to strike a deal.
Schmidt said the principle he was referring to was enshrined in August 1941, when Roosevelt secretly traveled to Placentia Bay off the coast of Newfoundland for a meeting with Winston Churchill. The two men produced the Atlantic Charter, which stated that they rejected “territorial changes that do not accord with the freely expressed wishes of the peoples concerned.”
Schmidt conceded that the Atlantic Charter was not without flaws — from Churchill’s attachment to the British Empire to racial segregation in the United States — but he said that its central principle applied to both Putin’s claims on Ukraine and Xi’s claims on Taiwan. Namely, who has the right to determine the fate of a people, a question Schmidt said Roosevelt answered 85 years ago.
Schmidt said that Trump views alliances as transactions, has shown contempt for long-standing allies and has even spoken about acquiring territory as though national sovereignty were a real estate negotiation. Schmidt said his greater concern is that the United States could end up legitimizing spheres of influence — where major powers dictate terms to their smaller neighbors — a world much closer to the one Roosevelt fought to defeat.
Schmidt asked whether Trump will stand up for Ukraine’s sovereignty, make clear that the future of Taiwan cannot be imposed through coercion or force, and reaffirm America’s commitment to its allies.
Schmidt said Roosevelt laid the foundation for the post-World War II world order but died in April 1945, before the United Nations came into existence. A month later, Roosevelt was honored as one of the architects of the United Nations in California’s Muir Woods, with delegates from 46 countries in attendance. It was not a world order guaranteed to last, Schmidt said, but it was one that was handed down to the present generation. “And now it is ours to save,” he added.
The Financial Times reported that there are likely to be few concrete results from Trump’s meeting on Thursday. But it said the image of Trump meeting with Xi and Putin could have ramifications in Ukraine, Taiwan and elsewhere.
From Your Site Articles
- Critics say 'pathetic' Trump’s summit behavior humiliates America ›
- Trump’s 'humiliation' paraded for world leaders as 'unserious' trip flops ›
- Trump is about to have 'most humiliating' event ever for Republicans ›
- Trump walks into a high-stakes poker game — with everything to lose ›
- Fox News analyst warns 'weak' Trump could start World War 3 ›
Related Articles Around the Web
- Opinion | Trump’s Ego Trip With Xi and Putin Will End Badly - The New York Times ›
- Europe fears what Trump, Xi and Putin might discuss behind closed doors in China | CNN ›
- Trump branded a ‘disgrace’ as Putin meeting puts millions in ‘danger' - World News - News - Daily Express US ›
- U.S. allies on edge as Trump heads to summit with Xi and Putin ›
- Putin's dream, Trump's photo op: CNN examines risks of summit with Xi for Ukraine and why Yalta 2.0 is unlikely ›
