Support AlterNet
Do you value the information you're getting from AlterNet? Please show your support with a tax-deductible donation.
Feedback
Tell us how we're doing.
A Record of Injustice
Also in Top Stories
Drive 800 Miles or Feed a Person for a Year? The Biofuels Dilemma
Stan Cox, AlterNet
NYC's Staggering Arrest Rate for Pot Achieved By Police Deception and Scams
Steven Wishnia, AlterNet
Will the Mortgage Industry Pay for Its Crimes?
Danny Schechter, AlterNet
Our Media Have Been So Wrong for So Long
Jayne Lyn Stahl, AlterNet
The Superdelegate Problem
Bernard Weisberger, Truthdig
How Should States Deal with Polygamous Sects?
Faye Bowers, Christian Science Monitor
An August 2002 Justice Department memo "was vetted by a larger number of officials, including...the White House counsel's office and Vice President Cheney's office." According to Newsweek, the memo "was drafted after White House meetings convened by George W. Bush's chief counsel, Alberto Gonzales, along with Defense Department general counsel William Haynes and [Cheney counsel] David Addington." The memo included the opinion that laws prohibiting torture do "not apply to the President's detention and interrogation of enemy combatants." Further, the memo puts forth the opinion that the pain caused by an interrogation must include "injury such as death, organ failure, or serious impairment of body functions – in order to constitute torture." The methods outlined in the memo "provoked concerns within the CIA about possible violation of the federal torture law [and] also raised concerns at the FBI, where some agents knew of the techniques being used" overseas on high-level al Qaeda officials. [8/1/02 memo [PDF]; WP, 6/27/04; Newsweek, 6/21/04; NYT, 6/27/04]
A 1/25/02 memo written by White House Counsel Alberto Gonzales said "the war against terrorism is a new kind of war" and "this new paradigm renders obsolete Geneva's strict limitations on questioning of enemy prisoners and renders quaint some of its provisions." The memo pushes to make al Qaeda and Taliban detainees exempt from the Geneva Conventions' provisions on the proper, legal treatment of prisoners. The administration has been adamant that prisoners at Guantanamo are not protected by the Geneva Conventions. [1/25/02 memo [PDF]; Newsweek, 5/24/04]
The 1/25/02 memo shows Alberto Gonzales was aware of the risk that ignoring the Geneva Conventions could create for the military. One concern expressed is that failing to apply the Geneva Conventions "could undermine U.S. military culture which emphasizes maintaining the highest standards of conduct in combat, and could introduce an element of uncertainty in the status of adversaries," which is what happened at Abu Ghraib. Secretary of State Colin Powell strongly warned against taking this decision, as did lawyers from the Judge Advocate General's Corps, or JAG. This week, a federal judge ruled that "President Bush had both overstepped his constitutional bounds and improperly brushed aside the Geneva Conventions" when he established military tribunals in Guantanamo Bay, Cuba, to try detainees as war criminals. [1/25/02 memo [PDF]; Bloomberg, 6/14/04; New York Times, 11/9/04]
Liked this story? Get top stories in your inbox each week from AlterNet! Sign up now »
| More News and Analysis: | ||
|
Leader of al-Qa'ida in Iraq Reported "Captured" in Mosul Raid War on Iraq: The Iraqi Defense Ministry claims Washington's prime target, Abu Ayyub al-Masri, has been arrested, but the White House is skeptical. By James Macintyre, Independent UK. May 9, 2008. |
Who Are the Gitmo Prisoners Released With Sami al-Haj? Rights and Liberties: The release of al-Jazeera cameraman Sami al-Haj last week made headlines. But few have mentioned the others prisoners freed from Guantánamo. By Andy Worthington, Andy Worthington's Blog. May 9, 2008. |
NYC's Staggering Arrest Rate for Pot Achieved By Police Deception and Scams DrugReporter: New study says New York's cannabis crackdown is both racist and fraudulent -- and that more have been arrested under Bloomberg than Giuliani. By Steven Wishnia, AlterNet. May 9, 2008. |