U.S. President Donald Trump at Joint Base Andrews, Maryland, U.S., August 7, 2026. REUTERS/Elizabeth Frantz
On Monday, a prominent analyst of Republican politics revealed an unexpected outcome of the midterms and the looming problem it poses for President Donald Trump. According to John Kenneth White – professor emeritus in political science at The Catholic University and author of several books on the GOP and the evolution of political parties – the latest round of elections proved that the American two-party system is breaking down, posing new obstacles for Trump.
“We are about to return to four-party politics,” writes White in the Hill. “Back in the 1960s, political scientist James MacGregor Burns described what he saw as a four-party politics that defined his era. Today’s new four-party politics has Democrats split between moderates who were the majority-makers in 2026 and the socialists who want an even bigger government. On the other side of the aisle, there are the remaining Trump Republicans, whose loyalty to the president is bonded by a superglue, and the Reagan Republicans looking back to traditional conservative principles.” But while the Democrats, predicts White, will largely “resist the urge for intraparty fighting” out of an “urgent need to triage the damage done by Trump,” the situation for the Republican party is a “different story.”
In the House, asserts White, the GOP’s ranks have been diminished to the point where they are largely made up of “Trump Republicans,” with the newly selected House leader, Rep. Jim Jordan (R-OH) representing the MAGA faction. Things are different in the Senate, however, where White predicts that the divisions between the Trump Republicans and the Reagan Republicans will likely continue to grow. “Those Republican senators elected in 2024 and 2026 will remain when Trump leaves office,” notes White. “Given the drubbing Republicans took this year, and their primal instinct for political survival, they are likely to defy Trump and while pursuing a different path forward for their party.”
Amid this political climate, White forecasts that the Republican Party may find itself in the electoral wilderness for decades to come, and he notes there’s a historical precedent for such a prediction. “Trump and Grover Cleveland are the only two presidents to serve non-consecutive terms in office,” explains White. “Like Trump in 2024, Cleveland won a narrow reelection victory in 1892. In 1894, Cleveland’s Democratic Party suffered a landslide defeat. That year, Republicans won control of both houses of Congress, gaining 110 House seats and added four new senators to their ranks. In 1896, the Republican Party won a landslide victory for William McKinley that began a 36-year reign of presidential dominance.”
The 2026 midterms, bets White, will be remembered as a prelude to what is to come. It has realigned future elections in Democratic favor, a situation that is exacerbated by likely GOP infighting. But whatever the political future has in store for Republicans, asserts White, one thing is clear: “the Trump era is over.”
From Your Site Articles
- Republican analyst calls it: Trump has 'doomed' the GOP ›
- Republican insiders reveal why the GOP wants to dump Trump — but can’t ›
- Ex-GOP leader: Republicans have plan to take party back from Trump ›
Related Articles Around the Web
