comments_image -

If you said yes at any point, it's not a rape

Women, you can't change your mind
October 31, 2006  |  
 
Advertisement
 

Jessica finds what she describes as "perhaps one of the scariest rulings I've ever seen," and I totally agree:

An appellate court said Maryland's rape law is clear -- no doesn't mean no when it follows a yes and intercourse has begun.

A three-judge panel of the Court of Special Appeals Monday threw out a rape conviction saying that a trial judge in Montgomery County erred when he refused to answer the jury's question on that very point.

The appeals court said that when the jury asked the trial judge if a woman could withdraw her consent after the start of sex, the jury should have been told she could not. The ruling said the law is not ambiguous and is a tenet of common-law.
This is truly, deeply disturbing. As Jessica says: "So ladies, once it's in, it's in. Ain't nothing you can do about it. Changed your mind? Suck it up. He's hurting you? Oh, sorry -- should have thought of that before. After all, it's not like your body is yours or anything." Patently absurd. What kind of FUBAR ethical paradigm allows someone to argue that consent to have sex means you cannot change your mind if you're being hurt or forced to do something you don't want to do or any one of a number of other reasons, including just not bloody enjoying it?

The entire premise of this decision appears to be that women are not active players in the sexual act, but instead consent to turn their bodies over to their partners, who are then free to do with it whatever they please until they're damn well ready to be finished. Feministing commenter Thomas says: "They have made a policy choice that a man has a right to orgasm once intercourse begins and that this right supercedes a woman's right to decide who gets to be within the boundaries of her own body. That is a policy choice that cannot be justified except as bareknuckled patriarchy." Absolutely spot-on.

(Feministing)

Melissa McEwan writes and edits the blog Shakespeare's Sister.
submit to reddit

-
Email
Print
Share
LIKED THIS ARTICLE? JOIN OUR EMAIL LIST
Stay up to date with the latest AlterNet headlines via email
See more stories tagged with: rape
Alternet Special Coverage - Occupy Wall Street
Advertisement
Most Read
Most Emailed
Most Discussed
On REDDIT
On DIGG
 
loading most read content ..
Advertisement
Will the Supreme Court Outlaw Affirmative Action in Higher Education?

By Victor Goode | Colorlines

 
 
Tonight, Watch the Premiere of Nat Geo's New Series "American Weed"

By Staff | AlterNet

 
 
NYPD, Big Brother? New Document Shows Shocking Reach of the NYPD's Secret Surveillance of Muslims

By Kristen Gwynne | AlterNet

 
 
Update: Governor Comes Out Against Trans-Vaginal Ultrasound Provision in Virginia

By Sarah Seltzer | AlterNet

 
 
Obama Plans to Slash Corporate Tax Rate And Close Loopholes: Why It May Not Work

By Sarah Seltzer | AlterNet

 
 
Santorum's "Satan Warning" Speech: How Will It Play?

By Jed Lewison | Daily Kos

 
 
The Challenge to Status Quo Economics Everybody is Talking About

By Lynn Parramore | AlterNet

 
 
Virginia Governor Backs Off ‘State-Sponsored Rape’ Ultrasound Bill, Promises To ‘Review’ Measure

By Amanda Peterson Beadle | Think Progress

 
 
Mitt Romney's Most Robotic Speech Ever

By Sarah Seltzer | AlterNet

 
 
What “Rape Sonograms” Are Really About

By Soraya L. Chemaly | Feminist Wire

 
 
 
WhoWhatWhy.com
 
 
 
 
loading ...
POWERED BY DIGG'S USERS
 
[ page served from web 1 ]