President Donald Trump speaks on the day the final steel beam goes into the ballroom, at the White House in Washington, DC, November 4, 2026. REUTERS/Evan Vucci
A Trump-appointed federal prosecutor in Texas who recently told four Democratic lawmakers that they might be violating federal law doesn’t have the authority to back up that threat, a former U.S. attorney argued Tuesday.
“Reitz doesn’t appear to have the authority to back up his threatening letters,” Joyce Vance wrote in her Substack newsletter, Civil Discourse.
The U.S. attorney for the Southern District of Texas, Aaron Reitz, sent “preservation letters” to Rep. Robert Garcia of California and Sens. Richard Blumenthal of Connecticut, Elissa Slotkin of Michigan and Elizabeth Warren of Massachusetts. All four intend to take up oversight of the Trump administration in January.
Reitz’s letters asked the lawmakers to preserve documents related to their “intention to weaponize congressional investigations” and warned them they may be committing two federal civil rights crimes.
None of the lawmakers is in Reitz’s district, and, as Vance noted, federal law prohibits U.S. attorneys from operating outside their districts unless designated by the attorney general to do so.
Vance said no such designation had been made public. She pointed out that this is different from 2019, when Attorney General William Barr appointed John Durham to investigate the origins of the Russia investigation. Vance also noted a ruling by the 2nd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in Ghislaine Maxwell’s case that a deal Jeffrey Epstein had made with federal prosecutors in Florida didn’t bind prosecutors in other parts of the country.
The charges of civil rights violations would also fail because prosecutors would have to prove the lawmakers intended to violate someone’s federally protected right, Vance argued. Additionally, the First Amendment and the Speech or Debate Clause would protect the lawmakers, she wrote. She argued it was absurd to think that the lawmakers would be committing a crime by requesting information.
Vance argued that if a prosecutor wanted to investigate these lawmakers, they would do so by issuing grand jury subpoenas, rather than sending preservation letters. She said the action appears to be political, and noted that Reitz, who previously served as chief of staff to Sen. Ted Cruz, R-Texas, comes from a policy background, rather than a prosecutorial background.
President Donald Trump himself reposted Reitz’s posts about the letters to Truth Social, including one that said “My first arrow shot.” Vance said the use of Native American terms in the letter was beneath the dignity of the office.
Blumenthal, whose letter was largely about his probe into White House ballroom donors, has already responded to the letter. “I will not be intimidated,” he wrote in a Nov. 11 response.
Vance closed with an anecdote about former Alabama Attorney General Bill Baxley, who in 1976 responded to a letter from a Ku Klux Klan leader with a one-line letter telling him to “kiss my ass.”
On Monday, the Campaign for Accountability filed a grievance with the State Bar of Texas against Reitz for the letters sent to Blumenthal and Warren, Democracy Docket reported.
From Your Site Articles
- Trump threatens to prosecute anyone who tries to prosecute his inner circle ›
- Trump’s strategy to save his own skin: Fight like a criminal ›
- Trump warned he could 'suddenly risk arrest' over latest attack on court ›
- 'Legally baseless' White House 'self-own' shows Trump is very afraid: experts ›
- Analysts see the strategy behind Trump’s latest legal threats ›
Related Articles Around the Web
- Trump’s Goon Cornered on Crackpot Threats to Democrats ›
- White House warns of criminal inquiries into House Democrats who investigate Trump - Los Angeles Times ›
- Trump calls for DOJ investigation into Democratic calls for oversight - POLITICO ›
- Trump White House threatens Democrats on way to Congress: ‘Blatant criminality’ | The Independent ›
- Tracking retaliatory use of arrests, prosecutions, and investigations by the Trump administration ›
