Israel's Settlement Stalemate: Is There No End in Sight?

By William Pfaff, Truthdig. Posted July 1, 2009.

The Obama administration’s confrontation with Israel over its colonies inside the Palestine territories began as a test of Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s willingness to enter serious negotiations on a Middle Eastern settlement. It actually possesses potential dimensions that few today imagine.

Netanyahu first counted on the Likud and settlement lobbies in Washington to produce, as always in the past, a disingenuous formula that would allow the colonies to continue to expropriate Palestinian land and expand the settlements, while the American government oversaw essentially meaningless negotiations with the Palestinians.

The prime minister was in Europe this week, and told RAI, Italian state radio, that after President Barack Obama had declared in his Cairo speech that the construction of new settlements must stop, he—Netanyahu—had replied “No” but had accepted Obama’s call for a two-state solution with the Palestinians, provided that it took place under specified conditions. Previously Netanyahu had rejected the two-state approach.

The conditions would deny a prospective Palestine state of full sovereignty, control of its frontiers or of its security, economy and trade, airspace, and water and other natural resources. The conditions are obviously unacceptable, as they are meant to be.

Netanyahu’s proposal constituted a message to the Palestinians that they should expect nothing from his government, and to Obama that Israel expects the United States to ask nothing further from it, and to resume the meaningless negotiations that have gone on since the first President Bush tried and failed to confront Israel on extension of the settlements.

The Israeli prime minister went on to say, “I think the more we spend time arguing about [the settlements] the more we waste time instead of moving towards peace.”

On Wednesday, he paid an official visit to France, expecting congratulations on his agreement to the creation of a Palestinian state. Instead, President Nicolas Sarkozy told him that France “would no longer accept Israeli subterfuges meant to disguise colony construction by the pretext of ‘natural growth’ in the settlements.”

This position already had been characterized by Israeli Foreign Minister Avigdor Lieberman as making it “impossible [for Israel] to build synagogues or kindergartens, or to add rooms for a family.”

Lieberman, who immigrated to Israel from Moldova, wishes that Israel’s Arab citizens—survivors of the original Arab population of what is now Israel—be given special identity documents and be encouraged to quit Israel. One might think that if they did depart they would leave real estate vacancies that could accommodate expanding Jewish settler families.

See more stories tagged with: israel, obama, palestine, west bank, netanyahu, gaza, settlements

Visit William Pfaff's Web site at WilliamPfaff.com

Liked this story? Get top stories in your inbox each week from World! Sign up now »