Civil Liberties  
comments_image Comments

Bradley Manning: A Totalitarian Show Trial of State Secrecy

The US government's suppression of all accountability and transparency in prosecuting the WikiLeaks suspect is totalitarian.

Continued from previous page


This is a clear violation of the law, but it will likely take burdensome litigation to rectify this lack of transparency. The  US supreme court has insisted that criminal trials must be public, and the fourth circuit, where this court martial is occurring, has ruled that the first amendment right of access to criminal trials includes the right to the documents in such trials.

The greater issue at hand is why this process should be necessary at all. As circuit judge Damon Keith famously wrote in  Detroit Free Press v Ashcroft, "Democracies die behind closed doors." Yet it is evident from the many layers of secrecy around Manning's arrest, imprisonment and prosecution that the government shows no sign of relinquishing its claimed powers to obscure rightfully transparent judicial proceedings. The doors appear to be tightly shut.

Unless we challenge the growing culture of secrecy within our government, and counter the ever-increasing, reflexive claims of "national security" by claiming our own constitutional rights, we risk finding those doors shut indefinitely.


Michael Ratner is president emeritus of the Center for Constitutional Rights.

See more stories tagged with: