Work Dries Up for Day Laborers

Outside a Home Depot store, it's a typical December morning in Seattle: cool and gray with a light sprinkle falling. At 7:30, about 50 men wait at the entrances to the parking lot. Most wear jackets, jeans and work shoes, and some carry day packs with tools, water and lunch. They stand silently with hands in pockets, alone or in knots of three or four, baseball caps or sweatshirt hoods deployed against the chilly mist.


Occasionally someone lights up a cigarette; here and there a conversation unfolds in Spanish. A young man with a ponytail and his sleeves rolled up shoots the breeze with another, gesticulating with both hands and pacing. They all scan the street for approaching cars and trucks.

Three hours later, around 10:30, a crew-cab pickup truck finally pulls up. A stampede of men engulfs it, shouting and jockeying for position. The driver points to four, who jump into the cab. Others try to squeeze in the door behind them, and the new hires have to fend them off to close it. As the truck drives off, the others retreat back to the sidewalk, a few grumbling, most silent.

A young man from Chihuahua jokes: "You have to be fast and strong to get a job here." Lately, he says, only two or three vehicles are stopping to hire people on an average day. Most hire only one or two workers.

Until recently he had a regular job with a small contractor two to three days a week, but he was laid off. "The whole country is like a gigantic hospital," he says, full of people with problems. When he can afford bus fare, he'd like to go back home to Mexico and his family to live.

The transaction around the pickup truck is the signature of an informal but high-profile marketplace that opens for business every morning outside home-improvement, paint, gardening and equipment-rental stores across the United States.

The resulting work is dispersed among neighbourhoods and job sites: a crew laying down roofing on a new condominium development, a couple of workers mowing a lawn, laborers helping to pour a concrete retaining wall.

The cheapness and productiveness of day laborers has kept many homeowners, as well as residential construction and gardening contractors, coming back for more over decades. And it has reduced the cost of living for millions.

Although day labor markets have existed in the United States for at least 170 years, their recent boom has been partly a response to the housing bubble of the past decade, fueled by an increase in immigration from Mesoamerica. The plentiful supply of cheap labor, in turn, has helped to lower costs and drive increased housing construction.

When the bubble began to deflate, day laborers were among the first and hardest-hit casualties. "Day labor is where the rubber meets the road in the economic downturn," observed Chris Newman, legal director of the National Day laborer Organising Network, a consortium of support organisations across the country.

As residential construction and discretionary income flat-lined, most network members reported sharp drops in jobs, beginning a year ago and accelerating this fall.

"We're having people losing their houses, people not investing in their homes. So that's having a huge impact on the day laborer population nationwide," said Veronica Federovsky, NDLON West Coast coordinator. She estimates that total day labor hours could be down 60 percent from a year ago: not only is the number of jobs reduced, but remaining jobs tend to last only a day or two rather than several days or weeks.

In some areas, worker centres that support day laborers are encountering a new trend: some employers are offering lower hourly wages. With a recent base wage of around 10 dollars for unskilled work, even many workers who could find jobs were already struggling to pay the rent, buy food, and send a little home to their families in Mexico or Central America.

As demand drops for day laborers, supply appears to be swelling with workers laid off from jobs in the formal economy. Nationally, unemployment has risen from 4.7 percent to 6.7 percent in the past year. Now day laborer advocates are seeing more U.S. citizens seeking work on the corners along with immigrants.

In an atmosphere where federal raids on workplaces have branded immigrants as criminals, local treatment of day laborers in the economic downturn has varied widely across the country. In Arizona, aggressive street sweeps by one sheriff have intimidated and angered immigrants and citizens across the political spectrum. Aurora, Colorado, a suburb of Denver, recently passed an ordinance aimed at clearing day laborers out of the centre of town.

Other cities, though, have resisted pressures on local law enforcement to cooperate with federal immigration authorities. Los Angeles recently passed an ordinance requiring new and renovated big-box home-improvement stores to create plans for accommodating the day labor markets they have attracted. This could include providing shade, water, restrooms and other basic amenities for day laborers.

Existing centres outside such stores already offer a "host of benefits to both workers and consumers, such as better wages, an orderly hiring process and more reliable workers," according to Professor Abel Valenzuela, Jr. of the University of California, Los Angeles.

In response to the economic crash, some workers say they are planning to return to Mexico or Central America. In the past, it was common for workers to make the trek home in the off season and return the next year, but now the increased costs and dangers of crossing the border make circular migration a more difficult option.

In northerly cities like Seattle, some day laborers have traditionally left for the southern U.S. in the winter. But now local economies are even worse in much of California and the Southwest.

The coordinator of an organisation of Mexicans abroad, Al Rojas, told the Mexican daily La Jornada that he expected thousands of migrants to leave the U.S. in coming months because of the collapse of construction.

Immigration to the U.S. from Mexico has already dropped off dramatically, 42 percent in the past two years according to the Mexican government's statistical institute. The U.S. Census Bureau found that immigration from all countries declined by nearly one half in 2007.

Many day laborers, though, say that economic conditions at home are even worse than here. The best among bad alternatives? Come back to the corner tomorrow and hope for work.

Enjoy this piece?

… then let us make a small request. AlterNet’s journalists work tirelessly to counter the traditional corporate media narrative. We’re here seven days a week, 365 days a year. And we’re proud to say that we’ve been bringing you the real, unfiltered news for 20 years—longer than any other progressive news site on the Internet.

It’s through the generosity of our supporters that we’re able to share with you all the underreported news you need to know. Independent journalism is increasingly imperiled; ads alone can’t pay our bills. AlterNet counts on readers like you to support our coverage. Did you enjoy content from David Cay Johnston, Common Dreams, Raw Story and Robert Reich? Opinion from Salon and Jim Hightower? Analysis by The Conversation? Then join the hundreds of readers who have supported AlterNet this year.

Every reader contribution, whatever the amount, makes a tremendous difference. Help ensure AlterNet remains independent long into the future. Support progressive journalism with a one-time contribution to AlterNet, or click here to become a subscriber. Thank you. Click here to donate by check.

Close
alternet logo

Tough Times

Demand honest news. Help support AlterNet and our mission to keep you informed during this crisis.