The 'resistance' to Trump's Venezuela coup won't be found on MSNBC
After much behind the scenes angling and plotting, the Trump administration is now waging an overt campaign to overthrow the government of Venezuela — coordinating directly with the Venezuelan military, lobbying other countries to support the opposition government-in-waiting, threatening a military invasion and engaging in aggressive PR stunts under the guise of “aid.”
Given that MSNBC is the largest, most influential liberal platform in the U.S. — one that has long marketed itself as a progressive counter to the lies and ruthless right-wing onslaught of the Trump government, one would think it would be leading the charge against Trump’s old school, Cold War–style coup-mongering in South America.
But a FAIR survey of MSNBC since Trump threw U.S. support behind self-proclaimed Venezuelan president Juan Guaidó (the effective start of the attempted coup) finds coverage has ranged from outright support to virtual silence — with only one five-minute segment on "All in With Chris Hayes" (1/29/19) broaching objections to Trump’s Venezuela policy. The only segment that comes close to criticizing Trump’s attempted coup, Hayes’ “Is Trump Moving Toward War in Venezuela?” largely framed his opposition as “just asking questions,” and had on Rep. Joaquín Castro, D-Texas, to insist the “timing” for sanctions and regime change wasn’t right.
Based on a search of MSNBC’s website, these were the only five of the cable channel’s 30,240 on-air minutes since Trump’s coup was launched three weeks ago that were dedicated to criticizing it, and these did so only mildly.
Aside from Hayes’ brief chiding, primetime coverage of Trump’s coup on MSNBC has been entirely nonexistent: Searching turned up nothing about Venezuela in recent weeks on "Hardball With Chris Matthews," the "Rachel Maddow Show," "Last Word With Lawrence O’Donnell" or "11th Hour With Brian Williams." The vast bulk of the coverage, such that it is, has been during the daytime, and has been largely fluffy, pro-regime change propaganda:
- Venezuela’s Maduro Cuts Relations With U.S. as Trump Recognizes Opposition Leader Juan Guaidó as Interim President (Velshi & Ruhle, 1/23/19)
A fairly dry news report where Andrew Mitchell, reporting on behalf of NBC News, repeatedly refers to Maduro’s “regime” and passes along Trump’s line uncritically.
- Sen. Rubio: If Any Harm Comes to U.S. Diplomats in Venezuela, the Consequences Will Be ‘Swift and Decisive’ ("Andrea Mitchell Reports," 1/24/19)
Softball interview with Sen. Marco Rubio, R-Fla., the leading congressional coup proponent. propping up all the primary arguments for the coup. The segment leads with “hundreds of thousands of Venezuelans are taking to the streets … demanding freedom,” and refers repeatedly to Maduro as an “authoritarian leftist, authoritarian socialist president.”
- Maduro and Guaidó Fight for Power in Venezuela, U.S. Gets Involved (Ayman Mohyeldin, 1/27/19)
A five-minute phone call with opposition leader Lilian Tintori.
- Brief discussion by Joy Ann Reid ("AMJoy," 1/27/19)
Not a full segment, but MSNBC go-to Venezuela expert Mariana Atencio promotes all of Trump’s core arguments for the coup.
- Velshi & Ruhle breaking news segment ("Velshi & Ruhle," 1/28/19)
MSNBC just plays the press conference of National Security Adviser John Bolton, the administration’s chief coup architect.
- Venezuela Power Play: Breaking Down Maduro and Guaidó’s Options (Hallie Jackson, 1/30/19)
Jackson leads with Mariana Atencio — using her personal background to lend gravitas to her one-sided pro-Guaidó analysis: “This is a battle right now between legitimacy and power. Guaidó has the legitimacy, but Maduro has the guns, meaning the power.”
“Mariana, we are so thrilled to have you on,” Jackson began; “You’re a native of Venezuela.”
But if Atencio’s background is brought up to present her as the voice of the Venezuelan people, why not mention her deeply atypical class status? A 2012 ABC profile of Atencio suggests she is far from representative of the average Venezuelan:
" data-google-container-id="3" style="box-sizing: border-box !important; -webkit-font-smoothing: antialiased; max-width: 100%; display: block; margin: auto; text-align: center !important; border: 0px; vertical-align: bottom;">
Besides the typical Disney trip that many Latin American families venture to, [Atencio] had not spent much time in the States before attending tennis summer camp at age seven. That’s when her father sent Mariana and her siblings to Camp Lincoln and Camp Hubert Tennis Camp in Brainerd, Minnesota, for four consecutive years. “It seemed like the end of the world,” she says, with a laugh.
The rest of the article was a gallery of Atencio’s favorite shoes.
- Thousands of Anti-Maduro Protesters Gather in Florida ("Weekends With Alex Witt," 2/2/19)
Pro-coup agitprop as Atencio reports from a pro-Guaidó rally in Doral, Florida. MSNBC is apparently still unable to find a Venezuelan to report or provide analysis who isn’t an Ivy League–educated tennis camp alum married to a real estate entrepreneur.
- Venezuela’s Opposition Leader Speaks as Pressure Grows on Maduro ("Velshi & Ruhle," 2/4/19)
Softball interview with Juan Guaidó by NBC’s Kerry Sanders.
This has been the extent of MSNBC’s coverage of Trump’s attempted coup, carried out in broad daylight by a murderers’ row of hardcore right-wing Cold Warriors: Five minutes of hand-wringing from Chris Hayes, total silence from all the other primetime personalities, and daytime reporting that echoes Trump and Rubio’s uniform praise for the coup attempt and its primary actors.
Just as the New York Times has long stood behind the U.S. history of coups, MSNBC is following the tradition of Democratic Party–aligned media who are happy to oppose Trump when it comes to mean words and Russiagate, but fall in lockstep with his White House the second he begins to carry out Washington’s bipartisan regime-change agenda.