Here's Why Attorney-Client Privilege Might Not Save President Trump or Michael Cohen
President Donald Trump is banking on attorney-client privilege to shield his sensitive communications with Michael Cohen from the prying eyes of federal investigators — but there's good reason to think it won't work.
As Mimi Rocah, former assistant U.S. attorney for the Southern District of New York, explained to Rachel Maddow Monday night, there are significant limits to attorney-client privilege.
"The attorney-client privilege is hugely important, and prosecutors and judges take it extremely seriously, but it is narrow," Rocah said. "You have to have a real, attorney-client, confidential relationship, where I'm seeking legal advice."
She continued: "It doesn't seem like Mr. Cohen is someone you go to when you have a real legal, tough problem you want an answer to. ... They're really showing that in the nature of the few clients that he has, the type of matters he's been involved in, which is not legal representation but more being this 'fixer,' almost a businessman, really."
Even though he has a law degree, if Cohen was acting more like a businessman than a lawyer in his interactions with Trump, then attorney-client privilege won't hold, Rocah explained.
So Trump — as well as Sean Hannity — may be mistaken if he thinks his conversations with Cohen will all be protected simply because of attorney-client privilege. A team of investigators will work to determine exactly what parts of Cohen's communications are privileged, and which are open to investigators. If agents working for the U.S. attorney for the Southern District of New York, which directed the recent raid on Cohen's office, discover evidence related to the special counsel's Russia investigation, they may even turn it over to Robert Mueller.
Watch the clip below:
Even if you have a law degree, if you're acting as a businessman the law is going to treat you like a businessman. pic.twitter.com/QSWHV7i6gB— Maddow Blog (@MaddowBlog) April 17, 2018