Paul Krugman explains why Republicans' new push to undermine blue states could blow up in their faces
Last week in his New York Times column, liberal economist Paul Krugman lambasted Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell for his assertion that individual states in the U.S. should be allowed to go bankrupt during the coronavirus pandemic and that he had no desire to “bail out blue states.” Krugman revisited the subject in a Twitter thread on Monday morning, explaining why some red states might be the ones suffering the worst budgetary problems in the months ahead.
“As states exchange insults over who subsidizes who (yes, blue states subsidize red states), some people I’ve been talking to are suggesting that red states may face a worse fiscal crisis than blue this time around, [because] of their different revenue bases,” Krugman tweets.
Krugman goes on to describe the revenue sources of two blue states (California and New York), a light red state (Texas) and a swing state (Florida).
As states exchange insults over who subsidizes who (yes, blue states subsidize red states), some people I've been t… https://t.co/xgfaHFTcXX— Paul Krugman (@Paul Krugman)1587998485.0
“Look at the big four,” Krugman writes. “CA and NY get most of their revenue from income taxes, which may hold up fairly well: high-income workers less likely to be laid off, often able to work from home. FL and TX have no income tax, dependent on sales taxes, which must be plummeting.”
From his Twitter thread, Krugman links to a page on the Federation of Tax Administrators’ website. The page breaks down the sources of tax revenue for individual states; for example, 64.3% of Florida’s revenue, according to the FTA, comes from sales taxes compared to only 16.7% from sales taxes in New York State or 20.7% from sales taxes in California. And Texas gets 59.9% of its revenue from sales taxes.
When so many brick-and-mortar businesses deemed non-essential are shut down, a lot of sales tax revenue is lost.
“We’ll see,” Krugman writes. “But not too surprising if a few months from now FL and TX are screaming for an aid package.”
Look at the big four. CA and NY get most of their revenue from income taxes, which may hold up fairly well: high-in… https://t.co/idJP8AmDr5— Paul Krugman (@Paul Krugman)1587998604.0
We'll see. But not too surprising if a few months from now FL and TX are screaming for an aid package. 3/— Paul Krugman (@Paul Krugman)1587998648.0
@paulkrugman If wealthy blue states like NY & CA are subsidizing poorer red states, that sounds a bit like a wealth… https://t.co/bIMBx1ZBMc— Sanity Check (@Sanity Check)1587998868.0
@paulkrugman It is also true that the blue regions within red states subsidize the rest of the states. In Kentucky… https://t.co/9knwFMfGqT— John Laurens (@John Laurens)1587999190.0