Gender Discrimination Has Its Day in Court

(The full text of this article appears in the Spring issue of Ms. magazine, available on newsstands and by subscription from

The first jury gave Lindy Vivas, the women's volleyball coach, $5.85 million. Diane Milutinovich, the associate athletic director, settled out of court for $3.5 million. And the third case ended with a head-spinning $19 million jury verdict for Stacy Johnson-Klein, the women's basketball coach.

All three women had complained about gender equity in the sports department at Fresno State University, situated in California's verdant Central Valley. All three lost their jobs. All three then sued for some combination of sex discrimination, retaliation and discrimination based on sexual orientation.

There have been many victories under Title IX -- the 1972 legislation that commanded federally funded educational institutions not to sex-discriminate in any area, including sports -- but the three cases that rocked Fresno State University's sports department last year stand out for their enormity.

The trials last fall were everyday news for months in Fresno, a town of 500,000 that's the gateway to Sierra mountain resorts such as Yosemite -- and the cases still haven't reached closure: Even after judges cut down the jury awards (to $4.52 million for Vivas and $6.62 million for Johnson-Klein, plus additional attorney's fees), the university appealed both. On top of that, Margie Wright, the school's legendary softball coach -- the only coach in Fresno State history to take a team to an NCAA national championship -- has hired legal counsel to deal with her longtime gender-equity complaints, whether by settlement or trial.

Meanwhile, an infuriated California state senator from the Fresno area, Dean Florez, has taken the university's president and the chancellor of the California State University (CSU) system to task during two hearings, and has threatened further action. "We were dumbfounded at the amount of insensitivity," says Florez, a Democrat. "We want the university to get it, and we don't think they get it yet."

The first to be let go was Milutinovich. In April, 2002, she was given three days to resign, retire, or move to a position outside of athletics. The reason for her termination? A supposed budget crunch. But subsequently, the athletic department added six positions and its budget increased nearly 5 percent.

"Isn't that a little obvious?" asks Milutinovich. "[They eliminated my position because] I asked too many questions and insisted on equity."

Vivas was next to be shown the door.

After having taken her team to the NCAA tournament in 2002 and being named coach of the year in her conference, she asked for a five-year contract similar to what the men's football and basketball coaches received but was offered only a two-year contract -- with performance clauses that no other coach, male or female, had to meet. When that contract was up, she wasn't offered a new one. "Which we all know in athletics means you're fired," she says.

Meanwhile, Stacy Johnson-Klein had been hired as women's basketball coach, and the glamorous six-foot-tall blonde was supposed to be the woman who made the men in Fresno State's athletic department more comfortable. The more jockish and outspoken Militunovich, Vivas and Wright -- women who didn't let any inequity go unnoticed -- obviously made them squirm.

"You'll be on our team, the 'home team,'" athletic director Scott Johnson told Johnson-Klein (no relation). "That was code for being straight," she explains.

The harassment began not long after Johnson-Klein came on board. First, Johnson made a pass at her while they were in a carwash. Then, the new associate athletic director allegedly began a running commentary on her clothing, telling her that her blouse was too low-cut, her pants too tight. Johnson-Klein also began to notice the same sort of gender inequities that grated on Vivas and Wright -- perks and monies offered to the men's teams but not hers. She started filing written complaints. In February 2005, she was put on leave without explanation, then fired -- and Fresno State, with shocking disregard for employee confidentiality, put up on its website a 380-page report of accusations against her.

"Of course no one complained of alleged improprieties at the time they occurred," says one of her lawyers, Dan Siegel (who also represents Milutinovic, Vivas and Wright). "It was only after she was suspended and they were looking for stuff to dump on her."

By the time the cases went to court, there was a new "home team": Johnson-Klein testified for Vivas, Vivas testified for Johnson-Klein and Milutinovich and Wright testified for both of them. "There was no way I was going to turn my back on somebody who was treated that way," says Wright. "I was going to stand up for her." "Now we're good friends," says Johnson-Klein.

Stung by the verdicts, Fresno State has now added two new women's sports and developed a five-year Gender Equity Plan. But Fresno State administrators remain in self-protect mode: Neither university President John Welty nor CSU chancellor Charles Reed have ever admitted any wrongdoing. State Sen. Florez has called for Welty's resignation to no avail, but has also set forth a bill that would create an independent office of gender equity under the state's attorney general.

"Handling this case opened my eyes," says Johnson-Klein's other lawyer, Warren Paboojian, a self-confessed former male chauvinist. "Women should have the same opportunity to compete in sports and get that enjoyment and benefit that men get, and they often don't. These women helped educate me."

Understand the importance of honest news ?

So do we.

The past year has been the most arduous of our lives. The Covid-19 pandemic continues to be catastrophic not only to our health - mental and physical - but also to the stability of millions of people. For all of us independent news organizations, it’s no exception.

We’ve covered everything thrown at us this past year and will continue to do so with your support. We’ve always understood the importance of calling out corruption, regardless of political affiliation.

We need your support in this difficult time. Every reader contribution, no matter the amount, makes a difference in allowing our newsroom to bring you the stories that matter, at a time when being informed is more important than ever. Invest with us.

Make a one-time contribution to Alternet All Access, or click here to become a subscriber. Thank you.

Click to donate by check.

DonateDonate by credit card
Donate by Paypal
{{ }}