The Female Condom: Sexual Freedom Doesn't Come Free

By Lauren Sisson, RH Reality Check. Posted April 30, 2008.

" ... Capital gets its first Female Condom Machine -- an effective step towards women's emancipation ... freedom of protection, freedom from STDs and, above all, freedom from embarrassment."

-- Times of India, "Female condoms -- freedom at last?"

Most would consider female condom vending machines in bars and night clubs a positive step toward increased access to safe sex technologies. But others would question the professed "emancipatory" qualities of the female condom. Over the last six months, the Center for Health and Gender Equity has interviewed experts involved in various aspects of global female condom availability, and several expressed skepticism regarding female condoms as a "liberating" tool for women.

They have reason to be skeptical. With roughly one female condom available for every 100 women in the developing world, and only five cents spent on female condom procurement for every U.S. dollar spent on male condom procurement, female condoms will not be freeing women from the risk of HIV infection, unintended pregnancy, or male-dependent prevention methods any time soon.

Lack of product investment, however, cannot be confused with product failure. As the host of the Prevention Now! campaign, CHANGE regularly receives emails from organizations abroad requesting supplies of female condoms. Rather than suggesting product failure, these requests are evidence that an obvious need is not being met. Why do these organizations want female condoms?

• Female condoms are the only approved and available HIV prevention method designed for women to initiate and control.
• Studies have shown that making female condoms available in the same market as male condoms increases the overall number of protected sex acts and reduces the rate of STIs.
• In situations where one or both partners refuse to use a male condom, female condoms provide an additional, and sometimes preferred, prevention option.
• Female condoms can increase sexual pleasure: the non-latex products can be used with oil-based lubricants and massage oils; the fact that they can be inserted up to eight hours prior to intercourse means their use does not have to interrupt foreplay; and men have reported that its one-size-fits-all design increases pleasure and some women have found that the outer ring adds to their sexual stimulation.

If the problem is not the product itself, what will it take to ensure that female condoms provide women with freedom of self-protection as described in the Times of India article? This is one of several questions CHANGE sets out to answer in its new publication Saving Lives Now: Female Condoms and the Role of U.S. Foreign Aid. In particular, Saving Lives Now seeks to answer what more the U.S. government, as the largest donor to the global fight against HIV/AIDS and international contraceptive and condom supplies, should do to ensure that female condoms reach their full prevention potential.

Saving Lives Now does not assert that increased global access to female condoms alone will simultaneously empower the world's women to take control of their sexuality and end the global AIDS crisis. As the report points out, female condoms are not the perfect method for everyone. But as we develop programs that provide women with information about female condoms, how they work, and how to negotiate their use, we take an important step toward guaranteeing comprehensive, good quality reproductive and sexual health services that foster human rights, empowerment, and a full range of prevention choices for every woman.

See more stories tagged with: global, hiv, female condom, stis, safe sex

Lauren Sisson is the program assistant at the Center for Health and Gender Equity (CHANGE). She has been involved in sexual and reproductive health advocacy for several years.

Liked this story? Get top stories in your inbox each week from AlterNet! Sign up now »