Open Borders Make Good Neighbors
Not long ago, half a dozen people calling themselves the Lone Star Minutemen descended on a corner in the college town near our farm to protest illegal immigration. Every day at this corner, undocumented Latino men gather in hope of landing a day's work with passing contractors.
These Minutemen appropriated their name from the militia of the American Revolution, who had to be ready to swap plows for muskets in a minute to defend their new country. Those independent small farmers became a cornerstone of the United States' civic mythology. Indeed, Thomas Jefferson believed them to be both source and guardian of democracy itself.
Today's Minutemen want stricter limits on immigration. But that approach would shut out people who come as close as anyone to making reality of Jefferson's vision. That's certainly true of some Mexican neighbors of mine -- hardworking folks who farm other people's land, scraping and saving until they can afford a few acres of their own. Against all odds, some are making that dream come true.
My Mexican neighbors, and others like them all over the United States, are also one of the first rays of hope that farm country has seen in many a moon.Ã‚Â Ever since the Dust Bowl days of the 1930s, manyÃ‚Â rural counties have been losing people.Ã‚Â BetweenÃ‚Â 1990 and 2000, Latino immigrantsÃ‚Â have keptÃ‚Â more than 100 rural counties fromÃ‚Â suffering that fate, according to the Agriculture Department.
Latinos are also the fastest growing group among farmers, whose numbers have been declining for decades. Nationwide, the number of Hispanic farmers doubled between 1997 and 2002, even as the overall number of farmers continued to dwindle.
The United States has its own trade policies to thank for the rising number of farmers migrating here from Mexico. As heavy U.S. farm subsidies flood Mexican markets with cheap corn, farmers there earn less on the corn they grow. Many of them have no choice but to go looking for another job. In that search, many learn the hard way that "free trade" agreements open borders only to wealth -- freeing it to go wherever it can multiply the quickest -- but not to the people impoverished by that process.
Combining an agricultural policy that ruins Mexico's farmers with immigration laws that keep them from rescuing the United States' own rural economies makes little sense and less justice. That lack is plain in the modern-day Minutemen's un-neighborly attitudes, and in the draconian immigration bill currently before the Senate. The bill would put up a new fence along theÃ‚Â U.S.-MexicoÃ‚Â border, use police and military troops to patrol it and make illegal immigration a felony.
Such schemes punish not only immigrants, but also the "natives" who still inhabit -- and value -- rural communities. Farming as a way of life is tough, rewarding and vanishing. I welcome people -- any peopleÃ‚Â Ã‚Â -- who will keep it going, and I want an immigration policy that doesn't get in their way. The National Immigrant Farming Initiative (immigrantfarming.org) has an approach I like, investing in immigrant farmers' contribution to U.S. agriculture with training, translation and the chance to network with other farmers.
My family has lived on the land that we farm for five generations and counting, but I try not to feel smug about that. For all I know, a like smugness may have inspired the earlier "natives" who scalped my great-great-grandfather. Wind the clock back far enough, and we are all newcomers -- all with something to contribute, all in need of, and eager to return, a helping hand.
However different our origins, the same economic winds blew my neighbors and me into the little stretch of country that we share. Like it or not, we're neighbors, and that fact carries certain obligations -- of fairness and decency, of neighborliness. We ignore those obligations only at the peril of losing community, democracy and even freedom itself.