alternet logo

Tough Times

Demand honest news. Help support AlterNet and our mission to keep you informed during this crisis.

Rice's Africa Reach

Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice visited Africa last week for the first time in her official capacity. For many African Americans and African women, who take pride in Rice's international stature, her trip to Senegal and Sudan was too little and too long in coming, reflecting perhaps a lack of concern. Others bask in the glory of one of their own being in such a powerful position.

As the first woman of color to serve as a Secretary of State, Rice is the center of intense scrutiny and comment by black women throughout the world.

For example, Sokari Ekine, a Nigerian blogger, features a "Rice Watch" section that takes frequent pot shots at the U.S. secretary of state, depicting her as a champion of corporate interests that not only are not shared by black women, but do them outright harm.

In Ekine's view, U.S. support of multinationals in Africa is eroding the livelihoods of many black women. And that, she says, means that the cons of Rice's foreign policy agenda outweigh the pros of her attaining one of the highest roosts in international politics.

"The privatization of public services has, for example, already impacted on the lives of South African women who cannot afford to pay the high costs of water," she says. "This has also led to the criminalization of women as they steal water from their neighbors in a desperate attempt to maintain their dignity."

While Ekine is not alone in her views, some black female pundits have applauded Rice for raising the international stature of black women while keeping quiet on the Bush administration policies she represents.

One expert says that these strikingly different views reflect an ambivalence felt by many.

"As much as African Americans want to herald the appointment of our first black woman to ascend to the position of U.S. Secretary of State, Dr. Rice's world view, policies and priorities are contrary to the interests of African descended people around the planet," said Ramona Edelin, a scholar and treasurer of the Black Leadership Forum in Washington, D.C., in a February interview with National Public Radio.

First Visit to Africa

Until last week, when the Secretary of State traveled Tuesday to Dakar, Senegal, to attend a conference of Washington's African Growth and Opportunity Act--where she stressed a commitment to U.S. and African trade--Rice had not visited the region in her new official capacity. Her visit follows First Lady Laura Bush's weeklong trip to Africa recently.

Last Wednesday Rice flew to Sudan, where she visited a refugee camp in the conflict-ridden Darfur region and spoke privately to women affected by ongoing sexual violence. Rice reaffirmed the U.S. position on Darfur saying, "The United States believes that by our accounts it was and is genocide."

Some black women felt Rice should have made the trip sooner, in light of this year's focus on Africa at the recent summit of the Group of 8--the annual meeting of the most heavily developed industrialized nations. In addition, the international concerns about the genocide in Darfur and the ongoing war in the Democratic Republic of the Congo also seemed to call for a visit from Rice.

"It is disturbing that Rice is just visiting Africa, especially considering the theme of this year's G-8 summit," says Bassey Ikpi, a Nigerian-born writer living in New York City.

Rice cut her trip short to go to Israel and the West Bank to demonstrate U.S. concern about the recent rise of violence in the area, a move some saw as an error.

"This sends a clear signal that the Middle East is more important in her eyes, and Africa--the land of her own ancestors --is at the very bottom of the U.S. foreign policy agenda," said Salih Booker, executive director of Africa Action, a Washington-based group.

Aissato Bey has a very different view. Like many, the longtime community activist in New York believes Rice's accomplishments are "admirable." She adds, "She is what white people think we should be." However, even though she is "not okay with her having done very little for the betterment of the community," she sees nothing to gain in singling out Rice for attack.

"Airing our dirty laundry is not our way. The media is already saturated with negative images of us, so why should we give them more reason to distort our image?"

Notable Admiration

Going one step further is Dorothy Height. The chair and president emeritus of the National Council of Negro Women is notable for her outspoken praise of Rice. The organization, with an outreach to nearly 4 million women, has worked with African women and has offices in Dakar.

"Our nation will finally put forward a face that reflects the hopes of generations of black women, to sit at the table on national and global affairs and participate as equals," she wrote in the Washington Post.

Height noted that Rice had many global priorities to balance in her official role.

When asked whether Rice should have made a visit to the continent earlier, or if she was wrong to cut the trip short, Height says, "We have to bear in mind that a lot is happening in the world--Iraq, the war on terrorism. Her choices may not necessarily reflect her wishes but reality."

Distrust of U.S. Approach to Africa

Mentions of Rice are rare on black media outlets or Web sites of black women's organizations--such as the National Coalition of 100 Black Women or Black Career Women. An ingredient of this reticence is an often open distrust of Bush administration policies in Africa, say critics. Bush's public promises at July's G-8 summit are a recent example.

The president pledged $1.2 billion to help in the reduction of malaria deaths, and $55 million to improve legal protections for African women affected by sexual violence. Bush also proposed doubling the amount of U.S. aid to $400 million for the education of African girls.

Ann-Louise Colgan, director of policy analysis and communications at Africa Action, was quick to note that funding had not been guaranteed for the commitments and that only a handful of countries would benefit from these initiatives.

"The Bush Administration's Africa policy is more noteworthy for its public relations efforts than for any benefit to the African continent," Colgan said in a statement following Bush's aid pledge.

Many black women also said Rice was missing the chance to use her identity as a powerful black woman to benefit black girls.

"If she identified as a black woman she would send a powerful message to young black girls of success and triumph," says Ikpi, the Nigerian-born writer. "I am impressed with her success and that she has beat all odds to get to where she is," she says. But, she adds, Rice should make being a black woman part of her public persona, demonstrating she has not forgotten "those left behind."

For all of this, however, few black women wish to criticize Rice openly--either for her approach to Africa or anything else--saying there is no set of ideas or positions to which Rice, just because she is a black woman, should be expected to hold.

"We are a diverse group of people, so why must we tell the same story over and over again?" says Bey, the community activist.

Darlene Young, president of Blacks in Government, a Washington-based advocacy group for black civil servants, agrees.

"Rice has enhanced our image," says Young. "Non-blacks now recognize that we are a diverse group of people capable of being at the level of intelligence and power that Dr. Rice has."

Enjoy this piece?

… then let us make a small request. AlterNet’s journalists work tirelessly to counter the traditional corporate media narrative. We’re here seven days a week, 365 days a year. And we’re proud to say that we’ve been bringing you the real, unfiltered news for 20 years—longer than any other progressive news site on the Internet.

It’s through the generosity of our supporters that we’re able to share with you all the underreported news you need to know. Independent journalism is increasingly imperiled; ads alone can’t pay our bills. AlterNet counts on readers like you to support our coverage. Did you enjoy content from David Cay Johnston, Common Dreams, Raw Story and Robert Reich? Opinion from Salon and Jim Hightower? Analysis by The Conversation? Then join the hundreds of readers who have supported AlterNet this year.

Every reader contribution, whatever the amount, makes a tremendous difference. Help ensure AlterNet remains independent long into the future. Support progressive journalism with a one-time contribution to AlterNet, or click here to become a subscriber. Thank you. Click here to donate by check.

Close