Sen. John Fetterman at the Jewish Democratic Council of America’s (JDCA) 2024 Leadership Summit on May 21, 2024 (Jewish Democratic Council of America/Flickr)
Sen. John Fetterman (D-Pennsylvania) has become one of the most talked-about Democrats in the U.S. Senate. While many progressives are expressing frustration with Fetterman's more centrist positions, the Pennsylvania senator has a vocal defender in "Real Time" host Bill Maher — who is attacking progressives for what he views as purity tests and emphasizing that Fetterman represents a swing state, not a deep blue state. If Democrats are going to be a big tent, Maher is arguing, they need to accept the fact that not everyone in their party is going to be a straight-down-the-line progressive.
Senate Democrats may be paying attention to Maher and other Fetterman defenders. According to NOTUS reporter Igor Bobic, Senate Democrats are trying to keep things friendly with Fetterman in order to keep him in their party.
"The iconoclastic Pennsylvania Democrat has often seemed like a senator without a party in recent years," Bobic explains in NOTUS. "He has broken with his party over Israel, immigration funding and government shutdowns, while defending some of Trump's projects, including building a grand ballroom at the White House and his revamp of the Lincoln Memorial reflecting pool. The breaks have led to speculation that Fetterman could be willing to make a change — either to become the Senate’s third independent or even join the GOP caucus."
Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer (D-New York) is making it clear that despite some policy disagreements, he considers Fetterman a "valued Democrat in our caucus."
Schumer told NOTUS, "We’re not going to agree on every issue every day — that's true of any broad coalition — but Senate Dems are united."
Sen. Peter Welch (D-Vermont) is reminding his colleagues that Fetterman won in a crucial swing state that can go either Democrat or GOP. President Donald Trump lost Pennsylvania in 2020 but carried the Rust Belt state in 2016 and 2024.
Welch told NOTUS, "We should listen to him. He won in a tough state. We're quibbling about somebody who speaks his mind and votes with us over 90 percent of the time. I think we should show some respect."
Similarly, Sen. Brian Schatz (D-Hawaii) said of Fetterman, " I think we should have a big enough and diverse enough party to not just tolerate that, but hope for it and work for it."