Why Is the Feminist Majority Foundation Refusing to Abandon the Women and Girls of Afghanistan?

The following is a response to the AlterNet article by Sonali Kolhatkar and Mariam Rawi's about the Feminist Majority Foundation's position on the U.S. occupation of Afghanistan by the president and a board member of the organization.

Afghanistan is in deplorable condition. There's no disputing that. Some feel that we should just walk away. We cannot endorse this position because the cost to women and girls would be too high, and the U.S. responsibility for the current failed state of affairs in Afghanistan is too heavy.

If the U.S. was to pull out of Afghanistan, the United States would be once again breaking its promise to the Afghan people, and the country would likely fall under Taliban control. 

Afghans, especially the women and girls, know something about the Taliban: their oppression and horrific human-rights abuses. We can never forget they stripped women and girls of all human rights -- the right to education, mobility, visibility, health care, employment ... the list goes on.

And more recently these terrorists have destroyed hundreds of girls schools, killed journalists, local women's leaders and killed women teachers in front of their students. They have filled water pistols with acid and disfigured the faces of young girls walking home from school. No wonder only 4 percent of Afghans would support the Taliban returning to power and 58 percent think they pose the biggest danger to the country (BBC/ABC poll, December 2008).

Since 1996, the Feminist Majority Foundation has been immersed in a campaign to support Afghan women and girls in their fight against the brutal oppression of the Taliban. Long before 9/11, we protested and helped stop Unocal's proposed gas and oil pipelines that would have provided the Taliban with millions of dollars in annual fees to support their reign of terror.

We joined Afghan women's groups and other concerned citizens, launched an awareness campaign, gathered and delivered hundreds of thousands of petitions. Together, we stopped the U.N. and the U.S. from recognizing the Taliban as the official government of Afghanistan. 

To begin to understand the scope of the U.S.'s responsibility in Central Asia, we have to revisit the invasion of Afghanistan by the Soviet Union during the Cold War years. During the war against the Soviets, the CIA covertly supported mujahedeen fighters with billions in dollars, weapons and equipment. Some of those fighters later became known as the Taliban.

The U.S. also backed and funded vicious warlords who committed gross human rights abuses. A few of them are now members of the Afghan cabinet and parliament. 

Once the Soviet Union was defeated, President George H.W. Bush promised that the U.S. would help Afghans rebuild. Instead the U.S. walked away. 

Afghanistan erupted into a devastating civil war. The Taliban emerged "victorious" with help, it is believed, from Pakistan's Inter-Services Intelligence. 

During the period from the 1978 Soviet invasion through 2001, 5 million to 7 million Afghans fled the country of some 26 million. The Feminist Majority Foundation sent a team to Pakistan to interview those who were fleeing from the Taliban over the Afghan border. Afghans were the single largest refugee population in the world.

They told our team of the atrocities being committed. Refugee conditions and those within Afghanistan were abominable. The country was also suffering from a horrible drought. Some experts believed 1 million Afghans would starve to death.

Prior to 9/11, the Feminist Majority Foundation urged the increase of food allotments to the World Food Program for Afghans suffering from the Taliban and the drought. We also tried to get the Taliban listed as a terrorist organization -- to no avail. 

After 9/11, the U.S. bombed Afghanistan, the Taliban were deposed, and the George W. Bush administration promised a Marshall Plan to rebuild Afghanistan. 

As long-time peace activists, we did not support the bombing of Afghanistan after 9/11. As a member of Win Without War, we opposed the war in Iraq for many reasons. But let's be clear -- it was directly after the Bush administration abandoned Afghanistan to invade Iraq that conditions further deteriorated into the mess we're facing today. 

Given that nonviolence is part of our mission statement, we, at the Feminist Majority, never expected to be asking for more security in the form of international peacekeeping troops (ISAF) back in 2002. (It is this outdated fact sheet that Sonali Kolhatkar and Mariam Rawi cite, and we thank them for reminding us how important it is to keep our Web site updated.) But when we traveled to Kabul after 9/11 to find out what the U.S. could do, security is what Afghan women wanted first and foremost. 

The Afghans we spoke with were more than gracious considering what our government had put them through. We were heartsick over the conditions we saw, inspired by the stories of struggle and devastated by one question that we kept hearing over and over: "Where were you (U.S.) after we defeated the Soviets?" They had not forgotten the first time the U.S. abandoned them. 

Early in 2002, the Afghans were also extremely worried that if U.S. focus turned to Iraq, their needs would be forgotten again. Their fears were well founded. 

After Bush invaded Iraq, NATO and the U.S. did not adequately fund the redevelopment effort. Instead, the U.S. hired contractors who overcharged, botched projects and did not come close to meeting their goals.

Moreover, humanitarian aid was dispensed mostly through large international nongovernmental organizations with high overhead costs and relatively high Western salaries, with little actual aid [going] to Afghans. 

