comments_image -

What Made Obama's Speech Great

The true power of the speech is that it does what it says. It not only talks about empathy, it creates it.
 
 
LIKE THIS ARTICLE ?
Join our mailing list:

Sign up to stay up to date on the latest headlines via email.

 
 
 
 

We are on the cusp of a new politics in America. It should be dated from March 18, 2008, the date of Barack Obama's landmark speech "A More Perfect Union." The usual pundits have looked mainly at the speech's surface theme: race. They weren't wrong. It was indeed the most important statement about race in recent history.

But it was much more. It was a general call to a new politics and an outline for what it needs to be. Just as Lincoln's Gettysburg Address was about much more than the war dead on that battlefield, so Obama's speech -- widely hailed as in the same ballpark as Lincoln's -- went beyond race to the nature of America, its ideals and its future.

To get an appreciation for the greatness of Obama's speech, we have to start with its context: What were the problems Obama faced in writing it, and what were the constraints on him?

He was under severe political attack, both from Republican conservatives and from the Clinton wing of his own party. Here's what he was facing:

  • Racial divisions and identity politics had been injected into the campaign by his opponents and the media. The effect was to position him, as an African-American, as being opposed to the interests of whites and Hispanics.
  • An attack on his and his wife's patriotism.
  • A claim that he was really a Muslim.
  • A repeatedly shown film clip of his long-time pastor, Jeremiah Wright, who had married him and his wife and baptized his daughters, making embarrassing remarks taken as anti-American and anti-Semitic.
  • One of the hallmarks of his campaign has been good judgment on foreign policy; his opponents claimed that his connection to Wright had shown bad judgment.
  • Another hallmark of his campaign has been authenticity, telling the truth. Two of his advisors had made remarks -- one on NAFTA and one on Iraq -- that opponents had twisted to make it seem that he was lying. He had to establish himself as truthful.
  • Another hallmark of his campaign has been values. His opponents had claimed that his values were unknown and that the public didn't know who he was.
  • His opponents had claimed that he could not stand up to strong opposition.
  • He was in the center of an intensely divisive campaign while pressing unity as a major theme.
  • His opponents had claimed that his eloquence was all talk and no action.

In addition, Sen. Obama faced certain constraints on what he could say:

  • He understands that people vote primarily on the basis of character and how he would govern: on values, authenticity, trust and identity, and only secondarily on fine policy details (See Thinking Points). He could not ignore the problems and hope they would go away. They wouldn't. Since he was being attacked on all of these character and governance issues, he had to confront them all.
  • He had been putting forth a vision of bipartisanship opposite that of Sen. Clinton. In her bipartisanship, she moved to the right, giving up on fundamental values. In his bipartisanship, he understands that "conservatives" and "independents" often share fundamental American values with him. Instead of giving up on his values, he finds those outside his party who share them. His speech had to have such an appeal.
  • The honesty and openness of his declared new politics required him to be consistent with his previous statements.
  • He could not explicitly go negative and still continue to campaign on civility and unity. He could only go positive and evoke implicit negatives.
  • He could neither accept his opponents framing of him, nor argue explicitly against that framing. If he did either, he would just strengthen their frames. He had to impose his own framing, while being true to his values and his campaign themes.
  • He could not go on the defensive; that would just encourage his detractors. He had to show leadership.
  • submit to reddit

    -
    Email
    Print
    Share
    LIKED THIS ARTICLE? JOIN OUR EMAIL LIST
    Stay up to date with the latest AlterNet headlines via email
    See more stories tagged with: speech, race, barack obama, framing, linguistics
    Advertisement
    Most Read
    Most Emailed
    Most Discussed
    On REDDIT
    On DIGG
     
    loading most read content ..
    Advertisement
    Fox Blames Obama for Manufactured "Gas Crisis," Even After Prices Fall

    By Shauna Theel | Media Matters

     
     
    Why Did the Associated Press Make an Anti-Choice 'Correction'?

    By Robin Marty | RH Reality Check

     
     
    Minimum Wage Not Enough for a 2-Bedroom Unit in Any State (Unless You Work Way More Than a 40-Hr Week)

    By Staff | AlterNet

     
     
    Minnesota Campaign Finance and Public Disclosure Board Will Investigate ALEC for Lobbying Violations

    By Kristen Gwynne | AlterNet

     
     
    Obama and Targeted Assassinations: Had Secret Kill List, Calls Killing American-Born Cleric "Easy Decision"

    By Sarah Seltzer | AlterNet

     
     
    Romney Excuse for Birther Trump Endorsement: I'm Running for Office and I Wanna Win!

    By Adele M. Stan | AlterNet

     
     
    Women's Center In New Orleans Destroyed By Arson, Third Incident in the South

    By Sarah Seltzer | AlterNet

     
     
    US Productivity Up, Wages Stagnant

    By Sarah Seltzer | AlterNet

     
     
    Scott Walker's Recall Strategy: Avoid Anyone Who Isn't A Walker Voter Already

    By Laura Clawson | Daily Kos

     
     
    Radioactive Bluefin Tuna Contaminated by Fukishima Reaches US Shores

    By Agence France-Presse

     
     
     
     
     
    loading ...
    POWERED BY DIGG'S USERS
     
    [ page served from web 2 ]