The Lending Crisis Is Becoming a Poltical Battleground
Stay up to date with the latest headlines via email.
So where is this credit crisis going? How will it end? What's the prognosis?
As the citizen of a country without an attention span, everyone wants some else to play forecaster and tick off what must be done. And they want it quick and simple even though there are no real quickie responses to a complicated problem. Almost any reassuring soundbite will do. The questions are predicable. What should I do to protect my money? Can't they fix this, after all our economy is supposed to be, oh so, "resilient?"
And yes your government is trying. George Bush doesn't want to leave office with two million families in the streets. He doesn't want a legacy worse that Herbert Hoovers. The loss of the incompletely managed war in Iraq is a tough enough burden to carry around.
Its probably truthful but not helpful to say that the mismanagement of our economy is an outgrowth of the very corporatist policies that will haunt this country for decades to come, including costly wars, and obscenely high levels of corruption and the list goes on.
This crisis, however is a bit different because it has built in intensity for years without much visibility or attention. It speaks to structural problems in an economy built on the quick sand of debt and delusion.
In order for the economy to function, in order for consumption to continue and profits to keep flowing, people have to believe that everything's all right. They want remedies modeled after Alka Seltzer . Put one tablet in water. It fizzes. You drink and feel better in minutes.
The truth is that confidence is eroding not because "the masses" hate capitalism but because our brand of unregulated capitalism is increasingly not working for them. They know that because prices keep rising and good paying jobs are harder to find. They know that because crime is going up in many cities, and it's harder to make ends meet.
And some even know that the very concept of the masses has been replaced by highly stratifies classes built on growing income inequality.
The credit cad companies are now encouraging us to pay our rent by charging it, They have jacked up their fees and passed rules that just somehow leads to more late fees and other charges which have doubled and tripled by fiat. Some economic wise men believe that the credit card bubble is the next to go in a widely predicted severe recession.
Personally, I don't know will happen with any certainty.. It is possible that we will bounce back from the precipice somehow. The big chiefs of our economy have done it before. There are whole industries at risk if we don't. There are a large number of wealthy people and institutions who want to get back to the business of making money. They have a strong self-interest in "normalizing" the system.
What's "normal" for then is of course why we are in the trouble we are. At the same time, many of the free marketers argue that all is needed is a correction of some undefined kind to put the "fundamentals" in line and bounce back. Capitalism has had history of boom and bust cycles and recoveries because there is no perceived alternative. And yes a depression is not out of the question.
Yet this time around, we are not talking about a small issue or some anomaly. As Business Week noted, "What we're observing, in all its bizarreness, is the ancient paradox of what happens when an irresistible force meets an immovable object. The irresistible force in this case is the U.S. economyâ€¦ The immovable object is a wall of debt that now can't be paid back."
As I write in early December of 2007, we do know that the Federal Reserve Bank is likely to cut interest rates again and Treasury Secretary Hank Paulson, a former honcho at Goldman Sachs, is proposing a plan to freeze interest rates on adjustable rate mortgages as one way to keep some homeowners from losing their homes.
Are these measures likely to work? Not based on their track record so far. The Fed has injected billions into the system to create more liquidity but the crisis is worse than ever. Paulson convinced big banks to start a super fund but that hasn't had much impact yet.
Many of the reports about the initiative were positive-there were 282 listed on Google. But one of them actually did off some analysis by a conservative who, this is rich, compares the supercapitalist Paulson to a communist. Seth Jayson, writing on the financial website Motley Fool called it "a plan to punish the public," and a reminder that there are away unintended and unspoken of consequences of governmental intervention in the affairs of the holy sanctum of the market:
"If the mortgage crisis and housing bubble have taught us one thing, it should be to watch out for the unintended consequences of greed. Unfortunately, our nation's legislators and political appointees haven't learned that lesson. Recent plans for housing and mortgage bailouts generally run from dumb to dumber.
While an intense debate rages, lay-offs continue on Wall Street with top female executives especially getting the blame and the axe at some investment banks. Meanwhile, credit has tightened for everyone, including businesses that live on loans, and the rich are blaming the poor while downward economic mobility becomes a pervasive new fact of life.
There is a conflict coming, as this problem turns into an issue. It could lead to an economic civil war. Its won't be just a working class led class war either. Says credit expert Robert Manning:
"What we've seen with this kind of financialization of the American economy, where the democratic system and so many democratic institutions have been co-opted and literally bought by the financial service industry, is that we're seeing a big backlash from the American people.
On opening salvo in this fight back will be a March on Wall Street led by Jesse Jackson on December l0. Already other protests against predatory lenders are breaking out like acne across the country.
The squeeze is on, and to quote the 60s poet, Mr. Zimmerman, "there's a hard rain that's gonna fall." The economy we save may be our own.