MS NOW host Chris Hayes. (Image: Screengrab via MS NOW)
President Donald Trump is widely expected to make a historically massive wave of pardons on his way out of the White House, and now, one top MS NOW anchor has a prediction for just how far he will try to go.
Wide-ranging abuse of the pardon authority has emerged as a central theme of Trump's second term in the White House, with the president consistently offering pardons to allies or those who corruptly curry favor with him, including some allegedly explicit "pay-for-pardon" schemes. Trump also seems keenly aware of how much wrongdoing his staff has been engaged in under his watch, and has reportedly suggested that he plans to eventually pardon everyone who has come close to the Oval Office before he leaves for good.
Presidents are often known to issue a whole raft of pardons near the end of their time in office, but the sheer volume of them expected from Trump is expected to dwarf those efforts by a considerable margin. This was among the topics of conversation when Chris Hayes, host of MS NOW's popular All In program, made the latest of his many appearances on Late Night with Seth Meyers to discuss the aftermath of the midterms and the current state of Trump's power.
Near the end of the segment, Meyers wanted to get Hayes's prediction about the number of pardons Trump will issue before leaving office, asking if he believed it would be over or under his own wild prediction.
"I do think one of the other things that he's gonna start thinking about is the legality of what he's done in office, the people around him, as, certainly, as people start investigating possible corruption," Meyers said. "Over-under number of pardons he gives when he leaves office. I think -- I'm gonna give you a real number because I'm not joking around -- 2,000."
"I think I'll probably take the over," Hayes said after some consideration.
Hayes then suggested that Trump might be looking for a new sort of "cohort pardon" to issue mass clemency for a specific class of people, citing several historic examples.
"So, you know, when [former President Jimmy] Carter comes in, he does this sort of pardon of everyone who had been prosecuted for evading the draft, right?" Hayes explained. "And so the idea of that, that's like a cohort pardon. And sometimes you'll see, like -- you know, [Gov.] Wes Moore did this in Maryland where there's, like, a class of people who had nonviolent marijuana convictions... Then January 6th [mass pardons from Trump] was another one of those. So the question [is], like, 'Are there classes like that?'"
Hayes then put forward one such class of people that he has worried about Trump trying to issue preemptive pardons for, explaining how he asked his wife, attorney and podcaster, Kate Shaw, if it was something he could possibly get away with.
"Now, the thing that I think is so interesting here is, it's very untested jurisprudence," Hayes said. "And I even said this to my wife the other day as a thought experiment, I was like, 'Would it pass constitutional muster for him to say, no Republican officeholder can be prosecuted for any federal crimes? Every Republican in the whole country... has immunity, and they're basically pardoned prophylactically... And she was like, 'I don't know if that, if you can do that.' But what I do know is, he loves that power and, on the way out, is going to absolutely maximally employ it."
