Cohen & Solomon: TV Talk is All Right Wing

Nobody would try to fly a plane with a right wing and no left wing. But on national television, political discussion shows have just such an imbalance. No wonder those programs wobble so weirdly. Take ABC's This Week With David Brinkley. Its pundit roundtable usually features rightist George Will along with establishment centrists Sam Donaldson and Cokie Roberts. No leftist need apply. Now that ABC has hired conservative William Kristol as an on-air political analyst, the Brinkley show -- whose executive producer is Bush administration official Dorrance Smith -- tilts even further rightward. A couple of weeks ago, the Brinkley roundtable was made up of Kristol, Will and Roberts. Why add Kristol to the panel? Why offer two rightists and no leftists? Or should we pretend Cokie Roberts is a firebrand of the left? In the real world, she might sue for slander if you called her "left-wing." The main "cause" she champions in Washington is the right of pundits to rake in big lecture fees from corporate interests. But in the make-believe world of TV, Roberts is the kind of pro-corporate centrist who passes as a liberal, the only alternative offered to the fire-breathers of the right. Network news executives and corporate sponsors seem to prefer TV debates that exclude half the political spectrum -- the half led by advocates for middle-class consumers, labor, the environment, minorities and others critical of the status quo. As we go to press, CNN's Crossfire -- the verbal food fight for adults -- is looking for a new co-host "on the left" to take on conservatives like Robert Novak and John Sununu. That role has been played by the departing Michael Kinsley, a columnist and self-described moderate. Crossfire is the show that made a national TV star (and presidential candidate) out of its right-wing co-host, Patrick Buchanan. But the man who originally co-hosted the show "from the left" is now little more than a trivia question: Tom Braden. Braden had unique credentials for representing the left on CNN. He'd been a high-ranking CIA official in Western Europe involved in covert operations against the left. (LSD guru Timothy Leary made one of his more sober observations when he referred to Crossfire as "the left wing of the CIA debating the right wing of the CIA.") Crossfire is now one of CNN's most watched shows, but it appears destined to remain as imbalanced as a one-winged airplane. The Los Angeles Times reported in late November that two "strong candidates" contending for Kinsley's job are Bob Beckel and Juan Williams. Formerly a Democratic campaign operative, Beckel now heads a lobbying and consulting firm that represents corporate clients like the Walt Disney conglomerate, long-distance phone companies and insurance firms involved in the battle over toxic waste cleanup. As a pundit, Beckel's views are often quite conservative. He consistently advises the Democratic Party to move rightward. In 1993, he hailed President Clinton's effort to downsize government as a great tactic to force a "showdown" with liberal Democrats, relishing that "the unions will grumble, the left will scream..." Beckel didn't just support the Gulf War; he denounced protesters as "punks." Last year, he applauded Clinton for rebuffing liberals who urged greater cuts in Pentagon spending. With such views, is Beckel an appropriate voice to represent "the left"? In the real world, no. On TV, perfect. The same could be said of Juan Williams, a Washington Post reporter. Search Williams' writings for his judgments on "liberals" or "the left," and you'll find more criticism than praise. Williams starred in a historic Crossfire episode about the Clarence Thomas/Anita Hill clash. Substituting as the left co- host, Williams was supposed to be a counterweight to Pat Buchanan, who wailed that liberal conspirators were persecuting Judge Thomas. But Williams agreed with Buchanan. Two days later, it looked like Buchanan had written Williams' column attacking "so-called champions of fairness: liberal politicians, unions, civil rights groups and women's organizations." The column concluded that "liberals have become monsters"; it led conservative Sen. Orrin Hatch to repeatedly praise Williams as "a great journalist" at the Thomas hearings. (At the time Williams threw himself into the Thomas defense, he himself was facing sexual harassment charges from "a number of women" in the Washington Post newsroom -- which led to disciplining and an apology from Williams after female employees protested his conduct.) I'm Juan Williams, from the left. Real world, no. On TV, yes. Williams, Beckel and other TV "leftists" express support for the right wing of the Democratic Party. They are well-cast only because TV debates are pseudo-symmetrical -- pitting conservative Republican pundits against conservative Democratic ones. What if the political shoe were on the other foot? Imagine the protests from groups like the Christian Coalition if CNN debates regularly featured left-wing Democrats against pundits reflecting the centrist Republican views of Senators John Chafee, William Cohen or Mark Hatfield. In recent weeks, the center-to-right TV pundit brigade has been expending surpluses of hot air about the budget. But we rarely hear calls for cuts in military spending. Or increased taxes on the wealthy. Or raising corporate income taxes -- which accounted for 25 percent of federal expenditures in the 1960s but only 14 percent now. Outside of Washington TV studios -- in the real world of grassroots politics, union halls, churches and college campuses -- such proposals make sense to a lot of people. In the real world, of course, airplanes with just one wing don't fly.

Enjoy this piece?

… then let us make a small request. AlterNet’s journalists work tirelessly to counter the traditional corporate media narrative. We’re here seven days a week, 365 days a year. And we’re proud to say that we’ve been bringing you the real, unfiltered news for 20 years—longer than any other progressive news site on the Internet.

It’s through the generosity of our supporters that we’re able to share with you all the underreported news you need to know. Independent journalism is increasingly imperiled; ads alone can’t pay our bills. AlterNet counts on readers like you to support our coverage. Did you enjoy content from David Cay Johnston, Common Dreams, Raw Story and Robert Reich? Opinion from Salon and Jim Hightower? Analysis by The Conversation? Then join the hundreds of readers who have supported AlterNet this year.

Every reader contribution, whatever the amount, makes a tremendous difference. Help ensure AlterNet remains independent long into the future. Support progressive journalism with a one-time contribution to AlterNet, or click here to become a subscriber. Thank you. Click here to donate by check.

alternet logo

Tough Times

Demand honest news. Help support AlterNet and our mission to keep you informed during this crisis.