In the last seven years, there have been some successes. In 2000, girls were not allowed to attend school; last year, the U.N. reported that 6 million children attended school and more than one-third were girls. Forty-nine percent of health care workers are women. Women comprise 25 percent of civil service workers. 

But make no mistake. Afghanistan is in terrible shape. The Taliban has gradually returned. Nothing is as it should be, which is why we are asking for no less than a Marshall Plan to rebuild Afghanistan, the same way we did for Germany and Japan after World War II.

Afghanistan's water, sewage, electrical, and their once-proud hospital systems have been all but destroyed by 30 years of war. We bombed it. We have an obligation to rebuild it. 

Though we'd prefer that all U.S. funding be spent on development aid, we cannot in good conscience advocate the immediate military pullout that some are suggesting. The 2009 U.N. Humanitarian Action Plan noted that in 2008, "Approximately 40 percent of the country, including much of the south, remains inaccessible for most humanitarian organizations."

Last year, 92 aid workers were abducted and 36 were killed, double the number from 2007. In recent public opinion polls, Afghans put security in their top three concerns right after food. Without stabilizing the country, there can be no significant redevelopment effort. 

In March, President Barack Obama announced a significant change in the Afghanistan/Pakistan strategy. He shifted the focus from Iraq to this troubled region not a moment too soon. The Taliban had taken over the Swat Valley in Pakistan and were within 100 miles of its capital.

In case anyone was wondering if the Taliban had changed its ways, it promptly closed girls schools, began flogging young women publicly, and committed other atrocities. In Afghanistan, the Taliban nailed a 70-year-old woman to a tree for allegedly talking with the enemy. 

The new administration's strategy recognizes the need for development and reconstruction. The military appears to be changing its priorities, announcing that protection of civilians is its first priority.

Virtually everyone knows that a military solution alone won't work. Yet, we cannot ignore that security and the Taliban are among Afghans' top concerns. 

For over 12 years, we have been listening to and working with Afghan women and Afghan women's groups to learn what they want supported.

Dr. Sima Samar is the director of the Independent Commission on Human Rights, the highest-ranking woman in the government of Afghanistan. A physician and founder of Shuhada, which runs health clinics and schools for underserved women and girls, as well as for men and boys in Afghanistan, she is also the U.N. Special Rapporteur for Human Rights in the Sudan. When she talks, we take notes.

From a recent U.S. visit, this is what Samar urges and that we support: 

  • Human rights, especially the rights of women, must be a central focus.
  • The U.S. and Afghanistan must work together as partners with shared responsibility.
  • The U.S. must stop supporting and funding corrupt warlords who violate human rights. The culture of impunity must be stopped.
  • Security must be re-established until the Afghan army and police can take over. Private or "community" militias must not be funded.
  • Insist on accountability and transparency for aid funds and contractors.
  • Any long-term plan must include job creation and development aid.
  • Women's rights cannot be negotiated away in the name of peace. This kind of peace would not be sustainable.

We are grateful for our many friends and colleagues in the peace movement who have joined the effort to support the courageous women and girls of Afghanistan. Together, we have helped designate substantial U.S. funding for women and girls programs in Afghanistan -- $367 million to date.

Right now we are working for passage of the Afghan Women's Empowerment Act with $100 million for critically needed education, employment and health care programs, and we continue to emphasize the need to fund Afghan-women-led programs of Afghan nonprofits. We are also working to increase the numbers of trained midwives. Afghanistan has the second-highest maternal mortality rate in the world -- only 14 percent of Afghan women have access to a trained childbirth attendant. 

Our past governments' failed policies over 30 years have directly contributed to the current conditions in Afghanistan. We at the Feminist Majority Foundation feel we owe it to the Afghan people, especially the women and girls, to keep our promises to stay this time and help them clean up the mess.

Enjoy this piece?

… then let us make a small request. AlterNet’s journalists work tirelessly to counter the traditional corporate media narrative. We’re here seven days a week, 365 days a year. And we’re proud to say that we’ve been bringing you the real, unfiltered news for 20 years—longer than any other progressive news site on the Internet.

It’s through the generosity of our supporters that we’re able to share with you all the underreported news you need to know. Independent journalism is increasingly imperiled; ads alone can’t pay our bills. AlterNet counts on readers like you to support our coverage. Did you enjoy content from David Cay Johnston, Common Dreams, Raw Story and Robert Reich? Opinion from Salon and Jim Hightower? Analysis by The Conversation? Then join the hundreds of readers who have supported AlterNet this year.

Every reader contribution, whatever the amount, makes a tremendous difference. Help ensure AlterNet remains independent long into the future. Support progressive journalism with a one-time contribution to AlterNet, or click here to become a subscriber. Thank you. Click here to donate by check.

DonateDonate by credit card


Thanks for your support!

Did you enjoy AlterNet this year? Join us! We're offering AlterNet ad-free for 15% off - just $2 per week. From now until March 15th.