Support AlterNet
Do you value the information you're getting from AlterNet? Please show your support with a tax-deductible donation.
Feedback
Tell us how we're doing.
On Censure, Democrats Wait for Godot
Corporate Accountability and WorkPlace:
When Will the Recovery Begin? Never
Robert B. Reich
DrugReporter:
The Supreme Court Resists Drug War Hysteria
Krystal Quinlan
Environment:
Are Climate-Change Deniers Guilty of Treason?
Eoin O'Carroll
Health and Wellness:
10 Dangerous Household Products You Should Never Use Again
Immigration:
Huron, California May not Exist in a Year
Viji Sundaram
Media and Technology:
Michael Jackson's Death Was Tragic, But He Was Little More Than an Icon of Mediocrity
Alisa Valdes-Rodriguez
Movie Mix:
Up: This Time, Pixar Has Gone Too Far
Eileen Jones
Politics:
Hunter Thompson Knew It Well: Robert McNamara's Vision for America Was Imperial and Elitist
Joe Costello
Reproductive Justice and Gender:
My First Abortion Party
Byard Duncan
Rights and Liberties:
Does a Senior Obama Official Have Unseemly Ties to Notorious Human Rights Abuser Chevron?
Jeremy Scahill
Sex and Relationships:
How to Make Marriage More Than an Arrangement of Love-less, Sexless, Domestic Drudgery
Vanessa Richmond
Take Action:
Ending Indefinite Detention is AlterNet's Top Take Action Campaign of the Week
Byard Duncan
Water:
Energy Industry Threatens Water Quality, Sways Congress With Misleading Data
Abrahm Lustgarten
World:
Homesick For Dictatorship: East Germans Liked It Better Under Communism
Julia Bonstein
While the discussion of the proposed censure of President Bush has largely focused on the Democrats' hesitance to take a position, today's debate actually reveals failures by Congressional leaders in both political parties. Republicans refuse to investigate their President's misconduct while Democrats keep waiting for Godot, hoping for investigations that will never happen.
Many Democrats are stalling on censure with an old Washington tactic: Demand an investigation and wait. While Congressional inquiries can be valuable, they should not substitute for taking a stand. Yet it is the Republicans who control Congress and its investigatory committees. Their failing is graver than inaction -- they are abdicating their constitutional duty to conduct meaningful oversight of the Executive Branch.
Senator Russ Feingold's censure resolution is specific. It says Congress should censure the President for misleading Congress and unlawfully authorizing wiretaps of Americans "without obtaining the court orders" required by law.
There are essentially two parts to the resolution: a description of the President's actions and prescription for what to do about it.
Several Democrats, including leaders on intelligence issues such as Senators Carl Levin and Diane Feinstein, say they need an investigation on the first part before they can decide on the second part. Yet as First Amendment attorney Glenn Greenwald has emphasized, there is virtually no disagreement about the facts in the censure resolution. The Bush Administration has admitted it spied on Americans without warrants. In fact, it is now working with Congress to try to legalize more warrantless spying.
It would be disingenuous for people in either party to claim they don't know if the NSA conducted surveillance without warrants. The second part is, of course, a matter of opinion: Do the President's actions merit censure? Most Republicans have answered clearly. Democrats should do the same.
Yet the battle over a potential investigation goes beyond simply answering that question. The Republican Congress has been either negligent or complicit in each Bush Administration failure, while Democrats keep waiting for investigations that will never happen.
On virtually every major scandal of the Bush Presidency, Republicans in Congress have stifled investigations or turned the oversight process on its head -- manipulating it to cover up failures instead of to expose them. This is not just partisan politics. American history has many instances of a Congress providing legitimate oversight when the same party controlled the Presidency. (In one of the most famous examples, Senator Harry Truman took on a Democratic Administration during war to investigate defense spending.)
Ari Melber is a regular contributor to The Huffington Post. His commentary has appeared on AlterNet, The Nation Online and TomPaine.com, among others.
Liked this story? Get top stories in your inbox each week from AlterNet! Sign up now »