Reconciling Allah

Reconciling AllahMy great aunt recently told me that queerness "never would have gotten to me if we'd stayed in Lebanon." She associates gayness, like fast food, cowboys, and Levi's, with Western culture. While hearing these messages from my aunt, I grew up in the U.S. where "Muslim," like "Arab," was synonymous with terrorism, hating women or dying in mobs. From either perspective I was taught, quite simply, that queer Muslims constitute an oxymoron; they do not exist.




















"I have never been driven from a Mosque, whipped publicly or deemed unworthy of Allah's compassion, but I could have, because I'm gay.

I have never been denied legal protection under the law, or medical treatment, or the right to participate in religious celebrations, but I could have, because I am gay.

I have never been driven from my home, rejected by my parents, or condemned by teachers and religious leaders, but I could have, because I am gay.

I am gay. And I am Muslim."

-- excerpted from an anonymous speech online



Never do we hear of the experiences of the three gay men in Afghanistan, who had a wall collapsed on top of them in 1998, while thousands of spectators, including the leader of the Muslim fundamentalist Taliban, looked on. Or, that same year, of the two lovers publicly whipped in Iran, 100 times each, for being lesbians.

Being gay is illegal in many Islamic countries, including Algeria, Bahrain, Jordan, Kuwait, Lebanon, Oman, Syria and the United Arab Emirates (UAE). However, in many of these same countries exist thriving queer communities, complete with gay clubs and human rights organizations. It is only in the fundamentalist populations (which, by far, are a minority) that being gay is deemed sinful and punishable by death. It is only according to these conservative leaders that being gay is immoral. Oftentimes Allah's name is invoked during public execution of gays, and yet nowhere in the Qur'an does it state, explicitly or implicitly, that death is the appropriate punishment for being gay. And all throughout the Middle East and the United States, queer people everywhere -- young queer people especially -- are disproving this myth by claiming their right to exist, to thrive and to love. And to be Muslim. "Love for Allah, love for Islam, love for my family, love for my partner; all of these are the same," says 19-year-old Linda Awad, born and raised in Syria. "The ways that so-called Muslims betray Islam by hating gays is the same way so-called Christians betrayed their religion by supporting slavery and racism. So much hatred "all in the name of God."

Growing up queer in the Middle East is, arguably, a very different experience than growing up queer in the Western world. For queer youth in the U.S., there is a myriad of resources available in our communities as well as online. In countries where fundamentalism prevails, however, the basic right of acknowledging your queerness within yourself can prove to be a tumultuous -- and isolating -- experience. It is because of that isolation that queer civil rights groups (such as the Iranian group Homan) have been established -- not merely for visibility purposes but also for solidarity. "[These] human rights groups are crucial to the queer community, especially youth who may be questioning their own sexuality but do not have the language to describe it, and thus stay silent in fear for their life -- literally," one queer youth (who wished to remain anonymous) had to add.

Online resources, then, are vital connections between the queers living in lavender bubbles like San Francisco with queers in places like Afghanistan. Discovering any kind of community -- cyber included -- has proven time and again integral to the coming out process of queer youth, especially those practicing a religion that, ostensibly, does not allow for much sexual freedom. Websites like Queer Jihad ("jihad" literally means an intense or holy struggle with oneself) and Al-Fatiha ("the opening") were created to help people reconcile their religion with their sexuality. The line between what is considered haram (forbidden) and halal (permissible) is slowly shifting, making it somewhat easier to combine Islam with queerness.

Dalilah, a young queer woman, tells her story: "As a Muslim woman, I struggled a lot with my sexuality. When I first started to have intimate feelings for other women, I tried very hard to ignore them. I let people arrange a marriage for me and convinced myself that I liked this man. In the end I broke off the engagement because I couldn't lie to myself or to him. After I came out to myself, I rejected Islam and God. I thought that if I no longer believed in this religion, I would not be bothered by my conscience and my upbringing. But, I was in a conflict with myself. Finally I told myself that if this God that I love created me the way I am, and I was taught that God was never wrong, then HE did not hate me."

Parents of queer Muslim youth dismiss their childrens identities as if they were simply products of living in a Western culture. It was somewhat ironic, then, for me when I started seeing queer references come up in Islamic spiritual texts. For instance I read about the Sufi Saint Jalaluddin Rumi, who uses earthly love as a metaphor for the love of the Divine or Allah, and yet uses metaphors in the form of his physical love for his male companion, Shams-e-Tabriz. Despite what my elders have said, I know that my sexuality is not a Western derivative. But the mere fact that they think it is, frustrates me.

But things are changing. I see young people around me beginning to come out, speak up and tell their story. Political asylum has been granted to queer Muslim refugees from fundamentalist societies in an unprecedented number of countries within recent years, and voices are finally beginning to be heard. The Muslim community is slowly changing, and maybe someday it will include and accept me and other queer people.

Enjoy this piece?

… then let us make a small request. AlterNet’s journalists work tirelessly to counter the traditional corporate media narrative. We’re here seven days a week, 365 days a year. And we’re proud to say that we’ve been bringing you the real, unfiltered news for 20 years—longer than any other progressive news site on the Internet.

It’s through the generosity of our supporters that we’re able to share with you all the underreported news you need to know. Independent journalism is increasingly imperiled; ads alone can’t pay our bills. AlterNet counts on readers like you to support our coverage. Did you enjoy content from David Cay Johnston, Common Dreams, Raw Story and Robert Reich? Opinion from Salon and Jim Hightower? Analysis by The Conversation? Then join the hundreds of readers who have supported AlterNet this year.

Every reader contribution, whatever the amount, makes a tremendous difference. Help ensure AlterNet remains independent long into the future. Support progressive journalism with a one-time contribution to AlterNet, or click here to become a subscriber. Thank you. Click here to donate by check.

Close