Attorney General Nominee Mukasey Refuses to Call Waterboarding Torture
October 19, 2007
This post, written by Lindsay Beyerstein, originally appeared on Majikthise
Talking Points Memo brings us this clip from the Mukasey confirmation hearings, in which Sheldon Whitehouse (D-RI) presents the AG-to-be with the following question: Is waterboarding constitutional?
Mukasey's answer?
If waterboarding is torture, then it's not constitutional.
Okay...
Let's put this another way. Is a convincing simulation of drowning that can cause brain and lung damage torture?
I don't know about you guys, but drowning is one of the ways I'd least like to die. Anything that simulates drowning has got to be torture--especially when it involves extreme pain and potential organ damage, or even death. It's difficult to know what the complication rate is for waterboarding because it's not something that any ethical physician or research institution would ever inflict on humans...or animals for that matter.
Talking Points Memo brings us this clip from the Mukasey confirmation hearings, in which Sheldon Whitehouse (D-RI) presents the AG-to-be with the following question: Is waterboarding constitutional?
Mukasey's answer?
If waterboarding is torture, then it's not constitutional.
Okay...
Let's put this another way. Is a convincing simulation of drowning that can cause brain and lung damage torture?
I don't know about you guys, but drowning is one of the ways I'd least like to die. Anything that simulates drowning has got to be torture--especially when it involves extreme pain and potential organ damage, or even death. It's difficult to know what the complication rate is for waterboarding because it's not something that any ethical physician or research institution would ever inflict on humans...or animals for that matter.
